News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by deanCommie on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:13AM (#11619831)
> fewer working mothers can find child care, fewer laborers to mow your lawn, fewer nurses, fewer teachers, etc.

First of all, even if the people in positions like this were only working for sustenance and UBI provides it for them, it doesn't mean some wouldn't want to continue working to make even MORE money. UBI is a baseline, not welfare. If previously a lawn mowing job was only enough for rent and food, maybe now with UBI it'd be enough for rent, food, and the occasional dinner and a movie. Ain't nothing wrong with that.

But you're right, at least some people would definitely completely exit the work force. Well, that just means the salaries of the rest would go up. Simple economics. Does that mean that some working families can no longer afford to pay a new immigrant bottom dollar to mow their lawn and instead have to pitch in themselves? Maybe so. Is that so bad.

Okay, you say, but what about those working mothers that are barely making enough money to be able to afford the most basic child care while they make their income? Good news - UBI also helps THEM too so either they no longer need to work if all they're doing is getting by to keep a roof over the child's head, or they have enough extra to pay for the increase in child care.

I'm not saying "don't worry about, it'll all sort itself out". This is a very complex policy with millions of consequences to our societies - intended and unintended. A lot of research must be done, and also experimentation. But to say that with UBI everyone would be worse off is ridiculous bordering on propagandistic.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by bane on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:29AM (#11619936)
Your arguments are interesting, but they hold only in systems with artificial inflation controls. UBI increases the amount of money in the economy, which has the same effect as simply printing more, thus the value (scarcity) of the money decreases. A poor mother without UBI will be a poor mother with UBI because costs will simply go up, something you acknowledge.

As costs for services go up, costs of products go up as well. For example, if I'm in the beer business, and the cost for me to bottle a single beer is $.10 per bottle on my assembly line. If labor costs increase under UBI to double that ($.20/per bottle) (because cheap labor is now harder to find), I must increase my sale price by at least the same or go out of business.

Now somebody buying my beer has to pay $.60 more per six-pack, potentially wiping out that fraction of new income UBI was providing them.

The government could come in and say "the price of beer may not increase at all" and set some kind of price control. So now I need to cut $.60 of cost somewhere else in my product.

But wait, it gets worse!

Bottling isn't the only cost for me to make and sell my beer.

- Grain harvest is more expensive - increasing my cost

- Transport costs are more expensive - increasing my cost

- Blank bottles are more expensive - increasing my cost

- Brewing is more expensive - increasing my cost

and so on...

So to prevent inflation I have to cut costs everywhere else. Cheaper glass, worse grain quality, worse brewing methods, worse water supply, and so on. If I can't balance the cost equation I simply go out of business, decreasing the supply of products in the economy and increasing unemployment.

In effect, nobody gets paid more because everybody gets paid more, which drives up prices, which is the definition of inflation. If inflation is artificially capped by price controls, then product quality either goes down, or I go out of business.

It's basic economics.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by jhall1468 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:51AM (#11620115)
Your entire theory is based on the idea that the labor market will decrease AND it will decrease so substantially that all markets will have to increase prices to a 1:1 ratio with the new UBI.

Sounds more like fantasy than economics.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by bane on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:05AM (#11620207)
Why wouldn't labor markets decrease? Isn't that the principle idea floating by UBI advocates entirely throughout this thread?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619722 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619538 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619598 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619476 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11619730

> AND it will decrease so substantially that all markets will have to increase prices to a 1:1 ratio with the new UBI.

No, all money will devalue with the increase in supply and increase in labor costs. That's pretty basic economics.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by jhall1468 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:57AM (#11620663)
> Why wouldn't labor markets decrease? Isn't that the principle idea floating by UBI advocates entirely throughout this thread?

They will, and I never said they wouldn't. The problem with your "theory" is that they are going to decrease at a 1:1 ratio with increase in labor costs from the UBI resulting in an overall "0 gain" from the UBI.

> No, all money will devalue with the increase in supply and increase in labor costs. That's pretty basic economics.

True, but that's not the argument you are making. You are arguing that nobody will be better off because the decrease in available labor will be entirely offset by the increased costs in goods/services based exclusively off of labor losses from the UBI.

