News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dharma1 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:40AM (#11495778)
While rental can be above mortgage repayments in the UK (particularly London), 2x is unusually high. It sounds like the mortgage in question is only for a small part of the total value of the flat.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by mollmerx on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:57AM (#11495865)
Particularly in London, houses are overvalued to the extent that rents are comparatively cheap vs. the rest of the country. Rental yields in London are significantly lower than they are in e.g. Manchester.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by Ntrails on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:19AM (#11495987)
Yet you miss the key issue - which is mortgage availability.

I end up where I can afford to buy my own flat and rent it out to someone who is not myself at the rent I am paying and make a profit. But I would not be offered sufficient mortgage to simply own it myself despite the fact that the rent I pay is higher than the mortgage would be (and indeed even accounting for 2% rate rise I'd be fine).

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dan1234 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:44AM (#11495799)
My mortgage is £350/month but the house next door is rented out at £750/month so it does happen, but then I had a reasonable deposit and got a low rate.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by e12e on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:02AM (#11495895)
When did you purchase your house? Because we're talking about people moving into the market. If you managed to buy a house that only costs you 350 GPB/Month for both interest and downpayment, that's great. But is that what it would cost you if you bought your house today? (I'm not saying it'd wouldn't, but it's relevant for the discussion to know for sure).
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dan1234 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:33AM (#11496078)
Bought in 2011 for £90,000. Current Zoopla estimate is £110k
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by sokoloff on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:49AM (#11495819)
I think the best apples-to-apples comparison would be to compare the mortgage payment, property taxes, and insurance calculated as if the full market value of the property was mortgaged. That takes out the variance from deposit variances and purchases made many years ago.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by freshyill on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:35AM (#11496094)
Isn't that how it's usually done? My mortgage payment is somewhere around $2,700/month, but I'm pretty sure that covers insurance and taxes.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by sokoloff on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:11AM (#11496319)
Yes, but I'm talking about something else.

If landlord A puts down 50% of the purchase price and landlord B puts down 20%, their mortgage amounts (and montly cashflows) will be different, but the inherent value proposition to the landlord will be about the same.

Likewise, if someone bought 10 years ago and their value doubled (but their mortgage stayed the same), that property will "appear" more profitable to that landlord than if they sold that rental to another landlord. That's why I think the "property holding costs" should be based on the full, mark-to-market, cost of the property today, and be based on a 100% financing mortgage rate.

There's also a strong argument that we shouldn't include the principal paydown part of the mortgage payment when doing this analysis, as that's a forced-savings (and cashflow) item, not an inherent profitability impact.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by e12e on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:01PM (#11500936)
Ah, but "forced-savings" doesn't work if that means you can't afford to eat. So it's very much relevant to the "young people can't afford to buy a house". True, it's slightly different problem - but it's also (probably) why people are forced to rent, driving up prices for rent vs buying a house/apartment. This also include the saving you need to do before you get a mortgage (which is harder to do if rent prices are inflated...).

It's of course true, that even with a catastrophic collapse in the housing market, the money sunk into the principal are rarely truly lost. At some point the market is likely to recover to the point that it is worth something. If you can afford to wait.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by imtringued on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:06AM (#11496295)
This raw number doesn't tell us very much. We still don't know the length of the mortgage, whether the house is larger or the condition of the building and a whole lot of other variables that I didn't mention.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by lhopki01 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:51AM (#11496634)
Even with a 10% deposit it's still only repayment of 1100 a month.

The point is that rents are higher than mortgages which gives the case of having money means you can save money. And that's before you consider the massive asset you own then.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dharma1 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:13AM (#11497340)
Noticed you said the property value is £275k?

£275k property with £1700/pm rental yield is very, very good.

Average rental yield (before tax) is around 4-6% of property value per year.

Generally speaking though, your point is true of course. Having enough capital to buy a property in London instead of renting (especially if you bought a few years ago) will save you a lot of money in the long run, provided that property prices don't go down between your your buy/sell dates.