The difference is that conspiracy theorists and others will fear that an asteroid would be used to destroy a major city.
But we've got to learn how to deflect asteroids anyhow, in order to save the Earth. So some international body formed out of NASA should start crashing them into the Moon, or into parking orbit around the Moon.
We can then offer mining rights to any company which is simply able to get up there. Presto. There'll be a lunar base within decades!
Who is "we" in this case?
Yeah there will be some nice absurd law fights before the wars.
I wonder if generally law applies to earth only.
Also See: Heinlein's "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress", which features space colonists seeking to break away from Earth dropping rocks on us to persuade us to let them go.
None of the space treaties were written with the anticipation of actual profits in mind.
You could make the same argument about Antarctica, but [actually I don't have a good argument why we haven't exploited the resources there and would be interested to hear one. Just political suicide? Too expensive?]
When it's feasible to make money space mining absolutely all of these things will be rewritten, probably with a heavy dose of realpolitik.
The treaty doesn't really protect Antarctica from anything other than nuclear tests, in the future if countries want to actually develop claims it can and will be revisited. That said there isn't much interest in this atm mostly because we do not have the technology and we aren't that desperate heck even if the largest oil field in the would would've been found there no one atm would try to develop it as it would most likely be financially non-viable but nothing would really stop anyone from doing so.
Outerspace on the other hand defines the universe as the heritage of all mankind where no one can claim any stake, which will shortly be changed probably to something along the side of what was used to be used in the US during expansion, where claims would be made by private individuals and corporations rather than countries.
Penguins are cute.
We ought to leave somewhere untouched, so let's pick the poles, because they're too bloody cold, and all.
/s
Also yes if there were space penguins: no chance
It was a rational assumption. There was good data suggesting we could expect a significant drop in launch cost. Then the two nations who could do this decided instead to spend all their money on nuclear weapons and conventional military forces as well as proxy conflicts which starved whatever civilian rocket innovations could have or should have happened in the 70s and 80s. They both had classic designs by then that worked well enough and competing on cost per lbs didn't matter to them as it wasn't incentivized by anyone.
Additionally, the '67 Outer Space Treaty was specifically written with open-ended provisions to allow for the commercial exploitation of space - at the time, they quite honestly thought that Hilton and Pan Am (yes, 2001 did it) would be operating in space within decades. They even thought so as far back as '58, before man had even been to space. http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20120712-where-is-hiltons-lu...