News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mass surveillance silences minority opinions, according t... by kup0 on Monday March 28, 2016 @04:26PM (#11377102)
I think the mentality that downvote = disagreement is widespread on any site with a karma/voting mechanism. Many subreddits themselves say right in the sidebar (and often elsewhere) that "downvote only if something is off-topic or does not contribute to discussion", but everyone still tends to use it that way.

So I think the issue is somewhat bigger than reddit or HN or even just a certain slice of users. It seems to be a fundamental problem in understanding up/down votes. Maybe psychologically we're inclined to downvote when we disagree, whether consciously or not.

I am also guilty of this even though I know better. It's hard to resist downvoting something I disagree with. It's like a natural response I have to actively work against.

Edits: grammar / clarifying wording

Re:Mass surveillance silences minority opinions, according t... by kstenerud on Monday March 28, 2016 @04:40PM (#11377211)
It's human nature. If something offends you, you WANT it to be wrong/unfair/trolling. And so it becomes just that, and then your downvote is justified.
Re:Mass surveillance silences minority opinions, according t... by ywecur on Monday March 28, 2016 @04:30PM (#11377132)
My theory is that it's because it's to convenient.

A solution could be to move it to next to the flag button, maybe? And also making it a bit more difficult to do, like requiring the user to input a reason.

Re:Mass surveillance silences minority opinions, according t... by DanBC on Monday March 28, 2016 @04:37PM (#11377182)
I agree that some people will always downvote to disagree. (I do, but I'm trying to stop it (to the point where I'm going to greasemonkey a script to take the button away)).

I also agree that people should probably not downvote to disagree.

But also, when other people see a grey comment and they think it's unfairly downvoted they should supply a corrective upvote. I know some people on HN do this, but I get the impression that not enough people do.