News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by wrong_variable on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:01PM (#11375511)
> "Personally, I prefer a government that lets people do stupid things"

What an ignorant statement to make. Are you okay with people making "stupid decisions" like smoking in public places ?

Are you okay with people making "stupid decisions" like driving drunk ?

Are you okay with people making "stupid decisions" like shooting up a school ?

Society works when we look out for each other - and not let people do whatever they think is "right".

Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by crazy1van on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:04PM (#11375544)
I think his caveat of "barring negative impact on others" pretty much covers these cases.
Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by wrong_variable on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:10PM (#11375607)
> "barring negative impact on others"

You think taking what little money poor people have from them via allowing them to spend it on lottery does not have social consequences ?

Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by palakchokshi on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:20PM (#11375666)
Ummm what happens when you apply your argument to allowing them to spend it on alcohol or cigarettes or a car or a thousand other things? This is a flawed argument my friend. No one group has a right to enforce their social, moral, economic or other ideology on another group based on what the enforcing group thinks is "right". That's a slippery slope with extra grease on it.
Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by frogpelt on Monday March 28, 2016 @03:41PM (#11376766)
Different methods of governing can basically all boil down to a simple balance scale:

On one side you have the rights of the individual and on the other side you have the rights of the community.

Some people tend to lean the scale toward individual rights and others toward community rights.

Smaller government tends to handle the balance by staying out of the way until it's necessary that they step in. Bigger government tends to handle the balance by marking clear (or blurry) lines and moving them when necessary.

Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by exolymph on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @02:27AM (#11387330)
This is exactly what I was trying to say. Well put.
Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by xixi77 on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:27PM (#11375705)
In your line of reasoning, should we perhaps also introduce mandatory drug testing for people with low income, and prohibit them from buying alcohol and cigarettes? Surely, these purchases have more social consequences than lottery tickets.
Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by timbowhite on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:26PM (#11375700)
Well then the government should create laws allowing it to dictate what you can spend your money on if you make less than $X per year. You know, to prevent social consequences.
Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by mindslight on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:45PM (#11375864)
This concept of "social consequences" is essentially a flipped framing of a situation to incorporate an implicit utility function of whomever is using the term.

If a person or group of people does not act in a way that benefits you, they still have not harmed you. It simply means they have not chosen to conform to your expectations.

Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by nostrebored on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:23PM (#11375687)
I guess it's hard for some people to relate to a large portion of any future savings being 'invested' in lottery tickets ("the money just goes towards your college education either way!") and spent on cigarettes -- not that hard at all when it's been your reality.
Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by exolymph on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @02:27AM (#11387329)
*her, but thank you. (I know it's a little thing, but it bothers me that people automatically assume anyone on Hacker News is a man.)
Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by nmrm2 on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:06PM (#11375560)
One could make the argument that there's a difference between letting people do stupid things that only indirectly and only in certain contexts hurt others (ex spending the rent money on lottery tickets) and letting people do stupid things that by definition hurt others (shooting up a school, smoking in public and populated places) or have a significant liklihood of harming others (driving drunk).

Of course this is always an awkward line to walk, and the definition of stupid is entirely subjective. Most things that make people happy aren't totally "rational".

Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by CompelTechnic on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:16PM (#11375641)
All examples you give have a high likelihood of hurting other people.

How does buying a lottery ticket hurt others?

Re:Lotteries: America's $70B Shame by zeveb on Monday March 28, 2016 @01:10PM (#11375604)
> Are you okay with people making "stupid decisions" like smoking in public places?

Yes, because mature adults recognise that smoking in public places is no more offensive than poor bathing hygiene, and less harmful than woodsmoke.

> Society works when we look out for each other - and not let people do whatever they think is "right".

What is right? The majority? That's just a synonym for might.