That is a nonsensical argument. There is ZERO evidence to support it. The overwhelming likelihood is that the price goods will increase, but no where near enough to offset the UBI. The remaining difference in the economy will come from wealth redistribution.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by bane on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:32AM (#11627590)
> The problem with your "theory" is that they are going to decrease at a 1:1 ratio with increase in labor costs from the UBI

Actually, I never said 1:1 ratio with UBI. I just claimed the labor markets would decrease and monetary supply would increase.

> True, but that's not the argument you are making.

No, that's exactly and precisely the argument I'm making. I'm not an opponent of UBI for wishy washy wealth redistribution reasons, but because of the lousy labor markets it would create and the inflation it would create.

The models for what would happen under UBI are not clear, but there are not positive economic models under a UBI scheme by major economists.

UBI proponents have failed to provide any model whatsoever and fall back on vague handwaivy feelings that seem to always only show extremely positive outcomes with no possible negatives and a reliance on magic automation technology that doesn't exist.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by jhall1468 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:58PM (#11633204)
> Actually, I never said 1:1 ratio with UBI. I just claimed the labor markets would decrease and monetary supply would increase.

But that is what you said:

> In effect, nobody gets paid more because everybody gets paid more, which drives up prices, which is the definition of inflation.

Emphasis is mine. That's a pretty clear indication that they will entirely offset each other.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by mrep on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:07PM (#11625673)
I 100% agree with you, but unfortunately, you're talking to technology people. The amount of ignorance when it comes to economics on HN has led me to almost never even talk about it.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by bernawil on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:12AM (#11621339)
Yeah, same argument raises every time is time to discuss minimum wage.

Fact is, labor is not 100% of the cost.

If UBI makes HALF of the worforce quit -which is not very likely- salaries wouldn't go up 100%. So it's not a 1:1 ratio.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by smaddox on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @10:59AM (#11621232)
UBI would only cause inflation if 1) it is not covered by taxes, 2) production does not increase in proportion, and 3) debt does not decrease in proportion. It is extremely likely that a combination of 1, 2, and 3 will keep inflation in check. Ideally, 3 would dominate, because that would greatly dampen the business cycle (i.e. the boom and bust cycle).

The potential for number 3 is the reason I think UBI is a macroeconomic necessity. Currently, our monetary system is based almost entirely on debt; only if that debt (private+public) grows is there an incentive to invest and further grow the economy. When the country and its citizens reduce their debt load, the currency deflates, which distinctivises investment and growth---a depression. With UBI, we could potentially replace this system with a much more stable and robust one, while simultaneously eliminating poverty and poor working conditions.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by bane on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:41AM (#11627627)
It's currently believed by most economic models that debt would wildly increase in proportion as there's few tax schemes that would tax the wealthy enough (and in the right ways) to make it work. For example, even a WW2 level progressive income tax scheme would not provide enough money because the wealthy have learned how to acquire wealth without it being their personal income.

Capital gains taxes only occur if money is made from investments, and there's lots of wonderful ways to show losses or get around that kind of tax system by reinvesting or working the books over to show losses.

You don't want to tax asset ownership too much, because then you'll be taxing people's stock and bond ownership and their retirement accounts and it produces a disincentive to invest in businesses that would need that money to produce the kind of automation revolution that would make UBI work (your #2). A great many assets also only have value and not intrinsic worth. For example, Donald Trump is on record saying that he believes his personal fortune can vary by billions of dollars on any given day given how he "feels" about his brand image. We all know about VC valuations. Do we tax paper billionaires who are pulling down $100k in real income? How can they possibly pay that?

Consumption taxes have been demonstrated to have an outsized impact on the poor.

and so on.

A notion that "well we'll just close all the tax loopholes to make UBI work" is quite frankly a fantasy.

