And in the absence of proof our court system is biased in favor of defendants (that's not exactly relevant to negotiations over this fine however since the EPA only has to prove that they broke regulations).
I'd guess that NOx can be a meaningful hazard in certain places with lots of cars and/or special geography (LA County for example) but almost nowhere else. I can't prove that hypothesis of course.
The guess is just for fun. Do you disagree that the effect of NOx probably varies greatly between LA County and any place without the same amount of traffic or special geography? You're welcome to make your own guess for the purpose of discussion.
You should be disappointed if the fine is unjust, GM not withstanding. That's not to say that I don't agree that the GM case was egregious, but let's agree that someone screwed up/had palms greased/plain didn't do their job, and leave GM out of the decision on what to do with VW. Because if we agree that the GM case was handled poorly, then we shouldn't use it as a basis for further cases. Last serial murder got off, so I'll be disappointed if this guy who hacked up ten people gets life?
Set their symbolic heads upon pikes, let them stand as an example to others that may follow. Whether that's a hefty fine, or a buy-back, I don't really know.
The basic idea behind the regulation is that if every manufacturer didn't follow it, there would be a lot more pollution and many more people could be harmed.
Whether or not we agree with that prediction is irrelevant. The people elected representatives who made this law, granting regulatory authority, at least in part to prevent it from happening. They have the authority to collect the fine. How many people were actually harmed has nothing to do with it (at least directly).
It makes more sense to be upset at how GM (partly owned by the government at the time) got off so easy.
While some might claim "pollution" from the TDIs is killing people the link is not direct and negligible in the big picture when you look at volumes. Frankly I think VW should be blocked from selling any TDI they have in stock, new or used and buy back them all. But a separate fine beyond that? Again, not if exceeds the fine giving GM which by the way also topped Toyota's fine for unintended acceleration which could not even be proven.