News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by zanny on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @09:45AM (#11381377)
It is in no companies fiscal interest to pay their employees more. They want you to work for as little as you agree to while producing as much return for the company as possible.

The real solution is to just do a UBI. If this is not an obvious call sign of how the efficiencies of recent decades are obsoleting human labor in general I don't know what is. Redistribute that money so consumers have spending power again.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by soundwave106 on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @11:00AM (#11381944)
One hope of mine, an actual capitalist solution to this problem of capitalism, is that companies start investing in their service employees more as an asset, not as a disposable automaton (eg, using higher quality service as a differentiation, which I think is even possible in the low margin / low price areas of business).

Already in service industries, it seems like current companies that focus on employees more have higher reputations overall, and often have higher growth despite higher expenses on employees. Costco and Trader Joe's vs. Wal-Mart is the frequently cited example of this sort of case scenario, but there are plenty of others.

Unfortunately, I'm not sure that a large portion of the investor class is really great for evaluating long-term value, and too focused on the quarter end. (Quite a number of the better service oriented companies are not public owned.)

For the same reason, I'll be honest, while UBI is another way around increasing automation, I just can't see the same short-term oriented investor class fully getting behind this concept, at this time.

The last time we had a similar scenario (the Gilded Age), it took a lot of unrest for things to get better for the manufacturing worker class. Unfortunately I wonder if a similar future will happen for the service worker class if something doesn't change...

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by Kalium on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @01:02PM (#11382905)
I think competing on service quality is only possible where either consumers will accept a price differential or you can manage to avoid any kind of price differential.

If I'm at a self-service gas station using the self-service pump and paying at the self-service machine, I really don't care if there's good service from the person behind the counter inside. I certainly wouldn't want to pay more for better service from a person I don't ever interact with.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by rfrank on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @11:21AM (#11382093)
> One hope of mine, an actual capitalist solution to this problem of capitalism, is that companies start investing in their service employees more as an asset, not as a disposable automaton (eg, using higher quality service as a differentiation, which I think is even possible in the low margin / low price areas of business).

A sentiment I agree with, but if the recent Yelp call center fiasco is any evidence, I don't find it terribly likely.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @01:27PM (#11391116)
>The last time we had a similar scenario (the Gilded Age), it took a lot of unrest for things to get better for the manufacturing worker class. Unfortunately I wonder if a similar future will happen for the service worker class if something doesn't change...

Let's say it: it took the Russian Revolution to get the Western owning classes sufficiently scared that they decided to buy wholesale into Bismarckism and social-democracy.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by incongruity on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @09:57AM (#11381487)
It is in no companies fiscal interest to pay their employees more.

In the short-run, yes. In the long run, perhaps not. From retention to training to quality issues, it can make sense to pay more.

Universal basic income is a bandaid on the fact that the short-term, market-driven focus of capitalism under-values people and seems to be creating a winner take all game that will eventually end the game itself, if balance isn't restored.

I'm not opposed to UBI – it may well be the best option at this point, but I'd also like to figure out how to incentivize the system to look at long-term consequences as well. (Though, I recognize I'm far from the first down this line of thought).

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by madaxe_again on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:14AM (#11381595)
Companies tend to not think in the long term - they are encouraged by investors, lenders and the market to think in very short planning horizons.

A recent experience when trying to get a personal mortgage as a company director underscored this:

"Your profits are down! Your business must be failing!!"

"No, we opted to re-invest some of the substantial amount of cash we're sitting on, and therefore took a hit to profitability this year so as to be more profitable in the future."

"So your business is failing?"

