> Our second identification strategy, introduced by Troesken (2006) and Clay et al. (2014), exploits the fact that more lead particulate will leach into water with low pH levels. If lead exposure has a causal effect on homicide, more acidic water should be correlated with higher homicide rates only in cities that used lead water pipes.
So there's more causal evidence than appears in the Mother Jones article. The two references for their "identification strategy" don't seem particularly well-cited though. [1][2]
[1] http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/REST_a_00396
[2] https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/great-lead-water-pipe-disaste...
[1] http://scholar.harvard.edu/files/jfeigenbaum/files/feigenbau...
I don't have time to check out the article this week, but will soon.
An important concern in a cross-sectional study such as ours is that the cities that installed lead pipes in the nineteenth century might have differed from the cities that did not in unobserved ways that were correlated with their homicide rates. Based on available data on the characteristics of the cities in our sample, we find little evidence that the cities that used lead pipes differed in observable ways from the cities that did not. Although larger cities, denser cities, and cities with comparatively low rates of home ownership were more likely to have used lead pipes, so were better-educated cities. High-homicide southern cities, meanwhile, were less likely to have used lead pipes. When we predict whether cities used lead pipes using all covariates, the only difference that remains statistically significant is the city population.
Using the Integrated Public Use Microdata Series (IPUMS) sample of the 1900 census, we calculate several city-level covariates that could be correlated with both lead pipe use and crime.17 These include each city’s population, population density, home ownership rate, and literacy rate, the share of each city’s population composed of African Americans, foreign-born residents, and single men aged 18 to 40, and the share of each city’s employed population working in manufacturing. We also create covariates for cities’ latitude and longitude...
> I don't have time to check out the article this week, but will soon.
Maybe reading first before accusing them of bad science is a good idea?
Paper's here: http://scholar.harvard.edu/files/jfeigenbaum/files/feigenbau...
The real kicker is that lead pipes combined with acidic water have a higher effect than lead pipes combined with basic water.
We've seen massive drops on the level of violent crime in the US (and beyond) over the last twenty or thirty years. And the attribution of that drop has huge ramifications. Should we double down on three-strikes laws, or can the drop be attributed to environmental factors like ambient lead levels due to leader gasoline?
What I see here is increased evidence for the lead poisoning hypothesis. We know that lead poisoning causes violent behavior; the evidence is indicating that elevated crime rates may be due to undiagnosed poisoning.
The task of making causal claims is a difficult one, and not one to be made lightly. The literature is replete with examples of this going terribly wrong, even with perceived physical justifications. See
[0]: tylervigen.com
[1]: http://nerdsonwallstreet.typepad.com/my_weblog/files/datamin...
[2]: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/16/reinhart-rogoff-aus...
[3]: http://www.economist.com/node/5246700