News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by nkurz on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:26PM (#11583706)
I appreciated this description of the difference between American and Swedish tax preparation by some who files both:

Our US federal and state forms tax forms were more than 30 pages long last year, downloaded completely blank. During the two weeks we'll spend in Wisconsin this summer, our main job will be to get our taxes done.

I'll wade through stacks of bank and credit card records line by line, documenting all professional income beyond our wages and scanning for every possible business or charitable deduction. Once this is done, we — like the majority of US taxpayers — will hire a tax professional who charges us $500 to review and co-sign our work.

Tax-preparation services cost American taxpayers more than $32 billion per year. My wife, Betty, and I each have a PhD, but that's not enough to understand IRS instructions. Finally, with a great sigh of relief, our marriage still intact, we'll sign the forms and send them to the IRS.

Of course, despite our great efforts, we don't know whether the IRS is going to be happy or not. We might get audited and have to dig up all this stuff again, because the government has three years to check and revise our returns.

In Sweden, the four-page tax form comes in the mail already filled out. On a Saturday morning, Betty and I take our coffee to the couch and review the forms. Seeing they look reasonable, as they always do, we "sign" with a text from our phones. In 15 minutes we are done. We don't have to hire a tax consultant, and we avoid fights about whether a print cartridge bought at the drugstore is a business expense or not.

http://www.vox.com/2016/4/8/11380356/swedish-taxes-love

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by ubernostrum on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:55PM (#11585264)
To be completely fair, most Americans can fill out either the 1040A or 1040EZ, which are short (the 1040A is two pages, the 1040EZ is one page). And while they don't come pre-filled, these forms are extremely simple ("look at the form your employer gave you; fill in the value from this box"-type instructions).

The complexity doesn't kick in unless you hit higher income brackets, need to declare income from a business you run, or want to itemize rather than take the standard deduction.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by matt_wulfeck on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @09:57PM (#11586114)
With Health care requirements even that is becoming harder. Besides, if it's so easy why doesn't the government just do it automatically for you?
Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by ubernostrum on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @10:36PM (#11586243)
The usual explanation cited is lobbying by tax-preparation companies to prevent moves which would cut their business. Also, on the short form there's just a box you check to say "I had health insurance all year".
Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by Spooky23 on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @05:52PM (#11584872)
I'm not a fan of income tax, but this is a bizarre quote.

I don't think that the Swedes track his ink consumption -- nobody forced the guy to deduct his print cartridge expenses.

I have a reasonably complex return. I think it's like 10 pages long if printed. I pay about $30 for software and spend 2-3 hours, unless I've had a year with an unusual volume of capital gains/losses or some weird delay in getting partnership forms.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:59PM (#11585293)
Presumably the idea is Swedish taxes are simpler, but also reasonably fair, such that how many ink cartridges you bought doesn't matter.

Like itemizing vs the standard deduction in the USA.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by rayiner on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:34PM (#11585475)
Is it fair? If I'm running a business, money I spend on consumables is not income--it's a cost of generating revenue. Why shouldn't I be able to deduct it?
Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @11:19PM (#11586365)
Perhaps your tax system gives you a standard deduction for your business. Perhaps it scales with the size of the business. Who knows, but itemizing isn't the only way.
Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by TheCoelacanth on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:52AM (#11589762)
But the whole concept of business expenses being deductible is just another set of special cases in the tax code. Why does a business not have to pay taxes on the money that it spends to maintain its existence but a person does? Why is one way for an individual person to generate income a business but another way for an individual person to generate income not a business?
Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by harryh on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:05PM (#11589855)
Taxing revenues instead of profits would privilege high margin businesses over low margin ones which would implicitly mean that customers would pay a much higher tax rate on their groceries than on an iPhone.

Literally no one thinks that would be a good idea.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by TheCoelacanth on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:14PM (#11589910)
I wasn't saying that businesses should be taxed on their revenues. I was asking why natural persons are taxed on their revenue.
Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by rayiner on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:27PM (#11590925)
The orthodox explanation is that with individuals, it is very difficult to distinguish between consumption and expenses incurred for the purposes of producing income. A business entity gets to deduct everything necessary to its upkeep because it exists solely for the purpose of producing income. A person, on the other hand, does not. Some part of what you spend on housing is attributable to your need to be near work, etc, but you have an interest in securing shelter for reasons that have nothing to do with your work.

As a practical matter, individuals do mostly get to offset the costs of producing income. Individuals who own houses effectively get to deduct the cost of housing through the mortgage interest deduction. Individuals who don't own their own house probably don't itemize either, and get the standard deduction. At $12,000 for a family, it probably a reasonable proxy for the component of living expenses attributable to the need to work to produce income.

There are some obvious gaps, child care being the main one, which is almost entirely attributable to working rather than consumptive.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by Zigurd on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:41AM (#11595303)
In theory, things like EITC and progressive rates should account for the fact that low income people spend all their income on living, while high-income people accumulate capital that they can invest and create more income. Also, in theory, this approach is less intrusive than asking people to account for their spending and try to find which spending is actually a "cost" the way it would be for a business, and what it some frippery that should (for some definition of "should") be taxed.
Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by westward on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @10:05PM (#11586140)
Ugh.

What kind of business person waits until their personal taxes are due to find their expenses? This should be done quarterly if not monthly. Use a separate account for business expenses. Hire a bookkeeper.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by SilasX on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @04:44PM (#11584371)
In fairness, that's a lot of information that Americans would consider private, going out through the mail in clearly marked envelopes. They can only be so casual about it in Sweden because they also have the social practice of being less secretive about how much they make.

With that said, if we could nail down the authentication process, we could do here (and should). It wouldn't improve everyone's situation -- e.g. if you have a lot of income from hard-to-track sources -- but for most people it would be a godsend.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by cortesoft on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @05:58PM (#11584915)
W-2s are usually sent in the mail currently, which have all the stuff you would want to keep private. I have never heard anyone complain that W-2s in the mail are dangerous.

In fact, what extra information would be on this pre-filled form that isn't already being sent via mail? Bank statements, retirement statements, pretty much all financial info is sent in the mail every day.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by enraged_camel on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @11:47PM (#11586457)
>>W-2s are usually sent in the mail currently, which have all the stuff you would want to keep private. I have never heard anyone complain that W-2s in the mail are dangerous.

That's because opening someone else's mail is a federal felony. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1708

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by tormeh on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @04:58PM (#11584499)
Alternatively, you could do it over the internet. Not totally unprecedented that ;)

As a Norwegian, I think sending a text is a little too much work. Here, silence is a confirmation in itself. That said, if you have foreign bank accounts or own foreign shares then you still have to do your taxes here too. I think they should get an information sharing agreement with other governments in place to get rid of that. Should be doable within the EU at least.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by icebraining on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @05:06PM (#11584569)
Don't you have to submit them by mail anyway?

By the way, in Portugal we download a cross-platform Java app that fetches the data over HTTPS and lets you fix it (if needed) and submit. Of course, that has its own problems, so paper submissions are still allowed.

Re:One Regulation Is Painless – A Million of Them Hurt by cortesoft on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @05:56PM (#11584903)
Most people file online these days, and no forms are sent.

However, many people still send in their forms by mail.