News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by dogma1138 on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @07:56PM (#11538664)
They don't need Atom, as far as mobile devices go they are bringing Core to ARM's power envelope. You can get Core M CPU's today with 3W power envelope with considerable performance lead over most ARM SOC's.

Intel has made a bet that it would take just as much time for ARM to reach x86 level of performance as it would take Intel to bring x86 power consumption down to SOC levels. Now Intel can play on both sides with their low power x86 parts, Xeon-D with upto 16 cores and Core-M in 2c/4t configuration.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by coldtea on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:11AM (#11539641)
>Now Intel can play on both sides with their low power x86 parts, Xeon-D with upto 16 cores and Core-M in 2c/4t configuration.

There's only one little problem: the market has settled on ARM and doesn't care anymore.

So how are they gonna play those "both sides" again?

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by Nullabillity on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:42AM (#11540267)
Not really, the market has settled on CPU-independent bytecode. I've got a x86 tablet, and you don't notice it at all, other than the Intel logo on the back. As long as there is an ART port it could be MIPS and still have pretty much the same compatibility.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by sirkneeland on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:53AM (#11540304)
While this is mostly true, it is just untrue enough to cause trouble for a non-negligible number of apps.

The Intel Houdini software used to make Android on X86 possible is a marvel of engineering but it is not perfect. I worked for a company that made an Android tablet around an Intel chip instead of ARM. We were hit with a great number of user reports of certain apps crashing, overheating, or simply refusing to run in the first place. We verified in QA that these apps would work just fine on ARM tablets with the same Android version and similar specs.

To be fair to Intel, they were very good to work with and really did (and do) want to make it work. I have no doubt they will. Eventually.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by flamedoge on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:23AM (#11540406)
... Compiler.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by szatkus on Thursday April 21, 2016 @06:53AM (#11540955)
AFAIK if app uses NDK it has to have compiled code for every architecture. If developer didn't make version for x86 you won't run it.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by pjmlp on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:56AM (#11540527)
Yes, all major mobile OSes have followed mainframes and have settled in CPU-independent bytecode, for most part, as long as C or C++ code isn't used.

Currently iOS is the only one that also supports having C and C++ as bytecode (LLVM one).

Android and WP, only support it for Java, RenderScript and .NET languages.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by merb on Thursday April 21, 2016 @02:56AM (#11540134)
Actually the market for mobile yes. But on servers it will actually take a long time to replace ARM. So it's actually a win for customers when these two are rivals since we get cheaper servers or lower tdp on servers and cheaper mobile devices.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by kyrra on Thursday April 21, 2016 @10:03AM (#11542188)
Server side, there is an initiative to get rid of Intel as well[0][1] with a PowerPC based chip. It'll be interesting to see if it ends up working, but I think everyone wants to get away from Intel's high prices.

[0] https://cloudplatform.googleblog.com/2016/04/Google-and-Rack...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenPOWER_Foundation

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by mtgx on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:00AM (#11540328)
First off, those "3W Core CPUs" are a scam and a dud. They will overheat and throttle.

Second, they cost WAYYYY more than a mobile chip. They cost more than an iPhone's ENTIRE BOM, or about 10x more than what Apple pays for its chips.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by creshal on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:11AM (#11540365)
> First off, those "3W Core CPUs" are a scam and a dud. They will overheat and throttle.

Throttling has been a problem on high-end Androids for years now.

> Second, they cost WAYYYY more than a mobile chip.

That's the real issue – the margins in the mobile market are ridiculously slim, and there is no x86 monopoly Intel can abuse to lock in vendors and customers. So cheap ARMs it is.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by agumonkey on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:30AM (#11539877)
Single core Atom (2012 Z2480 on Razr I) at 2GHz has significant perceived performance advantage even compared to processors released after. It's way snappier than the Moto G quadcore ARM cpu from 2013. I don't know how much battery life is sacrificed for this though. But I'd be very eager to try a Core M smartphone, since Atom has always been the low-end of Intel cpu architecture. That said I lost track of Intel marketing, maybe Core M is just a rebranding of the same or similar arch.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by mtgx on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:09AM (#11540359)
There's a very large difference between a Cortex-A7 in a Moto G and a Cortex-A57 or Cortex a72. The latter are about 3x faster.

