News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by brianpgordon on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @03:31PM (#11529517)
You will never, ever beat the market by making smart trades.

Get real- you're a beginner reading investopedia. Active funds employ hundreds or thousands of people who work more than full-time to support an operation of systematically studying investment opportunities and exploiting inside information to beat the market, and even they don't beat the market.

Put your money in a diversified portfolio of index funds and leave it alone. Making targeted trades costs money and will do no better than index funds anyway.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by dwc on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @03:53PM (#11529703)
Agreed, with one exception: when you as an individual have fairly deep knowledge about something and spot a market opportunity based on that knowledge, you might be able to correctly judge whether you can take advantage of it.

I've done this several times and made good money. Two times I approximately doubled my money over the course of several months. Yeah, not day trading but buying and waiting for the market to figure out what I already knew. The thing about that is, it only happens when it happens. Most of the time my money is sitting in index funds quietly getting solid but undramatic returns, and I don't have to pay much attention at all.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by brianpgordon on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @04:07PM (#11529841)
I admit that's a possibility, but be very careful and very limited in your domain. Stupid shit is wildly successful all of the time, and brilliant offerings fail all of the time.

The market still hasn't figured out that SharePoint sucks and enterprise lock-in from vendors like Oracle is predatory and bad for business. Amazing achievements like NeXT and the Amiga never made money. Gimmicks like the Amazon Echo and the Apple Watch ship millions of units. It's really hard to tell what the market will do.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by dandelany on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @06:55PM (#11531131)
Or as Keynes put it, "The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent."
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by dwc on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @07:13PM (#11531219)
I'm as bad at those kind of picks as the next person. I wasted time and money figuring that out, though.

The only time I buy in is when the market overreacts to some bit of bad news or something and I see the undervaluation. Of a strong, established company.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by lazyhummingbird on Friday April 22, 2016 @12:01PM (#11550138)
> Gimmicks like the Amazon Echo

Ah, the first mass-market ambient computer is a gimmick. And somehow I still want one.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by philjr on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @03:56PM (#11529733)
I agree with this, once you are aware (or think of) what you're doing as closer to gambling than "investing" ie. use money you're prepared to lose as opposed to the kids college fund
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by bbcbasic on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @07:01PM (#11531161)
I own shares given to me in a company I used to work for that has now floated. I am keeping the shares, which is effectively a pick but I know it is well run and very good at executing value acquisitions
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by aws_ls on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @12:10PM (#11535429)
If those shares are a small percentage of the net worth, then it can be Okay to keep them as is. But if its the case of them being the majority of your net worth, then its very dangerous.

I look at it from a downside vs upside perspective. I want a lower probability of a downside, which will cause pain to me. For that I am okay, to trade it with moderate upside e.g. index based funds.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by baccredited on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @03:56PM (#11529730)
>You will never, ever beat the market by making smart trades.

Agree. Just buy ticker VOO and get on with your life. Even Warren Buffet has said to buy 90% VOO and 10% bonds. And you will never be as good at this as Warren Buffett.

That said, I take 10% of my net worth and put it in a 'casino fund' where I can buy whatever I want. Startups, peer to peer nonsense, individual stocks, and so on.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by brianpgordon on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @05:08PM (#11530447)
VOO isn't exposed to international developed and emerging markets. If you have the appetite for risk, you may want to take significant positions in VEA and VWO.
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by baccredited on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @09:41AM (#11534273)
Point taken. But most big S&P 500 companies are heavily international. Look at Apple's last quarter:

'International sales accounted for 66 percent of the quarter’s revenue.'

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by log0 on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @08:56PM (#11531609)
Curious question to all you investment experts. The SPY/VOO guys did not improve since 2015 and even now. Proponents of the SPY/VOO are based on the 2008... which has been rising until 2015. So how is investing into index fund ETFs still relevant today? Just earn on dividends?
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by dsacco on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @04:05PM (#11529819)
You're making a lot of absolute statements that are demonstrably false.

>> You will never, ever beat the market by making smart trades.

How do you define "smart" trades? There are people and firms which consistently beat the S&P 500 after fees and trade commissions on a timeline of 20+ years without using insider trading. What would this be called, other than "smart" trading?

>> Active funds employ hundreds or thousands of people who work more than full-time to support an operation of systematically studying investment opportunities and exploiting inside information to beat the market, and even they don't beat the market.

Most do not, but the fact that most peoples' companies don't IPO doesn't mean it's impossible. Firms like RenTec consistently beat the market, and they have less than 300 employees total.

