Re:How a Cashless Society Could Embolden Big Brother
by AnthonyMouse on Monday April 11, 2016 @05:06PM
(#11475108)
> I'm not the CBO, but that tax plan would have at least a one trillion dollar larger annual deficit than the current one, maybe closer to two. You would need massive, massive budget cuts.
You mean like all the social assistance programs that sending everyone a $10,000 check every year would make redundant?
Your argument seems to be that if the government wants to spend more money then they have to set a higher tax rate. Of course they do. How does that in any way dispute that a system of flat consumption tax + fixed refund is inherently progressive?
> Plus now you're relying on businesses to collect your revenue instead of the IRS, and so you're going to see rampant sales tax evasion.
Businesses already collect income tax. Waitresses reporting their tips is basically on the honor system. Contractors get paid under the table all the time.
Moreover, VAT solves this easily because each component of the supply chain will insist that its supplier has paid the appropriate VAT, otherwise it won't be deductible from the VAT owed by the purchasing business.
You mean like all the social assistance programs that sending everyone a $10,000 check every year would make redundant?
Your argument seems to be that if the government wants to spend more money then they have to set a higher tax rate. Of course they do. How does that in any way dispute that a system of flat consumption tax + fixed refund is inherently progressive?
> Plus now you're relying on businesses to collect your revenue instead of the IRS, and so you're going to see rampant sales tax evasion.
Businesses already collect income tax. Waitresses reporting their tips is basically on the honor system. Contractors get paid under the table all the time.
Moreover, VAT solves this easily because each component of the supply chain will insist that its supplier has paid the appropriate VAT, otherwise it won't be deductible from the VAT owed by the purchasing business.