Our US federal and state forms tax forms were more than 30 pages long last year, downloaded completely blank. During the two weeks we'll spend in Wisconsin this summer, our main job will be to get our taxes done.
I'll wade through stacks of bank and credit card records line by line, documenting all professional income beyond our wages and scanning for every possible business or charitable deduction. Once this is done, we — like the majority of US taxpayers — will hire a tax professional who charges us $500 to review and co-sign our work.
Tax-preparation services cost American taxpayers more than $32 billion per year. My wife, Betty, and I each have a PhD, but that's not enough to understand IRS instructions. Finally, with a great sigh of relief, our marriage still intact, we'll sign the forms and send them to the IRS.
Of course, despite our great efforts, we don't know whether the IRS is going to be happy or not. We might get audited and have to dig up all this stuff again, because the government has three years to check and revise our returns.
In Sweden, the four-page tax form comes in the mail already filled out. On a Saturday morning, Betty and I take our coffee to the couch and review the forms. Seeing they look reasonable, as they always do, we "sign" with a text from our phones. In 15 minutes we are done. We don't have to hire a tax consultant, and we avoid fights about whether a print cartridge bought at the drugstore is a business expense or not.
The complexity doesn't kick in unless you hit higher income brackets, need to declare income from a business you run, or want to itemize rather than take the standard deduction.
I don't think that the Swedes track his ink consumption -- nobody forced the guy to deduct his print cartridge expenses.
I have a reasonably complex return. I think it's like 10 pages long if printed. I pay about $30 for software and spend 2-3 hours, unless I've had a year with an unusual volume of capital gains/losses or some weird delay in getting partnership forms.
Like itemizing vs the standard deduction in the USA.
Literally no one thinks that would be a good idea.
As a practical matter, individuals do mostly get to offset the costs of producing income. Individuals who own houses effectively get to deduct the cost of housing through the mortgage interest deduction. Individuals who don't own their own house probably don't itemize either, and get the standard deduction. At $12,000 for a family, it probably a reasonable proxy for the component of living expenses attributable to the need to work to produce income.
There are some obvious gaps, child care being the main one, which is almost entirely attributable to working rather than consumptive.
What kind of business person waits until their personal taxes are due to find their expenses? This should be done quarterly if not monthly. Use a separate account for business expenses. Hire a bookkeeper.
With that said, if we could nail down the authentication process, we could do here (and should). It wouldn't improve everyone's situation -- e.g. if you have a lot of income from hard-to-track sources -- but for most people it would be a godsend.
In fact, what extra information would be on this pre-filled form that isn't already being sent via mail? Bank statements, retirement statements, pretty much all financial info is sent in the mail every day.
That's because opening someone else's mail is a federal felony. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1708
As a Norwegian, I think sending a text is a little too much work. Here, silence is a confirmation in itself. That said, if you have foreign bank accounts or own foreign shares then you still have to do your taxes here too. I think they should get an information sharing agreement with other governments in place to get rid of that. Should be doable within the EU at least.
By the way, in Portugal we download a cross-platform Java app that fetches the data over HTTPS and lets you fix it (if needed) and submit. Of course, that has its own problems, so paper submissions are still allowed.
However, many people still send in their forms by mail.
Initially, every time a soy farmer support bill died due to a sunset time it could be a media issue. Some big bills will continue to die or be renewed amid a media frenzy; however, our capacity for sensation is limited. Many bills would die quietly. A delightful side effect could be the generation of enough actual news to keep the media busy reporting on useful topics.
A maximum word length or similar requirement sounds good; however, it might not be practical. If you prevented disparate pieces of legislation from being voted on as a single law, a limit on length might work and promote transparency.
But, beyond that, I'd like to see the law be self-repairing. There's a legal concept that goes back to the Romans that ignorance isn't a valid defense. Maybe it worked well back then, but not when the legal code expands as it does in modern democratic countries. The law should be a manageable size that is largely understood and agreed to by everyone. In that vein, I've always wanted a built in system to 'garbage collect' laws that were dated or misunderstood. In a simple implementation, a government department would poll the citizen body for understanding or agreement with a law. If the polling doesn't reach a threshold, then the law is purged.
If they spend more than about ten minutes on the whole exercise I'd be shocked.
Doesn't make the length boundary sharp, but still provides a limit of sorts.
Less restrictive than the one in Gulliver's Travels!
edit: whoops someone already said this
That should simply not be allowed. It's the legislative equivalent of handing out an inspection sticker without actually inspecting the car.
a) high (enough) rates, and
b) taxation of business income (where you must allow deduction of legit business expenses like inventory)
This spawns sort of an arms race where businesses try to classify consumption as a "business expense" so they can deduct it, and the tax authority has to respond with ever-longer lists of "no you can't do that".
One naive scheme might be for the boss to go around and say "hey, what would you spend your next $50 on" and then buy it, classify it as a business expense, and silently give it to them. Then the worker doesn't show up as having that income, but the company has the expense to deduct. Now think about the regulatory apparatus necessary to prevent that, and any clever variant, from happening. (It's also why fringe benefits were so lavish for high earners in the high-tax 50s.)
The higher the rate, the more activity is diverted into this (socially wasteful) activity. Do you want high-IQ people designing self-driving cars or outsmarting the tax code?
Can't do tariffs, those are bad for trade and bad for the economy. Consumption tax is hard because it encourages people not to spend money, which is bad for the economy. Income tax is bad because it makes income (and thus hard work and productivity to the economy) less valuable. Overall, income tax is something that works with some pitfalls, and better solutions are actually surprisingly hard. In the end taxes are necessary but difficult to do right.
But the bigger problem is that even if a simpler and less distortionary tax system were adopted, governments if permitted to will just gradually add all the other kinds of taxes on top, purporting to need to in this modern world.
Tell that to the oodles of lawyers and accountants managing Irish subsidiaries at Apple and Google. There is literally nothing with a better ROI than pushing papers around to save tens of billions.
This is actually fairly cheap and straightforward for a multi national to pull off. But, that's just the tip of the iceberg. Eventually you get into things that impact day to day operations for ever more marginal savings.
But the IRS has no data feed to tell them what I did for rental property (schedule E), my side business (schedule C), my charitable deductions (schedule A), nor other schedule A items, nor gift tax return information, nor many other cases that arise from tax law complexity.
You could possibly calculate my "most-pessimal" tax liability automatically.
At the moment they are trying to harmonize income tax and National Insurance (which is not entirely unlike income tax (especially because it all goes into the same pot), but it has exemptions for various groups which income tax does not (e.g. seniors collecting their pensions). So any change will invariably throw some group under the bus, which is why it's politically hard to do.)
Both with taxes and regulations, it's death by a thousand cuts. If you try to fix it, you'll hear "but soy farmers need tax breaks" and "but workers need to have good office chairs". Individually, each claim sounds reasonable. Collectively, it's a mess.
I sometimes fantasize of ways to limit this. Eg, have all laws sunset, so we have to prioritize renewing the most important. Or set absolute size limits on areas of regulation - like a one-page tax code (with specified font and margins). But likely none of it would work, humans being so good at exploiting systems for personal gain.