>> Making targeted trades costs money and will do no better than index funds anyway.

I agree with advice advocating index funds for beginners, but it's not fair to an individual's potential aspirations to claim that active trading is simply ineffective. It's extremely difficult, but that's wildly different from being ineffective.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by the_gastropod on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @05:06PM (#11530434)
>There are people and firms which consistently beat the S&P 500 after fees and trade commissions on a timeline of 20+ years without using insider trading. What would this be called, other than "smart" trading?

Mind naming a few? I'm unfamiliar with any firms that consistently can beat the S&P 500, much less for 20+ consecutive years. This could, of course, be called "luck". Given the number of investors, some will inevitably beat the index. The point is that it's impossible to predict, ahead of time, who that will be.

> I agree with advice advocating index funds for beginners, but it's not fair to an individual's potential aspirations to claim that active trading is simply ineffective. It's extremely difficult, but that's wildly different from being ineffective.

Again, even amongst professional investors, who have decades of experience, and spend 80+ hours per week doing this, very few are able to consistently beat the index.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by dharmon on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @05:27PM (#11530584)
Off the top of my head: Baupost Group (Seth Klarman), Greenlight (David Einhorn), Gotham (Howard Marks), Renaissance (Jim Simons), Oaktree (Joel Greenblatt), Graham & Newman (Benjamin Graham), Magellan (Peter Lynch), Pabrai (Mohnish Pabrai), ...

Most of these are closed and closely held. Keeping your capital base small with long-term-minded investors (e.g., "family" money) is a huge leg up.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by Spooky23 on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @09:44PM (#11531763)
There is a difference between an institutional investor or advisors with fiduciary responsibility and a free agent. Professionals have consequences for fucking up beyond the money lost. So they always parrot whatever advice will not get them sued.

Warren Buffet has been quoted elsewhere in this story recommending index funds. But, funny enough, his own behavior is 180 degrees from that.

I always find these threads amusing. The average commenter treat stocks as some sort of black magic that requires a mystical priesthood of professionals to touch. But nobody says "OMG, buying a house is a crazy investment, buy a REIT ETF and rent!"

Stocks are like any other commodity. My wife is an aggressive shopper -- she understands the marketing cycles and can get 6 months of Tide for $0.50 on the dollar. With some work, you can get deals on equites.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by JamesBarney on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @12:01AM (#11532174)
There are very specific reasons a house is a better investment than an REIT.

1. Taxes - There are tax breaks to owning 2. Property Management - For an REIT you pay a property manager. If you own, no need to manage your property. Free +1.2% return on asset! 3. Loans are heavily subsidized by the government, REITs cannot get 30 year loans at 3-4% interest. 4. Occupancy - You live here. Occupancy rate 100% so take an +.6% to returns!

If the government stopped 1 and 3, technology completely automated 2, and leases were 4 years long. Then no one would recommend buying your own house as an investment.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by throwawaymsft on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @01:50PM (#11536281)
How about Berkshire Hathaway itself?

http://www.businessinsider.com/warren-buffett-berkshire-hath...

You can think he got lucky 50 years in a row (1/2^50, what're the odds? Does it invalidate the null hypothesis?) or that investing involves an element of skill.

It's impossible to predict who will win a poker tournament but winning games is a skill, and certain players consistently do better than others. Sure, I wouldn't advocate the average person try to make money with poker, but it's disingenuous to pretend it's a black art.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by baccredited on Thursday April 21, 2016 @08:55AM (#11541704)
>How about Berkshire Hathaway itself?

Warren Buffett to heirs: Put my estate in index funds http://www.marketwatch.com/story/warren-buffett-to-heirs-put...

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by throwawaymsft on Thursday April 21, 2016 @11:47AM (#11543017)
It's good advice for most. I'm sure poker champions want their money invested similarly (instead of having their children attempt to grow their wealth by following their footsteps). But we shouldn't deny that investing is a skill.
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by jimcsharp on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @06:14PM (#11530918)
It's investment hyperbole. Like when a gun enthusiast tells you "your gun is always loaded"
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by acconrad on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @06:07PM (#11530875)
But you can beat the market by doing a few things:

1. Invest, don't trade.

That means buying companies in large quantities when they're at a bargain, and holding for a long time (think years or even decades). This will keep your costs and commissions down.

2. Look where others won't.

As Ben Graham and Seth Klarman have pointed out in their books, you want to look for companies that no one else is looking at for a variety of reasons:

* They've hit rock bottom in the last 1/3/5 years. If people are selling, you should look at buying.

