News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by steveklabnik on Friday February 19, 2010 @06:42PM (#1138249)
I thought that VP8 was basically On2's secret sauce, and that they had made all of it.

From their site: (http://www.on2.com/index.php?599)

     And with no patent-pool royalty hassles, VP8 licensing terms are flexible and affordable to ensure maximum ROI potential. 
So, it'd seem like just them.
Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by wmf on Friday February 19, 2010 @06:53PM (#1138271)
Microsoft said the same thing about WMV and then when they opened the spec a whole bunch of companies discovered that it was infringing their patents and now there's a patent pool around VC-1.

OTOH, I'm sure Google has thought about this problem and done some due diligence.

Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by lftl on Friday February 19, 2010 @06:49PM (#1138267)
This definitely doesn't mean VP8 is free and clear. It just means that On2 doesn't have any patents that they were actively enforcing on VP8.

It's quite likely that any number of H.264 or other random patents apply just as well to VP8, especially given the USPTO's penchant for handing out patents that cover even the most basic of ideas. This is Apple's stated reason for refusing to implement Theora. In this vein, it should also be noted that there's no guarantee that licensing H.264 actually covers you for every patent.

Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by steveklabnik on Friday February 19, 2010 @07:10PM (#1138316)
Ah yes, that "submarine" thing. We really need to get this whole software patent thing taken care of.
Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by zokier on Friday February 19, 2010 @07:53PM (#1138376)
>In this vein, it should also be noted that there's no guarantee that licensing H.264 actually covers you for every patent.

I'd assume that if someone would be foolish enough to sue a h264 licensee, MPEG-LA (or it's members) would be quick to counter-sue them to oblivion.

Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by wmf on Friday February 19, 2010 @08:44PM (#1138464)
On what grounds? MPEG LA specifically disclaims liability for any patents they don't have in their pool.
Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by steveklabnik on Friday February 19, 2010 @08:43PM (#1138461)
What would they counter-sue over?
Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by blasdel on Friday February 19, 2010 @08:55PM (#1138479)
They have the nuclear option -- refuse licenses of the in-pool patents to anyone licensing an out-of-pool patent. Most of the patents involved are unusable independently -- you have to license a chain of predecessors.

There's a reason why patent owners just join the pool when they discover they're eligible for a nice easy income stream.

Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by danbmil99 on Saturday February 20, 2010 @06:07AM (#1138916)
MPEG-LA can't do that because the pool has a rule of non-discriminatory licensing. That's one of the (flimsy) bases for their antitrust exemption.
Re:Open letter to Google: free VP8, and use it on YouTube by DarkShikari on Friday February 19, 2010 @09:03PM (#1138492)
This, by the way, is the reason why even non-litigious companies tend to accumulate huge quantities of patents: they serve as potent weapons against anyone attempting to sue them.

Equally, it's why productless patent trolls are so dangerous: since they don't make any products, such patent portfolios are useless as deterrence against them.