There's a reason why in the US, overwhelmingly contracts are read against the one who drafts them for example. There's an inherent power imbalance here. That's where laws and courts come into balance things out.
[1] To point, it's not uncommon for California-based tech companies to insert non-compete clauses into their contracts, even though they cannot possibly be enforced unless there is some special compensation.
Why is this on the employers, exactly?
"However, the awareness of a legal obligation is established, not through each party's subjective understanding of the terms, but on "objective indicators," based on what each party said and did"
Your T&C examples are adhesion contracts, subject to a different set of rules.
Here, you have an opportunity to bargain like any other party.
Of course, its usually slapped in front of them AFTER they've accepted a job. Having accepted a straightforward offer in good faith, the terms are then altered, slightly.
Perhaps it should be more clearly stated in a written offer that must be considered before accepting.
And perhaps that's why its better to not allow these. It makes it easier for employer and employees to deal with each other. And it makes companies compete more on merit, rather than manipulation.
It doesn't hurt the companies ability to compete with each other, as long as they all live under the same rules.
Of course the market runs because of rules we set in the first place.
Not enforcing some contracts is less intervention, not more.
I'm not saying it wouldn't happen, I just don't remember such an ancap society existing in the first place.
Within the context of the U.S.'s current economic/legal system, I think it's more in accordance with common usage to think of the existence of private property and contract law as being the basic substrate on which everything else happens, including more specific government action. For example, to continue with the property analogy, we typically think of eminent domain as a state "taking" property, even in cases where a person's "ownership" of a property depends on the government in the first place (someone owns a deed to land they don't actively reside on or use, but since it's legally recognized as property, the government choosing to build something on it is legally recognized as a taking of property). But point taken that this whole contract/property system is itself created and enforced by the state, not some kind of naturally occurring phenomenon.
This may have been common usage through the 1920s, and it may be common usage for people who wish the New Deal never happened. But even then it would be a stretch. This country's legal history is a lot more nuanced than that. What you articulate is probably best described as a minority vision today.
An alternate, more radical view would be that, since the state had created contract law, property law, etc. in the first place, many New Deal laws weren't even regulations or restrictions on anything, merely the state choosing to withdraw some kinds of legal arrangements that it had previously created. But I don't think any New Deal courts were nearly that radical. They instead agreed that they were regulations or restrictions, but held that those regulations/restrictions were within the government's powers to enact, most often justifying them as within the power the Constitution gives Congress to regulate interstate commerce.
By the same reasoning, if I sue you for defamation for calling me a lamebrained chucklehead, courts refuse to entertain the suit because the government won't restrict free speech. You're entitled to express your opinion, and the government won't assist me in suppressing your speech.
In many states, the government is happy to assist employers in restricting job-hopping.
I take your point that this government activity has its immediate catalyst in private actions in the free market, and that's different in important ways from other government activity. But still.
Also, in order for a contract to be enforceable, there must be an exchange of value. I would agree with the validity of a non-compete clause if there was specific compensation tied to that. For example, "we'll give you $50,000 after you leave the company if you don't compete with us for a year." But tacking it onto an employment agreement, no.
inalienable: incapable of being alienated, surrendered,
or transferred <inalienable rights> [1]
What the parent said sounds like pretty much the dictionary definition of inalienable to me?You can be denied of your life, your liberty, and/or your happiness. They cannot however be transferred to another person.
Your material possessions -- real estate, chattel property, intellectual property -- can be.
Again: the nature of inalienable rights is intrinsic, not protected by law.
You'll find that meaning supported in the definition you've provided.
(There's a whole 'nother discussion of rights-based arguments generally I won't get into, though I find the question somewhat problematic.)
End of the day, it's "freedom fighters" vs "insurgents".
Other states don't restrict job-hopping, they just stand by and don't interfere as the free market ends up having the effect of restricting job-hopping. Employees end up signing restrictive employment contracts, and states don't prohibit them from doing so. California has made a conscious decision that the economy overall works better if some kinds of private-sector contracts are prohibited, so it's restricted what can go into an employment contract to a greater degree than other states have (every state has some restrictions, e.g. in the modern era you can't sell yourself into indentured servitude, but some states are more restrictive than others).