At this point her actions become a lot easier to understand.
If you disagree with this assertion, please provide a link where govt is asking for that.
The implication that this is just about one phone is what is so demonstrably false. And it is people like you who we must seek to inform. The FBI has hundreds, if not thousands of iPhones they wish to unlock in this manner. Google it.
Further, what the DOJ does not understand is that if Apple provides the tool for opening this phone, then the government and any hackers who get ahold of that tool will be able to access any phone with the same specifications. As Tim Cook puts it, it'd be the software equivalent of cancer.
Regarding it being like cancer - why? How can it not be like smallpox? What is hard about clean rooming these phones and hacking them?
Specifics please.
On Tuesday, Comey said the FBI is asking for access to that specific phone but understood the decision would set a precedent for similar cases.
Asked how many iPhones the FBI would like Apple to unlock, Comey said he could not name a number but that there were "a lot" of phones that hold information needed for law enforcement investigations.
http://www.reuters.com/article/apple-encryption-congress-com...
Surely it's going to become a burden if the government has to go through Apple for every single unlock request - there may be thousands of them, so for convenience, why wouldn't they demand the software to do it themselves?
It seems like gaining access to this dead guy's phone is not really what the FBI is after - they can already get his call records and SMS's from the carriers, there's not likely to be any actionable information left on the phone.
The point I'm trying to make (repeatedly through this thread, which everyone seems to ignore) is that this is a pretty reasonable request.
Notice that it becoming a burden for the govt to request this through Apple every time is in no way a reason why the govt would legally be allowed to "demand the software to do it themselves". In fact, as every single case would require a court order, the hassle of the court order is likely a magnitude greater than asking Apple to comply.
For the govt to "demand the software to do it themselves" would be an entirely new court case. In fact, it is this very case that I do not want to see.
So when Apple makes the iPhone 7 such that even Apple cannot unlock the phone what happens?
The point I'm trying to make relates to the facts as they are before us.
She does not understand that even if the FBI can get into every Apple phone, criminals can simply choose another form of encryption software to accomplish means of hiding their communications. Assuming the FBI can force Apple to install a key logger to grant them access into encrypted apps, will the FBI then go after Samsung and HTC which are made outside the US?
The whole thing is absurd and a waste of our time. The way in which the FBI is going about this is not going to get them what they want.
I don't know how to get them what they want. That's their job to figure it out. But they should know better about encryption technology. Or someone should tell them. This has gone on too long.