But a consumption tax which is collected by the merchants provides the government with the least information. All they learn is that Walmart reported selling $8,500,000 worth of auto parts this quarter, not who your employer is or what specific customers bought what specific products.
Since most intellectual and "brand" property must also be registered, I am sure the same can apply to that.
> As much as possible, we should be taxing consumption, not income, savings, and growth.
These two desires are in complete opposition to each other, because the poor by necessity spend a much larger proportion of their income than the rich. What you are proposing is impossible.
It's actually very simple. You collect a fixed percentage as a consumption tax (e.g. 33%) and then send everyone a tax refund in a fixed dollar amount (e.g. $10,000/year). Then everybody who spends less than $30K/year pays no or negative tax and for everyone spending more than that their effective tax rate starts at 0% at $30K/year and increases progressively to 33% the more they spend.
This also has the useful consequence of not requiring minimum wage laws or social assistance programs because the refund exceeding the tax paid takes care of that at the low end.
Plus now you're relying on businesses to collect your revenue instead of the IRS, and so you're going to see rampant sales tax evasion.
You mean like all the social assistance programs that sending everyone a $10,000 check every year would make redundant?
Your argument seems to be that if the government wants to spend more money then they have to set a higher tax rate. Of course they do. How does that in any way dispute that a system of flat consumption tax + fixed refund is inherently progressive?
> Plus now you're relying on businesses to collect your revenue instead of the IRS, and so you're going to see rampant sales tax evasion.
Businesses already collect income tax. Waitresses reporting their tips is basically on the honor system. Contractors get paid under the table all the time.
Moreover, VAT solves this easily because each component of the supply chain will insist that its supplier has paid the appropriate VAT, otherwise it won't be deductible from the VAT owed by the purchasing business.
I don't see any tenable path towards implementing this kind of taxation scheme. Consumer spending is the driving force of the US economy, and higher taxes on spending would cause serious reductions in spending in favor of saving (which goes untaxed). So you'd see huge collapses in goods and services industries, with people putting off big purchases until after the inevitable collapse of the new taxation scheme. Meanwhile entire companies are dying and millions becoming unemployed.
My effective total taxation rate under your proposed scheme would go from ~45% to under 10%. I save most of my income, and housing is more than half of the money I do save. I don't live in luxury housing or anything, and since you're discounting income, you thus couldn't charge me any more in taxes on my housing than my neighbors who earn significantly less (and couldn't afford to pay huge taxes on expensive housing).
Since the poor spend most of their income, and the rich don't spend most of it, you are in any case taxing a higher portion of the income of poor people (with consumption taxes).
As much as possible, we should be taxing consumption, not income, savings, and growth. Where it is necessary to tax income and growth, we should be looking specifically at the largest, wealthiest corporations and their major beneficiaries, not average individuals.