News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swift 2.2 Released by pkolaczk on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @06:16AM (#11343196)
Templates are a macro system. Macro systems are often Turing-complete. But if being Turing-complete was the only important thing in programming, then we'd all code in assembly and never look forward. Most programming languages are Turing-complete, but this doesn't mean they are practically equivalent for every job. You know, Brainfuck is also Turing-complete, but you'd be probably pissed-off if I said heavy-templated C++ code readability is often close to that of Brainfuck.

Macro systems can be very powerful, but they are also quite hard to use. It is 2016 and error messages in C++ templates are still inferior to the messages you get in C#, Java or Scala generics, despite templates existing for much longer.

C++ templates are also not the very best at metaprogramming either. Take any macro system like the ones found in LISPs, Scala or Template Haskell - they are much more powerful and consistent with the rest of the language. I can code Scala metaprograms in Scala or LISP metaprograms in LISP. But I can't code C++ metaprograms in C++, I have to use this weird duck-typed functional template language which doesn't have even loops or conditionals.

Re:Swift 2.2 Released by pjmlp on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @07:44AM (#11343556)
That weird duck typed functional template language runs circles around C# and Java generics.

I have experience in compiler design and C#, Java and C++ are my tools of trade. So I know their generics systems pretty well.

Maybe if I get bored during Easter I can bother to provide your safe list.

Re:Swift 2.2 Released by pkolaczk on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @09:56AM (#11344435)
> That weird duck typed functional template language runs circles around C# and Java generics

This sentence doesn't make much sense. Comparing oranges and apples. It is like saying Scala macros are better than Scala generics. C++ templates are neither great at metaprogramming (there are much better macro systems in other languages out there) nor great at generics (Java, C# or Swift generics are not state-of-the-art either, but in some cases I mentioned they are better).