Consider this at a grand scale and you understand the incentives within which corporations operate. Everything is about the quarterly earnings report.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:23AM (#11381650)
Worse. Its about management bonuses. "Should we compensate floor mechanics better in our factory? How would that affect my bonus this quarter? It would be smaller? Then hell no." That's all it takes to explain myopic businesses. And so much of our manufacturing sector are motivated in just this way.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by pc86 on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @01:42PM (#11383276)
Self-interest is not necessarily myopia. The problem in your example is that payroll somehow affects a manager's bonus which is asinine (not saying it's not common).
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @03:50PM (#11384329)
Profit includes everything, affects everything. And that's the common (universal?) stockholder-value metric.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by eldavido on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @11:47AM (#11382311)
This isn't as crazy as it sounds.

Look at a typical main street business: retailer, car dealership, restaurant, etc. There is no "R&D". Profits scale linearly with revenue; it's not so crazy to jump from "profit is down" to "business is failing".

In fact, the very definition of a "high-technology company" is one that reinvests a large amount of revenue into development. The exact threshold varies, but 20-30% and most people agree you're into "high tech" land. For comparison, consumer product goods companies like P&G spend some 10% of their revenue on marketing/advertising. http://adage.com/article/special-report-pg-at-175/procter-ga...

The real issue is that "Business" doesn't yet understand the economics of software companies. They have no tangible assets, their cash cycles are vastly different from most other companies, and they grow in discontinuous, sharp, nonlinear ways. You'll see this bias all over the economy if you look.

"Silicon Valley companies are overhyped, THEY HAVE NO PROFITS"

"That company is failing, it's going under"

Amazon is the grand counterexample, look at how much of a head-scratcher that company is to Wall Street to get an idea of how puzzling this is to Joe Business Guy.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by TDL on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:10AM (#11381578)
Capitalism isn't inherently short-term oriented. This has more to do with the incentives in & the regulatory framework of the system (consider requirements for quarterly reporting & the whole expectations game that has risen from that requirement.)
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by incongruity on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @11:15AM (#11382052)
Capitalism isn't inherently short-term oriented.

No, but people do tend to be. We seem to be wired to value near-term gains much more strongly than long-term gains -- http://www.behavioraleconomics.com/mini-encyclopedia-of-be/t...

This then drives us to create the systems that focus on near-term rewards – like the quarterly reporting and equities that can be traded at a moment's notice, etc. etc.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by eldavido on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @11:50AM (#11382334)
I see a lot of parallels with the political system.

If you let the masses take charge, you're going to a get a more wild, dynamic, unpredictable outcome. In the stock market this new "democracy" manifests as extremely short hold times, in the political arena, as fringe candidates that party elites would never have let win the primaries, had they been in charge.

I, for one, hold stocks for a long time, and hope companies do optimize for the long term, but I realize I may be in the minority.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by zanny on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @05:26PM (#11385004)
If you want more long term business thinking you want more private companies. Once you go public, personal ambition goes out the window - all that matters is the share price and quarterly growth forecasts, because then the people that own and run the company are no longer passionate innovators, but the investors, who are only looking to make money.

We talk about how the tech industry has a problem with employer / employee loyalty where you should expect to work for a half dozen companies by 35, but even moreso investors have zero loyalty whatsoever, and will jump at the first sign of declining growth.

So entrepreneurship is only half the battle - we also need to incentivize more Dells that either revert from public to private or just get more new business startups that aren't looking to just cash out and sink the business.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by randyrand on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @03:31PM (#11384197)
> They want you to work for as little as you agree to

This implies retention. It also implies a certain level of quality or the agreement fails. So your long run argument falls flat.

Yes, you can pay more to get more quality. This is not at odds with wanting you to work for as little as you will agree to.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by pessimizer on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:06AM (#11381538)
> From retention to training to quality issues, it can make sense to pay more.

Depends on how consolidated the industry has been, and whether the firms that are left can collude or silently set norms to put ceilings on pay and quality.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by revscat on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @09:56AM (#11381475)
> It is in no companies fiscal interest to pay their employees more.

