News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by lhopki01 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:32AM (#11495731)
All a great and good till you do the math. In the UK you can own a house 2 hours away from work or you can rent a house 3 hours away from work. Rental prices in the UK are well above the rate needed to service a mortgage so if you can get a mortgage it's much cheaper. To give you an idea the 3 bedroom flat I live in has a mortgage repayment of around 800pounds a month but a rental income of 1700pounds a month.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dharma1 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:40AM (#11495778)
While rental can be above mortgage repayments in the UK (particularly London), 2x is unusually high. It sounds like the mortgage in question is only for a small part of the total value of the flat.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by mollmerx on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:57AM (#11495865)
Particularly in London, houses are overvalued to the extent that rents are comparatively cheap vs. the rest of the country. Rental yields in London are significantly lower than they are in e.g. Manchester.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by Ntrails on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:19AM (#11495987)
Yet you miss the key issue - which is mortgage availability.

I end up where I can afford to buy my own flat and rent it out to someone who is not myself at the rent I am paying and make a profit. But I would not be offered sufficient mortgage to simply own it myself despite the fact that the rent I pay is higher than the mortgage would be (and indeed even accounting for 2% rate rise I'd be fine).

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dan1234 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:44AM (#11495799)
My mortgage is £350/month but the house next door is rented out at £750/month so it does happen, but then I had a reasonable deposit and got a low rate.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by e12e on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:02AM (#11495895)
When did you purchase your house? Because we're talking about people moving into the market. If you managed to buy a house that only costs you 350 GPB/Month for both interest and downpayment, that's great. But is that what it would cost you if you bought your house today? (I'm not saying it'd wouldn't, but it's relevant for the discussion to know for sure).
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dan1234 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:33AM (#11496078)
Bought in 2011 for £90,000. Current Zoopla estimate is £110k
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by sokoloff on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:49AM (#11495819)
I think the best apples-to-apples comparison would be to compare the mortgage payment, property taxes, and insurance calculated as if the full market value of the property was mortgaged. That takes out the variance from deposit variances and purchases made many years ago.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by freshyill on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:35AM (#11496094)
Isn't that how it's usually done? My mortgage payment is somewhere around $2,700/month, but I'm pretty sure that covers insurance and taxes.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by sokoloff on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:11AM (#11496319)
Yes, but I'm talking about something else.

If landlord A puts down 50% of the purchase price and landlord B puts down 20%, their mortgage amounts (and montly cashflows) will be different, but the inherent value proposition to the landlord will be about the same.

Likewise, if someone bought 10 years ago and their value doubled (but their mortgage stayed the same), that property will "appear" more profitable to that landlord than if they sold that rental to another landlord. That's why I think the "property holding costs" should be based on the full, mark-to-market, cost of the property today, and be based on a 100% financing mortgage rate.

There's also a strong argument that we shouldn't include the principal paydown part of the mortgage payment when doing this analysis, as that's a forced-savings (and cashflow) item, not an inherent profitability impact.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by e12e on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:01PM (#11500936)
Ah, but "forced-savings" doesn't work if that means you can't afford to eat. So it's very much relevant to the "young people can't afford to buy a house". True, it's slightly different problem - but it's also (probably) why people are forced to rent, driving up prices for rent vs buying a house/apartment. This also include the saving you need to do before you get a mortgage (which is harder to do if rent prices are inflated...).

It's of course true, that even with a catastrophic collapse in the housing market, the money sunk into the principal are rarely truly lost. At some point the market is likely to recover to the point that it is worth something. If you can afford to wait.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by imtringued on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:06AM (#11496295)
This raw number doesn't tell us very much. We still don't know the length of the mortgage, whether the house is larger or the condition of the building and a whole lot of other variables that I didn't mention.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by lhopki01 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:51AM (#11496634)
Even with a 10% deposit it's still only repayment of 1100 a month.

The point is that rents are higher than mortgages which gives the case of having money means you can save money. And that's before you consider the massive asset you own then.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dharma1 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:13AM (#11497340)
Noticed you said the property value is £275k?

