News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @09:58AM (#11519884)
A shirt that depicts women as objects or objectized women is just plain wrong. I do not care about the celebration.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by Someone1234 on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:10AM (#11519965)
Objectification doesn't really apply to a still image. The whole trope was initially about women in media being the object of the male character's conquest. Essentially the women were turned into nothing more than props.

A t-shirt depicting scantily clad women may be in poor taste and likely isn't professional, but doesn't really contribute to the objectification of women. Women are allowed to be sexualised (just as men are), the line is drawn when women are subjugated to only that role (which, again, we witness in some media, games, movies, TV, rarely books).

You're just moralising right and wrong and then using objectification as some kind of trump card, no matter how little it applies. Men are allowed to wear t-shirts with half naked women on them, it isn't inherently sexist, just tacky and unprofessional (in my opinion).

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ceejayoz on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:31AM (#11520159)
> Objectification doesn't really apply to a still image.

What the what? Care to elaborate on how that works?

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by Someone1234 on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:59AM (#11520396)
> Care to elaborate on how that works?

A fully clothed women in a still image still has no personality, no interactions, no lines, no inherent character. A still image is within itself a prop or an object.

So criticising a still image for objectifying women is inherently both true but also completely redundant. Everything in a still image is static, it is an object, plants, animals, women, men, naked, fully clothed, they're all objects.

The term "objectifying women" (as a negative) originated from turning women into objects or props in situations where they wouldn't otherwise be so. So for example, you take a female character, you remove all of her lines, put her in sexy clothing, then have the male characters stand around and talk about how sexy she is. That's objectification, they've literally turned that women into an object or prop for male character's use.

Calling all sexual images of women "objectification" is simply an overreach. It also doesn't make rational sense when applied to women who couldn't have dialog, personalities, or interactions such as a still image on a t-shirt. It is pretty hard to have ANY women or man on a t-shirt who isn't an object.

You can call it "distasteful" (likely true) or "inappropriate" (again, likely true for work) but you didn't, you called it objectification which it objectively is not.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by stcredzero on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:39AM (#11520762)
There is a problem with only thinking logically about such issues. Humans are messy and not entirely rational creatures. We're constantly seeking dominance over one another and weird emotional games come into this. No one wants to be reduced to an emblem. No one wants to be subject to a stereotype, even a positive one. In the end, we all want to be genuinely related to as people.

Strong signals of dominance, emotion, and sexuality should be experienced consensually. The reason why the "bro" stereotype is so annoying, is the apparent insistence on the others around them to feel or act a certain way. The reason why politics and political discussions are so unpleasant is that dominance instincts are brought to the fore by necessity.

I think a truly consensual society should be without the feeling of witch-hunts. I'm not sure if that's possible for human beings, though. Maybe Mao was right, and "All power comes from the end of a gun." In the end it's all the hegemony of one "tribe" over another.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by sp332 on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:39AM (#11520221)
An image is literally an object. It's not a woman. Objectifying an actual woman would be more clearly immoral. Objectifying a shirt - which he literally, legally owns - is not necessarily a problem.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:26AM (#11520100)
The view that you, as an individual, bring to the world, is exactly what makes the world the way it is. That's why a shirt is a reflection of a reality. Now it is a shirt, tomorrow it is a perfume advertising image. The next day it is a man who thinks that the woman he is married to is his belonging.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by Someone1234 on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:07AM (#11520485)
That's actually the view academics such as philosopher Martha Nussbaum bring to the world.

See their definition of objectification here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Objectification#Definitions

As you can see, doesn't apply. A static t-shirt image of any sort is always an object but never objectification, because it lacks the context it would need to be more.

Objectification was never about naked Vs. clothed. It was about how women are treated and viewed as individuals. It is about autonomy and being more than a 2D prop for male character's use.

You can be naked and still have a great deal of personality, story importance, and be respected by both male characters within the medium and the writers. See Game of Thrones. There is an absolute ton of nudity in that, and yes, there is objectification (e.g. background sex) but the show gets a pass because female leads are given a great deal of importance, autonomy, and respect. They're nobody's props or objects.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:36AM (#11520737)
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by corford on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:04AM (#11519920)
You do realise the shirt was given to him by a female colleague/friend right?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ZeroGravitas on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:11AM (#11519978)
It was a friend, rather than a colleague, that made and gave him the shirt so they may well be unaware of how it would be percieved by his colleagues when worn in this context.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by gherkin0 on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:36AM (#11520195)
> so they may well be unaware of how it would be percieved by his colleagues when worn in this context.

Wasn't the controversy more about how the shirt was perceived by randos on twitter, not by his colleagues?

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ZeroGravitas on Monday April 18, 2016 @01:03PM (#11521405)
Yes, rando astrophysicists on twitter:

https://twitter.com/astrokatie/status/532509765989965824

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by gherkin0 on Monday April 18, 2016 @05:53PM (#11523422)
Was that person his colleague?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ceejayoz on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:11AM (#11519977)
So what?

