Rather than inequality, the problem is really that the bottom end of the range is too low. There are too many people who are not able to find enough work to provide an adequate income. There's a litany of social and economic reasons for that, but that is the problem, not the inequality itself.
The second network capital is concentrated and I borrow $100,000 dollar from two people (mediated by a bank) and buy a home.
Now I need to pay that capital back, with intererest. I can only do that by making shoes for people. Which network am I going to have a harder time doing that in? The one with 1000 people who have $200 saved in the bank? Or the one that has 2 people who have $100,000 in the bank?
Assume all people in the example have two feet.
Maybe that person is Bill Gates. Maybe it is the Koch brothers. But unless you strongly believe wealth correlates to competency and good will, it seems the system will inevitably attract abuse (power corrupts).
It may also be a problem for those other reasons, but that's not necessary for it to be a problem.
(People often mistake output and consumption measures of typical economic statistics for direct measures of experienced utilities. While they are proxies for utility, they are imperfect proxies, and one of the ways we know they are flawed is that they do not account for the disutility that directly results from inequality.)
Economists regularly use "Pareto Optimality" to solve for an optimal steady state or x-possibility frontier - a state/allocation where it is impossible to make any one person better off without making another worse off. Do you think this is a fair or useful way to determine the optimal allocation of resources?
If your solutions isn't Pareto optimal, that means we can make someone better off for Free.
Of course, just because something is Pareto optimal, doesn't mean it's the best solution. But the best solution is DEFINITELY going to be Pareto optimal.
> There is no optimum level of equality than can be solved for using a mathematical equation
This is not true: We can choose any function to maximize. As you correctly point out, the usefulness depends upon the validity of the quantity we're trying to maximize.
I don't know enough to say if Pareto efficiency is optimal here or not.
This is only true if one assumes private property and resource equality at the same time. If one abandons private property and tries to imagine systems of resource distribution based on democratic processes, there are far more possibilities. One possibility that obviously doesn't work out is a command economy where a centralized bureaucratic state owns everything. These systems seem to have similar dysfunctions to a megacorporation that owns everything in a country. We've never seen a decentralized, democratic system of communal property at large scale because they're always destroyed by violent means by other systems if they get too big.
A sprawling centralized state bureaucracy is none of those things. Indeed, the whole departure of Leninism from Marxism is the idea of a vanguard party transitioning from capitalism to communism via a state apparatus. It's a fundamentally elitist doctrine that quite obviously did not work the way it was presupposed to work.
It's not like people don't talk about capitalism in heavily idealized terms, either. I've never seen an exegesis of liberalism that doesn't elide the pervasive and frequent expropriation and violent enforcement required to prevent the system from falling over.
I doubt that the answer would be 'one where everyone is exactly equal,' because we do have differing physical and intellectual capabilities which would mean that if everyone was exactly equal, we would be under-allocating resources to certain people. On the other hand, it's almost assuredly true that the level of inequality we have now is just too high. The difficulty is in finding the exact equation to maximize.