In many cases what motivates a particular individual provides little insight into what happens in the economy as a whole. For example, a model of start-up success that included founder education level and sci-fi movies watched by founders would provide little, if any, greater insight than a model the model that looked at just education level. It's similar to over-fitting in machine learning – the extra parameter is probably harming the usefulness of the model by making it less general.
On the other hand, CEO cocaine addiction might be a very good predictor of company profits, but you would have a hard time getting accurate data for that regardless of how good your AI is. Furthermore, I could reasonably hypothesize that some CEO's would respond to cocaine by out-performing non-cocaine users while some would under-perform depending on physiological factors. Again, without massive invasions of privacy, economists will not be able to factor this into their models.
Psychology, especially social psychology, is an epistemological disaster area[1][2] and everyone would be better off ignoring its "findings", not just economists.
[1] http://www.nature.com/news/over-half-of-psychology-studies-f...
[2] http://michaelinzlicht.com/getting-better/2016/2/29/reckonin...
As someone who studied psychology, I've always recognized a lot of it is a bunch of wankery (as everyone should). That doesn't mean you toss it out, it means you think critically about any findings. This is the same reason I'm wary of a lot of economic talk: it's another social science studying something possibly even more complex. People seem to often carry a definitive tone
Human weakness, bias, ignorance etc are like software bugs in systems that mostly can't be patched.
We have got so good at detecting and exploiting these bugs at speed and scale that all I see happening is another Greenspan type moment, where a future Google\Facebook CEO is sitting before a committee wondering how everything imploded.
I mean Google\Facebook\Twitter etc benefit from the traffic Porn, Trump and ISIS pay for and generate much more than anyone else does. It's ridiculous.
Just because it can be taken advantage of doesn't make it a bug. There are reasons these features developed, they were/are evolutionary advantageous. Things like bias are important because they help make us more efficient. They create blind spots, but they also allow us to more wisely spend our limited processing power. We have to compartmentalize things to understand them, we have very limited capacities. We have to do mental rounding in order to make sense of the world around us, there's simply too much information.
I'm sure that hedge funds do exactly this and reap great returns as a result.
And political science isn't concerned with the behaviour of people or groups?
>benefit greatly from a more unified theory.
Economists are generally concerned with things that can be measured. As others have pointed out, psychological findings are often irreproducible. So what's the point in incorporating them into models?
And this all ignores the fact that behavioural economics is a popular and growing field...
How? AI doesn't magically solve problems, it still has to be programmed by a human, and as yet we really have no good models to assess exactly how, for example, cocaine abuse affects a CEO's performance.
See people's music listening trends on Spotify (or torrents or whatever). Examine the lyrics (or lack of lyrics) of the songs.
I would guess that an AI could find patterns and relationships between what songs people listen to and their emotional or mental heath (plus many other indicators).
Are people falling in love or are they breaking up, are they having more or less sex ? Are people using more drugs, partying or drinking more ?
Now you have some macroeconomic indicators - vectors - which affect a wide range of industries - from contraceptives to baby cribs to concert tickets.
Again, a wild guess, but I think AI could be applied to this kind of fuzzy analyses and probably be quite effective at predicting economic trends.
> To conclude, I think regulators should look at all these factors much deeper, determine the connection between mind and economy and exercise their influence by tuning other parts of society, not just traditional economic levers.
Can you clarify? I'm probably just misreading you, but it sounds like you're implying that we should be "regulating" culture -- or even thought itself ("thought manipulation and mind control") -- in order to improve the economy. Just wanted to make sure I was reading that correctly.
If that is what you meant, could you give some kind of hypothetical example? Would this be like banning certain themes because they cause social unrest? Requiring shows to carry certain messages? Eliminating styles of music that lead to "unproductive" activities? Bonuses for creators of films that cause a jump in profits? I'm legitimately baffled.
Culture and the economy are in a constant feedback loop and we should look at both components when building our theories.
There is this fallacy that companies offer customers what they want, when in fact companies do everything possible to suggest to people what they want or need by using all kinds of mind manipulation techniques. And the theory doesn't address this at all.
I don't know about regulation of culture - that never works as expected, but some activism is always welcome. Facebook or Google could potentially alter the whole global economy and ecology, just by carrying certain messages on their websites or apps.
Like "plant trees and recycle" ! Or .. "be generous, help the needy" or something like that.
Sure, unless there is real popular pressure for change, they the all increase together ad maximum, reinforcing one another...
Things like mental and physical health, addictions and substance use, thought manipulation and mind control, the fears and desires, sexual fantasies, even popular movies and music affect the economy greatly.
Not just a little bit, but greatly. A CEO's addiction to cocaine or promiscuity will have an impact on his company's bottom line. A young man starts a disrupting startup because he got inspired by a sci-fi movie a couple of years earlier.
Adam Smith's "invisible hand" is "invisible" because those forces can't be explained by the mechanistic rules of economics or mathematics. We just need to look elsewhere for a comprehensive picture.
What makes customers choose a product over the other ? Why do some companies retain great talent better than others - and hence reap greater profits ? How does pop music affect industrial design ?
Of course, human behavior and psychology is hard to quantify, that is why it's being left out, but I think we can start to make these connections now that we have the tools and information available.
Take Google and Facebook - these companies make their profits from advertising. Tens of billions. Add the profits of the media market - print, tv, radio.
Now consider how all that advertising affects the demand curve in all the other industries.
And it's not just the quantity, it's also the quality of advertising - today's ads are scientifically designed to drill their way into our subconsciousness. The colors, the sounds, the motions, the emotions - all of these are carefully weighted so as just to make you want a certain brand over the other.
And now my favorite part - is there a connection between advertising, corporate profits, pollution and climate change ?
I think there is and it's a great one. To conclude, I think regulators should look at all these factors much deeper, determine the connection between mind and economy and exercise their influence by tuning other parts of society, not just traditional economic levers.
Of course this is a monumental task for humans, but AI might just be perfectly suited for this type of analyses.