£275k property with £1700/pm rental yield is very, very good.

Average rental yield (before tax) is around 4-6% of property value per year.

Generally speaking though, your point is true of course. Having enough capital to buy a property in London instead of renting (especially if you bought a few years ago) will save you a lot of money in the long run, provided that property prices don't go down between your your buy/sell dates.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by e12e on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:59AM (#11495870)
At ~3% interest rate (ie: less than one should plan for in case of change in the economy), a 25 year mortage comes to approx 480 GBP/month per 100K. Are you saying your 1700GPB/month rental property sells for ~200k? Certainly rent should come at a premium to buying (eg: in the example above, down payment isn't considered as an investment -- mostly because you'll need somewhere to live. If you sell your house, were will you live?).

As far as I've been able to figure out in Norway, you'll generally end up paying more (total) per month if buy than if you rent. But like all things in life, if you can afford the monthly total of rent+downpayment, you'll be better off than renting due to the presumed price increase of the house. Worst case, you'll pay it down and live "for free" the rest of your life.

I think it's interesting to look at median yearly wage and house prices. How many years wages does it cost to buy a place to live outright? And as the article states, how can it be more expensive now, than it used to be?

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by lhopki01 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:02AM (#11496743)
Close 275k but with a slightly larger than 10% deposit. 2% interest rate but the point that it is cheaper to pay a mortgage than rent is valid even if interest rates go to 8 or 9%. Also you consider that in a vacuum. What do you think happens if interest rates go up? All the buy-to-let people that require the rental income to pay for the property will also raise their rental rates. There are enough of them that they will move the market.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by e12e on Thursday April 14, 2016 @06:53PM (#11500908)
Certainly sounds like the difference between rental and mortage is much bigger where you live, than here. One obviously need to look at the concrete market one is buing/renting in.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by atwebb on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:49AM (#11495823)
Not untrue in the states either, it's common for the rental price on a house to be 1.5-2x the mortgage payment or more, especially with rates the way they are.

I'm not talking about major, top ten city, I'm not familiar with the pricing there. I'm speaking from experience in 2 "B" tier cities.

Rents in our neighborhood are around 2-2.2x our payment of mortage+insurance+taxes, though we put 20% down so the payment is a little lower. In our previous location it was around 1.5x and rents are rising.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by charlesdm on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:54AM (#11495848)
That's the premium you get for owning property in a B city. Imagine having a portfolio of 50+ properties in Detroit in this day and age. Imagine owning high value property in a city like Detroit - it'll be hard to sell, hence the premium.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by atwebb on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:20AM (#11495995)
I guess so, our current city is redhot property wise so anything is expensive relative to what it was, the other city has a very large portion of renters which lends to the increased cost I'm guessing.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by maxaf on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:39AM (#11495775)
Wow, now that's the major difference from NYC. A mortgage payment for anything decent anywhere in Manhattan is far beyond my current means, yet I afford the rent easily enough. I wonder why the UK is so different? Are landlords simply profiteering off a bad situation?
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by k-mcgrady on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:46AM (#11495808)
>> "I wonder why the UK is so different? Are landlords simply profiteering off a bad situation?"

In my experience landlords tend to buy property and then use renters to pay for their mortgage. And then they add more on top of that so not only is their mortgage being paid but they're earning money too. I know some people for example who are buying a 2 bedroom apartment (they only need a 1 bed) and are renting the second room at a price high enough to cover their mortgage. So basically they're not paying a penny for their accommodation.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by UVB-76 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:46AM (#11495806)
I find the inverse to be strange, i.e. the notion that the rental value of a property should be less than the cost of a mortgage.

Not least because landlords incur overheads over and above those an owner-occupier does.

There is a large 'buy-to-let' industry in the UK, whereby millions have taken out mortgages to buy properties for the sole purpose of renting them out.

