The nail in the coffin of the tobacco industry wasn’t “cigarettes are unhealthy,” it was that the tobacco industry was actively deceiving the public and obfuscating scientific research over multiple generations.
(When the sugar industry follows step (this seems inevitable), it will because they failed to police themselves with candid acknowledgement that soda should be a treat and not a dietary staple. Perhaps the Bloomberg soda ban was a bad idea and heavy-handed mommy gov't etc, but if the soda companies had an iota of sense they would have pre-empted the whole mess.)
So getting back to lottery… let’s agree that it is okay for people to act as they wish, but is it acceptable for lottery to misrepresent the astronomically low chances of even breaking even? Is it acceptable for lottery to specifically market toward people who can least afford it?
You could enforce monthly purchase limits based on income, you could require an accurate demonstration of statistics on every ticket, you could raise taxes and double ticket prices, all sorts of things that would get the primary market - people who buy tickets and really can't afford it - to buy less, but...
Hey, you never know.
Spending a good bit of my formative years in Biloxi seriously changed my attitude around all of this.
The degree to which the casino industry in Biloxi is celebrated as a heroic engine of economic development and generosity depresses me. The Coast was no utopia before the casinos. And sure, yeah, the casinos employ a bunch of people and some tax money goes to local schools.
But seeing people - often poor people - gamble away their lives, seeing how much prostitution came into play, seeing how many hard drugs come in through them...I don't think the price was worth it.
But all you'll see in the local paper, and hear from most locals, is laudatory: casinos are the savior. We need more of them!
Lol...
The freedom allowing people to make those types of decisions trumps that argument.
Where would you draw the line and determine what we should "let" people do with their own possessions?
So you would not let a person gamble their house on a crap shoot? How about their car? Their watch? $5?
If you want to gamble your house away in a private bet, go for it, but the local government shouldn't move heaven and earth to get a casino built to enable thousands and thousands of people to make those decisions in the name of tax revenue.
Similarly, I don't think you would be taking away people's freedom in any meaningful way if, say, you limited lottery transactions to say, $20.
Only take it a step further. The state shouldn't move heaven and earth to get anything privately owned built. That it's a casino only makes something inherently bad even worse.
What an ignorant statement to make. Are you okay with people making "stupid decisions" like smoking in public places ?
Are you okay with people making "stupid decisions" like driving drunk ?
Are you okay with people making "stupid decisions" like shooting up a school ?
Society works when we look out for each other - and not let people do whatever they think is "right".
You think taking what little money poor people have from them via allowing them to spend it on lottery does not have social consequences ?
On one side you have the rights of the individual and on the other side you have the rights of the community.
Some people tend to lean the scale toward individual rights and others toward community rights.
Smaller government tends to handle the balance by staying out of the way until it's necessary that they step in. Bigger government tends to handle the balance by marking clear (or blurry) lines and moving them when necessary.
If a person or group of people does not act in a way that benefits you, they still have not harmed you. It simply means they have not chosen to conform to your expectations.
Of course this is always an awkward line to walk, and the definition of stupid is entirely subjective. Most things that make people happy aren't totally "rational".
How does buying a lottery ticket hurt others?
Yes, because mature adults recognise that smoking in public places is no more offensive than poor bathing hygiene, and less harmful than woodsmoke.
> Society works when we look out for each other - and not let people do whatever they think is "right".
What is right? The majority? That's just a synonym for might.
Yes, buying lottery tickets for any reason other than entertainment is irrational. But does that mean it shouldn't be allowed? People are choosing to spend their money like this.
Personally, I prefer a government that lets people do stupid things -- e.g. buying a lottery ticket with the expectation of winning -- to a government that paternalistically enforces middle-class norms.