"In short, I believe that non-violent methods of conflict resolution provide the only methods for protecting our country against the deadly threats we face in the long run. Military action, with its inevitable consequences to civilian populations, creates and fuels deadly threats, and therefore increases the danger that our country faces."
When the people who need to be brought to justice are in a nation that is friendly to them and entirely unconcerned about world opinion, economic sanctions, and other such tools of international diplomacy, I fail to see what realistic options there are besides violence. I may sound snarky at times, but seriously, if anyone has any realistic and practical ideas, please say so.
That's more what bothers me about Pacifism - being totally unconcerned with the realities of the world. They just say "find a non-violent way to do it" and then leave somebody else to figure out how to do that. I think it only applies in a few limited situations, and in general, pure Pacifism means you will be dominated by anybody who is willing to use violence to achieve their goals.
(He's correct, I think.)
The Human drive to solve conflicts with more conflicts is probably traceable to our evolution. Society has moved much faster than the standard genetic evolutionary feedback loops can deal with.
Unfortunately, this leaves us with situation that people who "follow their instincts" are likely to behave more like chimpanzees than the "ideal human".
Violence leads to the desire to achieve retribution. Those who achieve retribution almost invariably do so through more violence. Catch 22.
Logically, this can be solved in two ways (hopefully there are others, but I can't identify them).
Firstly, the majority (of the world population) recognizes this and agrees to stop violent solutions to problems in favor of mediation and rehabilitation (education, isolation etc.) of those who refuse to to "play by the new rules".
This is unlikely to happen.
Secondly, one side decides to do the Gandhi approach of non-violent civil disobedience, refuses to be part of the violent retribution, and lets the situation unfold.
This also, is unlikely to happen.
Humans have the ability to solve conflicts in many ways. We can compete in games of mental skill (Chess or Go), we can compete in games of physical prowess (Soccer or arm-wrestling), but I've yet to see a real attempt to compete in terms of compassion and understanding.
Until we can debate our differences, decide and agree on who has the best solution for the species as a whole, then we're bound to keep repeating the mistakes of history. Mainly due to looking for the solution in the wrong place.
That's the (admittedly optimistic) point.
Most people who categorically object to violence do so because they categorically object to a worldview that approves or disapproves of tactics by their results.
I think that Paul Verhoven's satire on the very work to which you refer says it all. In it, the military is made to appear to be an elaborate human sacrifice ... cult run on survivor bias, in the service of creating a self-sustaining elite. The justification for slaughtering "bugs" is never supported. The master stroke is that the bugs are inherently disgusting.
Violence has its uses. But institutional violence uses those parts of human behavior that make us ... crazy.
CSPAN 3 has the Fuulbright Vietnam hearings available. They're worth watching.
Heinlein is not always spectacular about following through on the consequences of his ideas.
I'll further note that he does not and cannot argue that the issues are settled satisfactorily.
- Robert Heinlein
This quote stuck with me, possibly due to the force of its presentation rather than its merits.
I thought it would be interesting to present the other side of the debate to HN and open it up to comment. I'm undecided.
Heinlein's viewpoint and the author's viewpoint are polar opposites. Perhaps the truth is somewhere in the middle.