* They're special situations. Is the stock going through the process of bankruptcy, merger/acquisition, spin-off? This is the basis for books like Margin of Safety and You Can Be a Stock Market Genius.

* They're complicated. Distressed debt, credit-default swaps, and other alternative investments to access by the public can be profitable if one is willing to put in the time (years) and dedication to analysis, but I generally wouldn't recommend it

* They don't fit the fund's portfolio / low institutional ownership. Active funds may employ thousands of people to work full-time on investments that suit their fund. This generally means large cap companies because the funds have to utilize so much capital that they can't waste it on institutional ownership of small and micro cap companies. Everyone and their mom has done research analysis on Google, few spend their time on Sanderson Farms, which only broke into mid-cap territory for the first time in over a year, and has since risen by over 10% after being massively undervalued.

If you are in a diversified basket of 15-30 value-oriented stocks with at least some focus on quality, you can stand to beat the market over the very long term.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by wdr1 on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @06:27PM (#11530986)
Any support evidence?
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by Spooky23 on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @09:33PM (#11531725)
I've been investing like this since high school and that portfolio consistently beats the performance of the Boglehead style 401k & 457 plans that I am stuck with from my employers.

I use a narrower field of 5-8 companies, a reasonable cash portfolio and occasionally municipal bonds. It's like anything else, if you are motivated, it's quite possible to find undervalued assets with good potential.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by acconrad on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @11:16PM (#11532030)
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by jamez1 on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @08:11PM (#11531474)
There's a lot of folklore about how active funds consistently under perform passive funds, but that's only in aggregate.

If you aggregate a few active funds they will be a good proxy for the index, which after fees, will have less returns than buying the index.

There is dependence in active fund returns, a good fund will consistently be a good fund, and a bad fund will consistently be a bad. You also have selection bias, because the best funds do not tell the public they exist, while the worst prey on public money to exist.

From the public's point of view, of course active funds are all bad. From those in active fund management we gain nothing from correcting them.

Journalists don't care for the truth and we don't care for their falsehoods.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by JamesBarney on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @11:51PM (#11532146)
If this was said of companies people could say "Don't buy an index. That's just an average of good companies and bad companies. Instead just buy good companies they will consistently outperform the index."

The problem is in the details. Identifying good companies is very very hard. Identifying good funds is much much harder. By the time there is a large amount of evidence that a fund is a good fund it is either A. closed to new funds

or

B. Drowning in so much cash that there is no hope of delivering it's historical returns.(its much easier to return 12% on 10 million than 10 billion)

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by js4 on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @12:15AM (#11532214)
Don't listen to this. You can beat the market --there are plenty of people that do.

The thing about investing is that it takes experience and you unfortunately only get that by investing.

One thing you don't want to do is trade. You want to act like an owner. That means find companies and get involved for the long term.

Also remember there is no free money out there. Investing takes a lot of work and often times doesn't pay off for years.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by JamesBarney on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @12:13AM (#11532209)
One thing to note is that even if you are one of the few who has a gift for investing, you need to be investing a lot of money to break even.

Assume

1. it takes an extra 500 hours a year to research and buy good investments.

2. you make $60 an hour

3. all your hard work delivers a respectable alpha of 3%(3% better returns than than the market)

You need to be investing approximately 1 million dollars to break even.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by potatosareok on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @12:43AM (#11532313)
I don't understand this at all. In what world is there an infinite amount of hours I can work? Most people work 40 hours a week and if they work more don't get paid extra (barring overtime but do you work somewhere where you can just work 100 hours a week and put in 60 hours of overtime because you felt like it?).

Between weekends and just general downtime in week (I spend time watching netflix and browsing the internet and I read books in my commute) I have at least 30 hours free a week. If you're into stocks as much as I'm into wasting time entertaining myself then why not.

Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by pilom on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @03:56PM (#11529735)
Well, you might do better trading for short periods of time, but you probably won't beat stock index funds over a 25+ year period.
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by dominotw on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @03:53PM (#11529696)
Why does an investor have to beat the market. If the companies you invested in are getting richer and making useful products, investors should get rich too. Its not zero sum.
Re:Ask HN: How did you learn about stocks and the market? by brianpgordon on Tuesday April 19, 2016 @05:11PM (#11530465)
That's what you're trying to do by poring over investment books and investopedia. Anyone can track the market by buying the S&P 500 or an index fund. All of the complicated investment advice comes when you try to do better than the index.