News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by bluejekyll on Sunday April 03, 2016 @09:53PM (#11418908)
But this comes at an expense to nature and or natural preserves for wildlife. California has some of the greatest protected forests and areas like Yosemite.

So, yes we pay more and have more restrictions, but a better question is is it worth it?

Following the articles car analogy, this is like requiring cars to have airbags for the safety of the people in them, but that comes at a higher cost on the purchase price of the car.

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by surfmike on Sunday April 03, 2016 @10:19PM (#11418988)
This is a false dichotomy.

We have minimum lot size restrictions, and restrict lots to one housing unit (R1 zoning). These regulations push up the prices of homes (since it increases the minimum amount of land for a housing unit), and do nothing to save forests and national parks.

In fact, if we keep building low density neighborhoods, more open space will be used up than if our zoning allowed for denser development.

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by gwbas1c on Sunday April 03, 2016 @10:26PM (#11419011)
I think you miss the point:

Two words: Eminent Domain. Silicon Valley (and other areas in CA) need to use eminent domain to build high-rises.

The housing crisis can be solved without impacting nature preserves.

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by mtviewdave on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:59PM (#11419321)
In California, the state constitution forbids (in general) state and local government from using eminent domain to acquire an owner-occupied residence for the purposes of conveying it to a private entity. This restriction was added to the state constitution in 2008 via referendum.

On a broader note, while I understand the frustration with NIMBYism, a lot of these discussions about housing here on HN cross the line from anti-NIMBYism to anti-democracy. The United States is not China. The solution to the housing crisis in the US is not and never will be for governments (at any level) to impose solutions contrary to the general will of the American voting public. Any government that tries to do so will find itself replaced. Quickly. And quite rightly so.

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by ghaff on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:17PM (#11419205)
Or tech companies could just move to the many areas of the country, such as many areas of the Midwest, where housing isn't so constrained. There's plenty of space in the US. Just not in the Bay area.
Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by drivingmenuts on Monday April 04, 2016 @12:29AM (#11419433)
Sure, and then they'd be stuck with Billy Joe and Jim Bob, who once used a computer back in the 90's, as a workforce.

Or they could offer the same California salaries to programmers, who would live like kings in a small town but wouldn't have the same conveniences, and still spend the same amount of money.

Moving to the countryside doesn't always make business sense. Sure, costs to have a business in an urban area, but it's easier to find workforce at all needed levels and the trappings of urban civilization keep your workforce occupied and happier in their off hours.

Case-in-point: I work for a cash-strapped startup (for reasons) and sometimes have to live off my savings, but I live in an urban area. I could move to my hometown, where my costs would be about 25% of my current expenses, but then I'd be living in a special kind of hell where there are few good restaurants and the nearest bookstore is 60 miles away.

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by kedean on Monday April 04, 2016 @10:47AM (#11422255)
"The Midwest" doesn't mean small 50-person towns. There are many big cities and medium cities in the midwest, chock full of computer savvy people who need jobs. Where exactly do you think this workforce overflowing the Bay Area is coming from? They've flooded California because CA has told them that's where all the jobs are, but there are plenty more where they came from.
Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by douche on Monday April 04, 2016 @07:37AM (#11421023)
Oh my god, the horror of not having five-star restaurants!

If Google or Apple moved from the Bay to anywhere else, their workers would follow. Don't doubt that for a second.

Or we could just embrace technology and stop insisting that all your workers have to breathe the same oxygen, and allow remote work. There are huge swathes of the United States that are becoming depopulated because industry died and all of the young people have had to leave to find work. I just got back from a trip home to western Maine, and it's disturbing the number of houses that are just abandoned up there.

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by drivingmenuts on Monday April 04, 2016 @07:49AM (#11421104)
> Oh my god, the horror of not having five-star restaurants!

It's not just the lack of 5-star restaurants, it's the lack of 2+ star restaurants and everything else that goes with it. If your job relocated to western Maine, how much of a wrench in your life would that be?

> If Google or Apple moved from the Bay to anywhere else, their workers would follow. Don't doubt that for a second.

Only if the pay incentive was great enough, I'm sure. Otherwise, it might be easier to just get a new job in the same area. Google and Apple might be exceptions, considering that they're pretty much both loaded, but any smaller company would have to think long and hard about the expenditures required to get the bulk of their employees moved. People get rooted in their communities, especially if the standard of living is higher than where they're expected to move.

> Or we could just embrace technology and stop insisting that all your workers have to breathe the same oxygen, and allow remote work.

And someday pigs might fly, but not this century.

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by douche on Monday April 04, 2016 @07:59AM (#11421157)
> If your job relocated to western Maine, how much of a wrench in your life would that be?

I'd be fucking stoked. Cheap land, low population density, mountains. But I'm originally a redneck from that area to begin with, so my expectations of amenities and services are very low.

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by cmurf on Monday April 04, 2016 @02:31AM (#11419778)
Denver. Double digit rent and housing increases for 2-3 years now.
Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by mcguire on Sunday April 03, 2016 @10:40PM (#11419059)
Didn't some place in New Jersey get roundly hosed around here when they pulled eminent domain on some properties and then turned them over to developers?

Something about property rights?

Re:Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it... by tomschlick on Sunday April 03, 2016 @10:18PM (#11418986)
And SF has some of the highest rent in the country because they won't zone for larger apartment buildings.