News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by illumin8 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:02AM (#11397660)
This can really be traced back to the repeal of Glass Steagal. After the great depression in the 30s, congress passed the Glass Steagal act, which put a firewall between investment banks and commercial banks. In other words, Wall Street investment banks could no longer gamble with customer deposits. This seems like common sense, and all of the financial problems actually occurred after Glass Steagal was repealed in the 90s.

It seems fairly obvious in hindsight that Glass Steagal was good legislation. It led to a 60+ year period of extended prosperity, and the greatest economy in the world. Once it was repealed, it set us up for a global financial crisis a decade later.

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:17AM (#11397773)
> This can really be traced back to the repeal of Glass Steagal

Can it? Because none of the banks who initially failed would have been firewalled by Glass-Steagal. Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, AIG...none of these were deposit-taking institutions.

The problem erupted from corn-fed mortgages, something Glass-Steagall wouldn't have saved us from. This isn't just my opinion. Most economists see Gramm-Leach-Bliley (the Act that repealed Glass-Steagall) as having had a minor effect, at most, on the 2008 financial crisis [1].

[1] http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/10/14/448685233/...

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by legutierr on Thursday March 31, 2016 @12:56PM (#11398617)
One of the driving factors behind the bad mortgages that were issued pre-2008 was the lack of ongoing oversight and poor risk assessment with regards to those mortgages, driven primarily by securitization.

Your linked article itself tells that Geithner and his ilk admit to securitization being at the heart of the crisis, saying that "other factors were more important in causing the 2008 crisis, such as bad mortgage underwriting, poor work by the ratings agencies and a securitization market gone crazy."

But strangely, they write this as a defense of Glass-Steagall's repeal, as if those factors came from nowhere. In fact, those factors were the specific result of the efforts by the largest banks to sell as many of their banking products as possible--and offload as much of their risk as possible--through their investment banking and securities divisions. Many suspect that some banks took advantage of the inherent opacity of mortgage-backed-securities to knowingly hide bad assets (and possibly even fraudulent, non-existant assets) and sell them to unsuspecting securities buyers at fraudulently inflated prices.

Would securitization have become such a problem if the repeal of Glass Steagall hadn't effectively pushed all of the money center banks to acquire or build their own investment banks? Would it have been so easy for bad actors to have committed fraud in this area if it wasn't so easy to keep everything "in house"?

The main reason that Glass-Steagal was enacted in 1933 was because the Crash of 1929 was in-part caused by Banks' selling over-hyped, over-priced securities to ordinary, unsophisticated banking consumers. OK, so it happened in the reverse this time. That doesn't mean that the crisis wouldn't have been prevented by the same firewall, had it existed, from 2003-2006.

Yes, none of the institutions that failed initially were deposit taking. But maybe that was because this time around they were the outsiders and the rubes. Who had a better sense of what kind of risk mortgage-backed-securities actually represented, than the people who were originating them?

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by cm2187 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:20AM (#11397801)
And if we look at the UK, all the banks that failed (RBS, HBOS, Northern Rock) failed because of their bad loans or over-reliance on short-term funding, not because of investment banking activities.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by deepnet on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:40AM (#11397954)
I disagree.

The RBS failed entirely because of foolish investments. Funding covered the cracks till it dried up.

Fred the Shred (RBS CEO) invested billions in toxic assets worldwide - his last act was to buy an investment bank full of them.

He still walked away with bonuses, though now the taxpayer paid for his golden parachute.

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by simplemath on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:37PM (#11399464)
The problem erupted because of a gigantic grey market in CDOs and other esoteric "financial products" which mainly appear to have been designed primarily to siphon money from their customers.

Glass-Steagal never envisioned the Rube Goldberg tower of cards this market created, with many transactions being so complex that they resist analysis.

