News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by kstenerud on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:28AM (#11555635)
That's a bit of a silly thought experiment.

If faced with a symmetric foe that has launched a nuclear holocaust upon my country, it would be absolutely essential to retaliate in kind so as to ensure that they could not mount a second assault and kill even more people. If I were president, I would not hesitate.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by ekianjo on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:54AM (#11555779)
> If faced with a symmetric foe that has launched a nuclear holocaust upon my country, it would be absolutely essential to retaliate in kind so as to ensure that they could not mount a second assault and kill even more people. If I were president, I would not hesitate.

OK, and it's the end of the world as we know it. Like, Game Over, the survivors are back to the Stone Age and the civilization can start from scratch with 99% less people. Sounds like a sound decision you'd make.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by jerf on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:03AM (#11555818)
This is well-trodden ground, though perhaps long enough ago that younger people have never heard it. A lot of stuff that sounds really sweet and nice and moral turns into nightmares if you play it out in the real world. Advertising to the world that you won't strike back even if you are wiped out is, over the long term, an invitation to be wiped out. Of course if you want to signal your morality to certain types by valuing your own people at zero that may sound better than striking back, but you're still in the end advocating for millions of deaths, whether you meant to or not. If nothing else, allow me to appeal to your own naked self-interest in pointing out you'd be one of them.

It is ironic, but by taking a strong "We will strike back" stance, you decrease the chances of ever having to strike.

On the flip side, some of the well-trod ground is now out of date, too. Arguments about how maybe we could try non-proliferation instead become irrelevant as nuclear weapons become relatively speaking easier and easier to acquire due to advancing and dispersing technological sophistication.

Anyhow, upshot, if you're serious about thinking through the issues this turns out to be a really challenging stage to get up and morally preen at people on. It's very easy to end up advocating a strategy that kills billions of people while preening. It may be unpleasant to you, but you do in fact have to think. Hard. With neither rose-tinted glasses nor excessive cynicism. The easy answers don't work. The sweet answers don't work.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by csallen on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:21AM (#11555901)
Parent was merely saying that you shouldn't actually launch missiles back, not that you shouldn't advertise that you're willing to do so. Deterrence is no longer relevant once missiles are in the air.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by shasta on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:54AM (#11556042)
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by Retric on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:22AM (#11555912)
Assuming accurate information. If people had followed true Tit for Tat we would have all died due to false alarms.

The correct action may be to back down from a full scale launch while saying that you will respond in kind.

PS: South Africa actually gave up nuclear weapons. Which is the extreme end of not shooting back scale.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by vidarh on Saturday April 23, 2016 @01:08PM (#11556369)
During Able Archer 83, the Soviet Union allegedly got close to launching a first strike against the US because they feared an imminent US attack because of what they picked up of the exercise.

Advertising to the world that you have a firm policy against nuclear attacks other than in very limited, clearly defined scenarios puts you at risk of the other side decides it is ok to strike you for their own gains, but it also protects you against potential adversaries who have no designs on you but who you might inadvertently scare.

Able Archer 83, and the realisation that it appears to have genuinely terrified the Soviet leadership is often credited with changing Reagans course and making him determined to sit down with the Soviet leadership.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by danbruc on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:44PM (#11556251)
I think the position you are presenting is wrong. You are essentially saying that it is irresponsible for a country to not have nuclear weapons because that invites other countries to wipe it out, after all there is no difference between not having nuclear weapons and convincingly asserting that you will not use them for retaliation strikes.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by kstenerud on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:16AM (#11555870)
Precisely. Tit-for-tat has always been the most effective strategy.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by Retric on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:21AM (#11555903)
Assuming accurate information. It's far less useful in the real world.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by notahacker on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:53AM (#11556039)
Indeed given that in the real world a false alarm is far more likely than an actual inbound missile strike, maintaining a convincing illusion of willingness to carry out tit-for-tat" is a far better survival strategy than one which involves actually launching the nukes. If you're too late to retaliate, it doesn't really make much difference to your civilians' survival rates but it certainly does if you fire prematurely when the enemy wasn't* in the process of escalating the conflict
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by vidarh on Saturday April 23, 2016 @01:26PM (#11556449)
Even that is dangerous, because it means that an adversary who think they have inadvertently crossed a line will have every reason to go all out, because they'll expect a full scale retaliation.

Indicating a willingness to use nuclear weapons at all may also make an adversary more willing to believe you may deviate from policy and strike first, which again may lead them to believe an all out first strike is safer than holding back (e.g. I've mentioned Able Archer 83, where the Soviet leadership allegedly considered a first strike because they thought the US was planning one)

Part of the problem is that neither you nor the other side knows whether your opponent will stick to any given strategy, nor if they will behave rationally.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by dogma1138 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:34AM (#11555657)
What if the first strike wasn't a disablement strike but an exterminating one?

If your foe launches a strike that would kill 99% of the population of your country would you retaliate to ensure same level of destruction?

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by fanzhang on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:41AM (#11555694)
Let's put aside the likelihood of a exterminating strike (where the enemy achieves near-total destruction before you can even think about launching).

Now suppose you do also decide to retaliate to ensure 99% destruction to your foe. Would your foe's knowledge of that change whether your foe even tries an eliminating strike in the first place?

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by dogma1138 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:19AM (#11555888)
You have 2 first strike options. 1) that will target your opponents nuclear capabilities (ensuring that no 2nd strike is possible) 2) that will target everything including population centers to achieve maximum destruction.

In both of these scenarios if you are attacked first (early warning) your only option is to attack their centers of population to either prevent an all out invasion or to retaliate.

