Just a stray thought.
If you penalise users for doing that, they'll do less of it, which will make the ranking/filtering less effective.
Like any major site, I would guess the majority of HN readers do not comment, or only comment rarely.
Losing karma for upvoting means you need to comment if you want to upvote, and I suspect many readers will simply choose not to participate in either activity rather than try to maintain a positive karma balance.
Each upvote on a submission: +100 for submitter, -1 for voter.
Each upvote on a comment: +10 for commenter, -1 for voter.
Each downvote on a comment: -10 for commenter, -1 for voter
This aligns with the ladder of engagement, where there are 10x as many creators as commenters as voters, while keeping a steady stream of currency injection.It's rather the opposite. There are tens of thousands of potential voters, a fraction of that in comments and a fraction of that in quality link submitters (once you filter out the spam). Anyway, regardless of the situation there is an easy way out of this: measure and adjust accordingly, I'm sure 'arc' has the ability to define named constants.
This would also answer the question 'what is karma good for?' once and for all.
Forcing the comment box is also interesting. Maybe only make the downvote available to people who have already replied to a post.