http://www.kamakuraco.com/Portals/0/doclibrary/KCP26.pdf

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by pyre on Thursday March 31, 2016 @12:19PM (#11398309)
AIG wasn't a bad, but an insurance company that failed because it took on too much risk. If, for example, AIG was that only one to fail I'm not sure it would have taken down the economy with it. I see them as someone that got embroiled in the "sub-prime mortgage crisis", but not necessarily a perpetrator (unless I'm missing something).
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by breischl on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:37PM (#11399465)
AIG wasn't a bank but it was insuring a lot of the bank's assets, including securitized mortgages. By taking that risk off the banks' balance sheets, they let the banks take on more risk than they otherwise could have. So maybe AIG wasn't a perpetrator, but it was an enabler.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by illumin8 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:37PM (#11399460)
AIG insured the mortgage backed securities that caused the crisis.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by illumin8 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:40PM (#11399501)
The mortgages themselves weren't the problem - the problem was the way they were allowed to be bundled into mortgage backed securities, which created a firehose of investment money piling in from Wall Street to the mortgage market, which created bad incentives to issue more low quality mortgages (NINJA - no income, no job, no assets).
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by cm2187 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:53PM (#11399599)
People forget there was a demand for them, because investors were starved for yield.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by ktRolster on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:19AM (#11397784)

  >This can really be traced back to the repeal of Glass Steagal.
The evidence against this hypothesis is that Canada did not have Glass Steagal (or legislation similar to it), and yet they were not harmed by the financial crisis nearly as much. The banks were smart enough to not invest so deeply in mortgage backed securities.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by ajlburke on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:29AM (#11397877)
Canadian banks have generally been much more regulated than US ones. Through the 90s and early 2000s they constantly complained about too much government regulation getting in the way of their profits etc. - they seem to have shut up about that since 2008.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by badsock on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:41AM (#11397961)
They weren't smart enough. They were prevented by government regulation introduced in the 1990s.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by tosseraccount on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:44AM (#11397980)
Canada does not have personal residence mortgage deductibility and was riding a commodities boom at the time.

Speaking of the popular "austerity ruins the economy", Canada ran a budget surplus during the crisis, enabling them to weather the financial crisis quite well.

Keeping an eye on the accounting books is always a good idea.

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday March 31, 2016 @12:26PM (#11398373)
We did not run a budget surplus during the crisis. Far from it.

There was extensive stimulus spending that led to very high deficits during that period.

We had a budget surplus in the decade prior to the crisis, but not right before, and once the Harper gov't took power it slashed revenue through a bunch of tax cuts and then once the crisis hit the opposition demanded stimulus spending or it would bring the gov't down (minority parliament at the time).

And while Canada was "riding a commodity boom" at the time this hardly helped anybody east of Saskatchewan or west of Alberta. You could argue it helped their investments but you'd also be wrong, in 2008 the stock market tumbled the same here as everyone else, including energy stocks.

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by tosseraccount on Thursday March 31, 2016 @12:43PM (#11398514)
http://www.tradingeconomics.com/canada/government-budget

According to this link, the Canada Federal Budget appears to have been in surplus during 2007-2008 crisis.

Deficits came later.

Their previous fiscal prudence mitigated the problems that struck Italy, Greece and the United States.

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday March 31, 2016 @08:37PM (#11401726)
The stimulus budget was passed in 2009, the bulk of the spending came through in 2010, and the graph you linked to shows that.

Cutting your tax revenue isn't fiscal prudence. It's letting ideology triumph over reality. Harper never met a surplus he didn't throw away.

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday March 31, 2016 @12:27PM (#11398380)
And I should add that housing prices did dip briefly immediately following the crash in the US. Just not nearly as bad and they almost immediately recovered.
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by RobertoG on Thursday March 31, 2016 @12:20PM (#11398316)
OK, I propose we change the popular

"austerity ruins the economy"

to the most precise

"austerity ruins an economy, if it's not ridding a commodities boom at the time, and you don't have a private debt grow for compensating what the government is not spending."

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by theseatoms on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:07AM (#11397701)
I agree that this is the heart of the issue.

And the American people are about to elect back into the White House the couple that presided over the repeal of the Glass Steagal Act.

So much for learned lessons.

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by illumin8 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:12AM (#11397737)
To be fair, Clinton only signed the law - it was created and voted for by a Republican majority congress. Look at the votes - every Republican senator voted Yea and only one Democrat voted Nay: https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/106-1999/s105

He still shouldn't have signed it, but to blame this law on the Clintons is really not being honest.

Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by guelo on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:52AM (#11398047)
That's not the final vote. It passed 90-8 in the senate and 362-57 in the house. https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/106-1999/s354 https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/106-1999/h570
Re:Iceland put top finance executives behind bars, but fears... by illumin8 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:38PM (#11399482)
Thanks for the correction.