This is exactly why MAD sort of works, because it actually ensures mutual destruction of not only the nuclear and military capabilities but also of all national and human infrastructure as the only possible answer to even a limited nuclear first strike is "fire zee missiles!". Or to put it in a more structured manner there is virtually no room for proportionate response when it comes to a nuclear attack. When there was it was the biggest threat to "MAD" since it more or less would ensure that any side that gains sufficient advantage would be prone to launching a first strike. Because of this very fact the nuclear arms treaties between the USA and then the USSR limited fixed launch site while promoting mobile launcher and nuclear missile subs as much as possible as the guaranteed 2nd strike capability of both nations was what MAD was actually built upon.

But MAD is not without it's faults, heck so far i think Norway out all countries was the one that brought us closest to total nuclear war. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegian_rocket_incident

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by hga on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:23AM (#11555913)
The biggest defect of MAD was that the Soviets correctly thought it was profoundly immoral and never accepted it, and, well, once Robert Strange McNamara, he of the oh so wise initial prosecution of the Vietnam War, pushed it through, the Soviet leaders didn't have much trouble painting us as immoral because we were.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by varjag on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:57AM (#11556058)
They did accept it and played along, even if doing the usual lip service on militarist capitalist imperialists.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by GunboatDiplomat on Saturday April 23, 2016 @04:49PM (#11557366)
MAD is not immoral. There's nothing immoral about preventing nuclear war. I also find it hard to believe that the Soviets, of all people would dare claim the moral high ground.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by hga on Saturday April 23, 2016 @05:04PM (#11557415)
The Soviets attack our military establishment, and our moral response is to burn Soviet children to death in their beds?

Yeah, right. And the Soviets most certainly took advantage of this moral error, for as you note, they're hard pressed to do so with a straight face otherwise.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by GunboatDiplomat on Saturday April 23, 2016 @05:15PM (#11557447)
Yes. That is how you prevent nuclear war. By being prepared to do terrible things that you hope to never do. Only by being ready to commit atrocities can you hope to not have atrocities committed at all.

There is no moral error here, only moral reality.

Also, it's not like our military establishment is separate from our civilian population centers. The SF bay area, New York, San Diego, among others, would be devastated in a counter-force first strike, no matter how precise.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by Ao7bei3s on Saturday April 23, 2016 @11:31AM (#11555949)
> i think Norway out all countries was the one that brought us closest to total nuclear war. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegian_rocket_incident

The article says "a team of Norwegian and American scientists". I am not surprised.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by PakG1 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:44AM (#11555716)
Well, this is basically the question upon which the MAD (Mutually Assured Destruction) doctrine hinged itself.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by js8 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:54AM (#11555774)
That's the problem with the MAD doctrine, see. It assumes your opponent is rational. But if he is rational, then perhaps you can agree on not having nuclear weapons in the first place.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by GunboatDiplomat on Saturday April 23, 2016 @04:51PM (#11557372)
Rationality is bounded by reality. It might be better if no one had nukes. But, if no one had nukes, what prevents a conventional war from breaking out on the scale of WWII or even larger? Nothing. Nuclear weapons are the greatest creator of peace in history.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by js8 on Sunday April 24, 2016 @03:56AM (#11558934)
> what prevents a conventional war from breaking out on the scale of WWII or even larger?

The same MAD principle? The knowledge that after 6 years, everybody will be exhausted by fighting, and what for exactly? Hitler wasn't rational, and maybe he would use nuclear weapons. Actors in the WWI thought it would last couple months, again, weren't exactly rational about what they are getting into.

It's not nuclear weapons what creates peace. It's the rational ability of humans to (eventually) see the hopelessness of destruction, that creates peace.

Whether the destruction comes from nuclear or normal weapons is irrelevant, however conventional weapons at least give us chance to have that rationalization later. In other words, stronger weapons require more responsible humans, not cause them to be more responsible.

The MAD doctrine is just a false rationalization of irrational fear. It is not a rational principle, it is principle adopted so that humans can feel better having nuclear weapons, although having them objectively makes the world a more dangerous place. If people indeed followed MAD doctrine as rigorously as MAD doctrine itself assumes, WWI and WWII would never have happened either.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by venomsnake on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:40AM (#11555691)
No. I will aim for 100%. 1% with enough technology will still rebuild.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by archgoon on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:25PM (#11556173)
> retaliate in kind so as to ensure that they could not mount a second assault and kill even more people

The bigger issue is that they are more likely to initiate the strike if they know about this protocol and believe it will reduce the likelihood of a counter strike.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by vidarh on Saturday April 23, 2016 @01:55PM (#11556578)
Or they might be less inclined to strike first to pre-empt a strike. I've mentioned Able Archer 83 elsewhere: The Soviets appears to have gotten close to strike first because they believe the US was preparing to strike. Knowledge of a policy that appeared to indicate a distinct goal of deterring the President from launching a strike might have made the Soviets less nervous.

A while afterwards Reagan wrote that he long thought that the Soviet leadership, like the Americans, did not believe a US first strike was a serious possibility. But he eventually learned that this was a flawed assumption: The Soviet leadership saw the US as a possible - even likely - aggressor, and interpreted US actions accordingly. In that context, posturing was incredibly dangerous, and this realisation made him change tack and become determined to sit down and talk to them.

Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by thu on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:44PM (#11556248)
For those in this thread that speculate about hitting this or this before reacting: nuclear weapons take a certain time to reach a target and retaliation would happen before _any_ nuclear explosion occurs.
Re:The Heart of Deterrence (2012) by hga on Saturday April 23, 2016 @01:06PM (#11556353)
In the MAD era, there was the theory that we (the US) had a sufficiently robust retaliatory infrastructure that we could ride out the first wave of a first strike and only launch, or in the case of bombers give the PAL codes to arm the warheads to the crews, after the first nuclear explosions happened and were sufficiently confirmed. Launch on Warning was always recognized as an inherently dangerous doctrine.