It's also worth noting that GDP missed things before that were a lot more important than clock cycles.
In 1800 in the US about, say 1/3 of children died before they got to 5. This wasn't captured in GDP. But it's a far bigger deal to watch children die than to play games on a faster computer.
Years of healthy life also shot up, mostly prior to 1950 in the developed world. How much is it worth to see your grandchildren grow up because you live longer and healthier and children don't die as much?
This all comes from the fantastic book 'The Rise and Fall of American Growth' by Robert Gordon. It might be worth checking out for you. It goes on about what GDP doesn't measure but still uses it to show that productivity isn't rising like it used to and shows the implications of that.
For what it's worth, I too cannot think of anything better. And good points about all the other things not captured by GDP.
But given that GDP is a terrible measure of productivity, shouldn't the result be: We don't know how to measure productivity on a nation scale so let's stop pretending that GDP meaningfully measures it?
Thanks for the book recommendation. For anyone else who's interested in checking it out I found chapter 1 available here: http://press.princeton.edu/titles/10544.html
"This would be a useful measure for steel and cement production. I'm not sure how well it would measure retail sales.""
This is what one Chinese official uses to get a better sense of the economy rather than relying on massaged numbers. It's still far from perfect obviously, but I find it interesting.
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-economy-wikileaks-id...
I am from Norway I spent a lot of time reading American news and some of the big differences I notice is that while we in Norway pretty much never talk about GDP and economic growth in public, it is a very central theme in the US. It doesn't mean economics isn't discussed, it is simply different aspects of it. competitiveness, unemployment, salaries is discussed a lot as well as how money should most effectively be used on welfare programs.
I am not saying one thing is better than the other. E.g. in Norway there is probably not enough focus on how value is created. But at least the economic debate feels broader.
Solitaire?
Guess which memories are the better ones now?
I see a problem arising from Maslow's hierarchy. You can't eat Pong or an Xbox. They're both entertainment. Not fundamental needs. Security, shelter, food, clothing, are fudamental. You can't build the pyramid from the top down.
But to use a computer analogy: 40 years ago, $100 got you the home version of pong (a primitive computer game) -- today the same inflation-adjusted money would get you something mind blowing.
Whoever produced today's game is in some sense a million times more productive than the creators of pong (as brilliant as those developers were for the time).
As far as I can see, GDP or cost is not the correct measure of productivity. Trying to connect GDP with productivity is like linking stock market performance to the outcome of the Super Bowl -- there might be a relation but it's very very very remote and tenuous.