If a black friend gives me a shirt with the N-word on it, that doesn't mean I should wear it at work.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by corford on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:32AM (#11520161)
Context is key. I haven't followed this shirt brouhaha in any serious depth but I assume that all of his colleagues and management saw him wearing the shirt before he delivered his talk. AFAIK it became a problem afterwards. So, if you (not me) want to equate a shirt with female characters on it to a shirt with the N-word on it then, yes, if the workplace context was right why not wear it at work (e.g. I'm thinking an indie record label or similar environment with black, white, whatever people working together as a tight team and a black friend of a white guy bought him said t-shirt).

Ultimately, it's up to the guy wearing the t-shirt to make a judgement call as to whether doing so would offend or not offend his friends and colleagues. So: context, relationship with everyone else at the place he works at, balanced sensitivity etc.

If he honestly (not deliberately) makes the wrong call, he should apologise and everyone should move on. Work is a place for adults, not children on a lynching party.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by Chris2048 on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:36AM (#11520194)
If you're white, and your black friend gives you a shirt with the N-word on it, they aren't your friend.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ceejayoz on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:38AM (#11520213)
These guys are probably friends.

http://realfunny.net/picture-3097-these-two-friends-wearing-...

They probably don't wear the shirts to work.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:42AM (#11520246)
You do realise that a woman can be wrong about women's rights, right?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by sp332 on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:13AM (#11520532)
This is an under-recognized point. Women can definitely undermine women's interests.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by mooseburger on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:04AM (#11519916)
It's art. The shirt was also made by a woman, for what it's worth.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by vkou on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:24AM (#11520086)
Nude paintings are also art, but if you hang a couple in your office, you'll have a lawsuit waiting to happen.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by mooseburger on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:33AM (#11520170)
Really? I would fight that lawsuit tooth and nail. Neo-puritanism makes my blood boil.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by vkou on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:02AM (#11520434)
That is also one kind of lawsuit where your personal assets will be on the line if you lose.

Regardless of what you think of Puritanism, don't sexualize the workplace.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:27AM (#11520121)
Nabokov's Lolita is also art. Lester the molester is also art. Invalid argument.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday April 18, 2016 @12:41PM (#11521236)
Have you actually read Lolita.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @03:29PM (#11522497)
Yes, I found it quite interesting but deeply disturbing. You can rest assured that I'm not the only one: http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/books/2005/12/lolita_at_5... https://101books.net/2011/12/15/lolita-inside-the-mind-of-a-...
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by sp332 on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:10AM (#11519957)
I don't think you're going to convince anyone by just stating what your view is. Give some reasons or something.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:29AM (#11520135)
I have to give a reasons to why a shirt that depicts naked women is wrong?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by sp332 on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:45AM (#11520281)
Well, yeah. (Also they're not naked.) Heck, there are Bibles that have pictures of naked women in them. Are you saying women aren't allowed to be naked, or no one is allowed to make pictures of them, or they should only be photographs and not fantasies, or what exactly?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ownagefool on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:05AM (#11519922)
Do you find it wrong in general or wrong in a professional setting?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:31AM (#11520155)
In general. Women should not be shown as objects, prices, decoration, etc... It is bad for all the women and puts us the men in a false superior position.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ownagefool on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:45AM (#11520812)
That's interesting. What do you think woman who do this or desire to be viewed like this?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:36AM (#11520200)
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by sp332 on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:16AM (#11520553)
I think brudgers's advice is excellent, and I would encourage you again to take it. I hope this doesn't sound too pushy, it's just a suggestion.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:27AM (#11520669)
It is an excellent advice. Made by someone who writes for a living. However, the comment system is not made to make us all agree about everything. My concern is about the restriction you put in a unconscious way to your opinions when there is dissent. Is this a kind of censorship? A very sofisticate one?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by sp332 on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:51AM (#11520873)
I don't see the point in expressing your opinions on this forum if you don't care whether anyone agrees with you. If you're not interested in connecting with the readers and influencing them, why not just keep it to yourself? What are you accomplishing by posting here?
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @03:32PM (#11522517)
I really do care if the 'audience' agrees with me. What I'm trying to understand is why I have to restrain myself just because I think that I might not be under the most popular line of thought or going to arise some controversy. No one deserves downvoting for expressing its line of thought even if it is an unpopular one. I would never downvote anyone for expressing its beliefs in a proper manner.
[dead]
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by LoSboccacc on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:29AM (#11520141)
there's a precedent with that - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniele_da_Volterra#The_loincl...

and we're headed straight there, again.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by deong on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:48AM (#11520844)
As stated by no less than the supreme court, we all recognize the difference between Michelangelo and Larry Flynt.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by rokhayakebe on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:20AM (#11520053)
You make a good point. There is a lot of art out there about naked men and women and no one cares.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:34AM (#11520181)
This is not about how the art was made some centuries ago. In that time all women had a hard time chosing even their own lives, couples and rights. It is about the current fight and rights.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ainiriand on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:22AM (#11520604)
In a more general note about the downvotes about sexism: https://medium.com/@sh4ka/sexism-and-hacker-news-6678897fccc...
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by collyw on Monday April 18, 2016 @04:57PM (#11523098)
Demonstrates that context is everything.

Do most of the people reading this thread think it is sexist?