Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe...
by justsaysmthng on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @01:21PM
(#11383058)
Not at all. I wasn't trying to suggest any fixes.
I was just rhetorically questioning the validity of our economic theory without including the "laws" of human behavior and the factors that influence it.
Culture and the economy are in a constant feedback loop and we should look at both components when building our theories.
There is this fallacy that companies offer customers what they want, when in fact companies do everything possible to suggest to people what they want or need by using all kinds of mind manipulation techniques. And the theory doesn't address this at all.
I don't know about regulation of culture - that never works as expected, but some activism is always welcome. Facebook or Google could potentially alter the whole global economy and ecology, just by carrying certain messages on their websites or apps.
Like "plant trees and recycle" ! Or .. "be generous, help the needy" or something like that.
Re:Profits are too high. America needs a giant dose of compe...
by iamnothere on Tuesday March 29, 2016 @01:41PM
(#11383256)
Thanks, that makes a lot more sense then. Culture informs economy and vice versa, and it makes sense to study that. It just worries me when it looks like someone is advocating the elevation of economy over culture, especially when potential regulation is on the table.
> To conclude, I think regulators should look at all these factors much deeper, determine the connection between mind and economy and exercise their influence by tuning other parts of society, not just traditional economic levers.
Can you clarify? I'm probably just misreading you, but it sounds like you're implying that we should be "regulating" culture -- or even thought itself ("thought manipulation and mind control") -- in order to improve the economy. Just wanted to make sure I was reading that correctly.
If that is what you meant, could you give some kind of hypothetical example? Would this be like banning certain themes because they cause social unrest? Requiring shows to carry certain messages? Eliminating styles of music that lead to "unproductive" activities? Bonuses for creators of films that cause a jump in profits? I'm legitimately baffled.