I agree that UBI would stabilize boom bust cycles, but it's not clear that that's a desired end-state. Boom cycles are often when major innovation happens.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by syrrim on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @09:38AM (#11628202)
Labor should get substantially cheaper though. As it stands, people will only accept a job if it covers all their living expenses. Even if you offer to pay enough for half their bills, they'll keep looking for a job that can pay all their bills. With most of their expenses covered by the government, they would be willing to work for a lot less money than before - assuming they're willing to work at all.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:49AM (#11620580)
I am not sure your argument does not suffer from the lump of labor fallacy. But it's not like there is a coherent definition of inflation, much less a working model for it.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by bane on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:46AM (#11627647)
There's actually very good models for inflation. They're basically the models the entire global macro economy is run on. They about as good as weather models, and sometimes they don't work well, but they're generally pretty good at this point.

e.g. When the Fed raises and lowers rates, it's using inflationary models to inform that decision. With a desired goal of sustainable and controlled minor inflation.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by lifeformed on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:59PM (#11623271)
What if we phase UBI in with increasing automation. Maybe the opposing problems caused by both will cancel each other out?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by bane on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:44AM (#11627639)
Let me know when we have sufficiently advanced AI to complete most of the jobs on "Dirty Jobs" and it might just could work.

An amazing amount of work is not mindless factory work.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by fucking_tragedy on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:06AM (#11620224)
How many bottlers are running on such razor thin margins?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ams6110 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:32PM (#11623991)
All of the ones that operate in a competitive market.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by bane on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:47AM (#11627651)
Why is it the bottler's job to absorb the impact of the UBI out of their profits?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:20AM (#11619875)
But you're right, at least some people would definitely completely exit the work force. Well, that just means the salaries of the rest would go up. Simple economics. Does that mean that some working families can no longer afford to pay a new immigrant bottom dollar to mow their lawn and instead have to pitch in themselves? Maybe so. Is that so bad.

Yes, it's bad because now we are all poorer. We have fewer goods and services to go around. The fact that salaries (paper) go up doesn't change this fact.

Okay, you say, but what about those working mothers that are barely making enough money to be able to afford the most basic child care...

I'm referring to highly productive women who should be designing self driving cars, automating business processes, and other such valuable things. Instead they are stuck at home changing diapers.

We, as a society, lose the value of their output.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by pjc50 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:36AM (#11619985)
If someone's that highly productive they'll still be able to earn enough that going out to work would make economic sense. Or they could have the fathers change the diapers.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:47AM (#11620072)
If someone's that highly productive they'll still be able to earn enough that going out to work would make economic sense.

This is absolutely true in a free market with no labor distortions (BI, tax, etc). However, we already live in a world with distortions (taxes, welfare, regulations) that drive a wedge between economically optimal and actual choices. How would adding an even bigger wedge help?

Also, due to women's sexual choices, most likely the father is also highly productive. So your "fathers change the diapers" is not really a viable solution - it just means you lose his output rather than hers.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Al-Khwarizmi on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:20AM (#11620332)
Actually I can't imagine anything closer to the "free market" utopia than a labor market with basic income.

The current market is not free because people are forced to offer their services if they don't want to starve. That's a huge distortion that you would remove with basic income.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by wooter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:09PM (#11623797)
you really don't understand what a free market is then. i would suggest any econ 101 book
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by CWuestefeld on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:00PM (#11621797)
I don't think it's even true without market distortions. The whole point of BI is to give people without adequate income some means to support themselves. In other words, it changes the compensation to our hypothetical woman from $0 to $X,000.

At the margin this will certainly cause people to drop out of the workforce. Heck, as I get closer to having enough assets saved to be able to require, I'd probably choose the pull the trigger on that decision sooner.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by IanCal on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @02:25AM (#11626586)
However on the other side it should be easier to remove the welfare cliffs that exist in current systems. In the UK there are points where the marginal tax rate is iirc ~75%. In the US there are points where you end up with less money if you work more.

So we may be removing other large disincentives at the same time.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by maxerickson on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:01AM (#11620183)
I wonder how big of a basic income you could pay out while keeping the distortion from the basic income about the same size as the distortion from the replaced programs.

Later: Which is not intended as more than hand-wavy thinking out loud. Regardless of the impact, a basic income is a political pipe dream in the US. More immediate improvements in quality of life might come from better aligning incentives in the healthcare system and fixing cliffs in existing programs.