The rental income pays the mortgage, and usually provides some profit on top, all while the value of the property itself continues to appreciate.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by awinder on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:09AM (#11495927)
In the US anyways you have favorable tax treatments for interest and property taxes, but rent (of private properties like houses) tends to exceed principle + interest + taxes in many areas. I find that to be fairly weird, because you've essentially got a very low out of pocket expense at that point (or even nearly net positive) in raw money exchanged, yet principle is recoverable on sale and tax deductions offset a portion of property taxes.

Basically if buying a house and renting it out immediately turns a profit, that's a renter-saturated market, and it seems best to be on the non-saturated side of the market

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by dagw on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:54AM (#11496215)
Not least because landlords incur overheads over and above those an owner-occupier does.

But isn't there also an economy of scales argument to be made. If you own dozens of buildings and hundreds of flats, you should be able to keep your pr. flat cost lower than someone who just bought one flat.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by UVB-76 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:04AM (#11496762)
None of the overheads I'm thinking about lend themselves to economies of scale.

I'm talking about things like:

* Admin costs (contracting, etc.)

* New tenant costs (marketing, agency fees, reference checks, credit checks, inventory, etc.)

* Landlords' insurance

* Extra safety checks (e.g. annual gas safety checks)

* Cost of downtime between tenants

* Cost of rectifying wear and tear (cannot recover from tenants)

There's also a difference in terms of maintenance. If I'm an owner-occupier and something breaks, I can live with it for a while, shop around, get a few quotes, and get it fixed at my leisure.

As a landlord, if something goes wrong with one of my properties I have an obligation to repair it as soon as reasonably possible.

Then every now and then you get a tenant who completely trashes a property, causing damage far in excess of any deposit, and which you're unlikely to ever recover.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by gizmo on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:56AM (#11495858)
I think in NYC many real estate buyers are really speculators. They don't buy to live there, but because the prices are expected to go up. With this increased demand the price for houses keeps going up, but the price to rent is based on how many people want to live in NYC. In most areas of the country there is a balance between renters and buyers. People may prefer one or the other, but they will switch to renting or buying to save money. This keeps the market from going out of whack. NYC is different because for investors renting isn't an alternative to buying, hence the mismatch.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by lhopki01 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:55AM (#11496682)
London is an even more extreme example of speculation in the property market. There are no restrictions on foreign ownership. In South Kensington an area of London 1 in 50 homes are designated as long term unoccupied. Buy-to-leave is a well known term in London and it's even a sensible decision. London property appreciates at a rate greater than 10% a year.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by lhopki01 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:58AM (#11496710)
As said in other comments buy-to-let is a massive thing in the UK and in London buy-to-leave is big too. But yes profiteering is a major part too.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by switch007 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:39AM (#11495773)
Which part of the UK can you rent for £1,700 but mortgage for £800? The housing market varies greatly in the UK, e.g. London is an extreme outlier. It's usually only useful to talk about specific locations
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by lhopki01 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:49AM (#11496617)
London is more extreme but it's the case in almost the entire UK that rents are higher than mortgage payments.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by switch007 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @01:43PM (#11498847)
Perhaps so. e.g. in Greater Manchester rent might be £470 for a 2 bed terraced house whereas the mortgage would be about £300-400, depending on interest rate, but a mortgage payment isn't a direct comparison to a rent payment: you need life insurance, buildings insurance, contributions to a repairs fund, service fees if a flat, upfront costs to be amortised over the duration of ownership etc (but those payments are not necessarily the difference).

Also, the set of people who are renting and unable to get a mortgage I imagine is quite large.

Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by sokoloff on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:13PM (#11501627)
What does life insurance have to do with owning a house? Is that required for a mortgage in the UK?
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by collyw on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:48AM (#11496173)
Probably anywhere if you bought the house 15+ years ago.
Re:Why younger people can’t afford a house by seanmcdirmid on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:27AM (#11496455)
Interesting, this is quite the opposite from Beijing. 7500 RMB/ month rent translates to around a 20,000 RMB/month mortgage (not exactly since down payments are much larger). But we are also at peak proper bubble.