I'm actually not sure this is true. From a short term perspective, perhaps. But longer term it is more beneficial for everyone if there is more money to be spent.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by savanaly on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:03AM (#11381522)
You said you're differentiating between long and short term, but I think you're actually talking about the difference between "one company's interest" and "all companies' interests". It is possibly in all companies' interest to all pay their employees more as it would stimulate demand for their products. But any given individual company's own workers are such a vanishingly small fraction of its own customer base that it could hardly ever be argued that it would be best for that particular company to pay its own workers more for the purposes of stimulating demand.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by lfowles on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:15AM (#11381599)
Your workers will be more invested if they can comfortably afford the product, though. Obviously this depends on the market.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by savanaly on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:27AM (#11381666)
Oh, no doubt that can be a reason. The literature around the "efficiency wage" is well developed [1], my comment was only disputing that there were a reason to pay above market clearing wages for reasons of stimulating demand.

[1](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficiency_wage)

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by ktRolster on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:45AM (#11381807)
Your workers will be more invested if they can comfortably afford the product, though.

Most of the companies I've worked for I would never buy their product: either because I didn't need it, or because I knew its true quality, or both.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by SpaceCadetJones on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:48AM (#11381843)
I wonder if this is different for companies like Walmart / Costco / Meijer where they carry the majority of goods you need day to day. What if they started paying their employees higher wages, meanwhile giving them discounts at the store to encourage them to spend there? Maybe the lowered profit margins could be made up by the increased spending at their store. Not to mention it would also be a good PR move
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by tanker on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @12:59PM (#11382878)
Obviously, you would have to avoid the "Company Store" problem.

I think it could be a terrible PR move. If you effectively pay your employees less and justify by giving them discounts. A program that begins with good intentions could end badly. Especially if the program is conceived in an era of high profits. In low profits, management makes different decisions. Also, you often get new management.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by SpaceCadetJones on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @01:25PM (#11383092)
I'm a bit confused, where does the effectively paying less come from? I suggested they increase their pay while also giving them a discount at the store to give them an incentive to spend their new income at the store.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by tanker on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @03:55PM (#11384380)
I communicated poorly. Paying your employees more and giving them a discount is harmless. Lots of employees receive a discount.

I meant you run into problems when you end up effectively paying them less and justifying via a larger discount.

Management could end up doing this gradually as times get tough. For example, a company announces lay offs and pay cuts, but softens the blow with a larger discount.

I guess I'm recommending caution. I would avoid making a discount a major part of employee compensation. A worker deciding to apply for jobs at Walmart and Costco could end up weighing a better health plan against a higher discount on basic goods. That seems problematic to me.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by SpaceCadetJones on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @04:25PM (#11384580)
Thanks for clarifying, this makes a lot of sense.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by nradov on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @05:23PM (#11384991)
Employee discounts can't be very high or else employees will set up side businesses buying up cheap products and then reselling them on eBay or whatever (arbitrage). This directly hurts the employer's profits. With an employee discount of 10% or so it's usually not worth the hassle. But when discounts go over ~20% it gives employees an incentive to act unethically. Employers can partially counteract that by limiting purchase quantities but it becomes a huge hassle to enforce.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by jandrese on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @10:50AM (#11381864)
> It is in no companies fiscal interest to pay their employees more.

Henry Ford realized just how wrong this is almost a hundred years ago. He realized that if you don't pay your workers enough they you won't have demand, and growth is driven by demand. It's a feedback loop. This is why having so much wealth concentrated at the top is so bad, it stifles growth. You end up with a stagnant middle ages type economy.

Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by mortehu on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @11:12AM (#11382028)
Based on the documentaries I've watched, the real reason Henry Ford lifted wages to $5 was to solve retention issues. Working at the car factory was a pretty bad job, and employees were constantly leaving. Before the wage hike, he hired 52000 people in a year to maintain a staff of 14000.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe... by rm_-rf_slash on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @12:25PM (#11382621)
More or less the same reasoning: if you spend more on employees they can cost you less in the long run, just as spending more on shoes means they will last you far longer than junk that wears away.