Atom has barely increased its single-threaded performance from like 300 pts in Passmark to about 540 right now (in Pentiums, in PCs, which cost $160 a pop).

Intel is not competitive on price. That's why Atom didn't pan out in mobile. They tried to do it by heavily subsidizing its high-end mobile chips, which typically cost close to $50, to compete against a $15 mid-range Qualcomm chip. That's why some people were "impressed" by what an Asus Zenfone could do for instance, for its mid-range price overall.

And if Intel can't compete with Atom on price, then there's NO CHANCE it will ever compete with Core M in mobile. The only reason it even exists in so called "tablets" that go for $1000 right now, is because Microsoft failed to make a good case for ARM-based Windows machines with its poor app support. But that will always remain a niche.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by creshal on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:14AM (#11540375)
> And if Intel can't compete with Atom on price, then there's NO CHANCE it will ever compete with Core M in mobile. The only reason it even exists in so called "tablets" that go for $1000 right now, is because Microsoft failed to make a good case for ARM-based Windows machines with its poor app support. But that will always remain a niche.

And outside the Surface those aren't selling well either.

(IMO rightfully so, the Venue 11 Pro is the worst device I've seen in years – hypothetical hardware dickwaving aside, even a $50 OEM Android tablet has better UX and usability than Windows 10 without mouse/keyboard.)

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by B1FF_PSUVM on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:27AM (#11540631)
Asus T-100 TA series work pretty well as Windows 8/10 tablets.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by creshal on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:46AM (#11540685)
Yes, because they ship a keyboard and touchpad. But you wouldn't buy the Asus ZenPad instead and try to use Windows 8/10 solely with touchscreen, would you?

It's the complete opposite of how iOS/Android tablets operate.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by dogma1138 on Thursday April 21, 2016 @11:31AM (#11542892)
Core M is the "same" CPU as their server and desktop CPU's. It's not based on the Atom line. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skylake_(microarchitecture)
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by Grazester on Thursday April 21, 2016 @07:01AM (#11541002)
That moto G had great battery life I could tell you.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by rasz_pl on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @08:52PM (#11538891)
That core M will be $1xx compared to $1x-2x for ARM chips.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by dogma1138 on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @08:59PM (#11538916)
That's economy of scale I don't see a reason for it to be more expensive the Apple A8x had a higher transistor count than an 8 core Core i7 Haswell-E CPU. Also I'm pretty sure that high end SOC's that end up in iPhones, Galaxy S's and the like cost more like the Core-M than the 20$ or so you would pay for a MediaTek SOC.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by bravo22 on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:54PM (#11539330)
I've design with Intel Atoms and ARM chips. Atoms are very bloated and require a lot of external support to get up and running. Intel's firmware/boot support is atrocious. They still have PC OEM's in mind. ARM chips on the other hand are much easier/cheaper to design for. The SoC is better integrated and targeted towards a low overall BOM cost. Core M is worse than Atom.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by mtgx on Thursday April 21, 2016 @03:59AM (#11540323)
Not true at all. If Intel could do that:

1) they wouldn't have replaced its Core-based Celerons and Pentiums with Atoms to increase profits - and they sell those for $110-$160

2) they wouldn't have licensed Atom IP to Rockchip and other low-end chip makers, essentially pursuing an ARM-like IP-revenue model (for which they would've made peanuts and didn't pan out anyway).

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by dogma1138 on Thursday April 21, 2016 @07:19AM (#11541098)
Intel Celerons even the embedded ones are currently based on Skylake. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_Celeron_micropro...

Intel licenses allot of things they still have ARM licenses and probably even Power PC ones.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by rasz_pl on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @09:48PM (#11539098)
mediatek socs are actually $4(this is a price from 2014, when Intel had to match that $4 price while subsidizing Atoms), and that includes pmic. $20 is a price for a hieng quad core chips.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by tdsamardzhiev on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @11:45PM (#11539540)
The recommended customer prices for older Core M's is listed as $281
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by bnolsen on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:45PM (#11543969)
so intel is going to start selling CORE processors for 1-5usd apiece?