News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by x5n1 on Saturday March 12, 2016 @06:48PM (#11275355)
In another words totalitarian governments should be reformed. Laws did not come into existence on their own. They were implemented by governments that don't respect the will of the people.
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by nickff on Saturday March 12, 2016 @06:56PM (#11275390)
It may surprise you to hear that most citizens do not care about privacy, and actually support government surveillance, for a variety of reasons. If you want a simple gauge of whether the public supports a measure without wanting to read through polls, just look for a signing ceremony, and the date of passage. Unpopular or politically risky things (like releasing Hillary Clinton's e-mails) are done just before major holidays or events, and popular measures are enacted Monday-Wednesday on a quiet week (, whereas the largest group of Clinton's e-mails were released the day before the Super Bowl).
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by striking on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:17PM (#11275451)
Let's do some research!

Pew Research states that "A majority of Americans (54%) disapprove of the U.S. government’s collection of telephone and internet data as part of anti-terrorism efforts".[1]

So, right off the bat, we know that most people care about privacy. And maybe this meme that so many people are uncaring or ignorant about privacy will eventually die.

1: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/05/29/what-america...

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by ktRolster on Saturday March 12, 2016 @08:51PM (#11275753)
I see your poll, and raise you another! 60% favor renewal of the bulk-data-collection programs. (Ha! Since 60% is higher than 54% I win! That's how you do statistics, right?) http://kron4.com/2015/06/01/poll-6-in-10-back-renewal-of-nsa...

Interesting thing about all these polls, it's not split on party lines. The two major parties (and independents as well) are divided about whether they favor or oppose it.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by striking on Saturday March 12, 2016 @09:07PM (#11275789)
Great find! So I may be wrong, but at least we can agree that the outlook isn't as bleak as some people think.
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by nickff on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:24PM (#11275471)
This is a snapshot, when the issue has been brought to the fore; if you look at the historical data, it appears that people were more comfortable with continuous monitoring and intrusions in the past, and that they will again become more comfortable with it in the future.
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by striking on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:38PM (#11275509)
They were fine with it until they realized their private pictures and everything else belonging to them on the web were accessible to the government. In other words, no one cared until they were made to care. No one knew the government was watching, and people who thought they were had no evidence.

But that's tangential to the fact that a statistic has poked a hole through your argument about today's day and age, for which you haven't provided a counterargument. Is there a logical reason you think that people "will again become more comfortable with it" or is it just a hunch?

I'm tired of the nonsense and FUD surrounding American attitudes towards privacy.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by nickff on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:46PM (#11275535)
I actually looked up the Pew polling data before posting. You found a contradictory point, but not a solid case. Look at the public's reactions to the 'Echelon' program for instance, and you will see their revulsion is ephemeral. In addition, the average citizen is against general surveillance, but in favor of suspect surveillance (as you will find if you look at the data a little more closely). The only way this works is to have backdoors, which everyone here knows are flawed.
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Sunday March 13, 2016 @01:26AM (#11276497)
Or in other words: People always see themselves as good, then naively assume that therefore everyone else does, too, and that therefore obviously nobody would want to watch them, and therefore agree that surveillance of bad people is ok, as it couldn't possibly ever affect themselves. People generally aren't actually ok with surveillance, but rather they don't understand the dynamics of surveillance and thus ultimately don't actually understand the question they are answering in such a poll.
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday March 12, 2016 @08:01PM (#11275586)
> The only way this works is to have backdoors

That is a lie. Targeted surveillance is easy if you can justify spending more resources per person than would be economical for mass surveillance. Because you don't need their own device to do the surveillance, you can use your device. Put a bug where the suspect is. You'll get surveillance of them entering their passphrase and then you can decrypt their device with it. No backdoor required.

The Apple case is bizarre because the suspect is dead. Normally you don't investigate the dead because it's hard for the government to punish them.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by striking on Saturday March 12, 2016 @08:05PM (#11275604)
This is the kind of discourse I was looking for! Is there anywhere I can read about the public's reactions to Echelon?

And in terms of suspect surveillance, do you mean terrorist suspects? While it is true that most Americans are okay with terrorist surveillance (e.g. 64% think it's acceptable, ibid.) I don't think that equates with supporting blanket 4th-amendment-breaking government surveillance on US citizens.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by x5n1 on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:03PM (#11275410)
I think other than a minority, the majority in the US that consume digital goods are willing to not respect copyright when acquiring them, so they don't care about copyright much more so and then don't wish to be prosecuted for it. In fact you will have a very hard time finding majority support for prosecution of copyright violation. In terms of money laundering most Americans don't care for their finances to be constantly monitored, and will not support such policies.

Surveillance and privacy are a different issue, because it's not really possible to properly frame it in terms of most American's activities. You can frame it as a way to get drug dealers, junkies, the terrorists. So obviously when you put it that way you can get support.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by wildmusings on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:08PM (#11275425)
>In fact you will have a very hard time finding majority support for persecution of copyright violation.

I think it's a little more nuanced than that. Most people might not support criminal prosecution for individuals downloading movies, but I think a majority would definitely support prosecuting someone that made thousands of dollars from copyright infringement.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by elorant on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:06PM (#11275419)
Why do we keep assuming that people don’t care about privacy? Perhaps they care just not the way we do because we’re more informed. The average user doesn’t have the technical background to realize how companies are monitoring him online, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that if he knew he wouldn’t give a damn. From another point of view perhaps the main reason a great part of society is skeptical towards technology could be exactly because they fear it could steal away their privacy.
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by mikeash on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:17PM (#11275453)
I think just about everybody cares about privacy, but many care about it so differently that it looks a lot like not caring.

A lot of it comes down to essentially having faith in law enforcement. Basically, "if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear." Nobody wants to be watched while they get dressed or use the toilet, but government surveillance is looking for criminal activity. People don't mind it, because they're not criminals.

Another big chunk is what I'd call theoretical versus practical privacy. The NSA is capturing all our phone calls and internet activity. Us techies typically see this as a massive invasion of privacy, because NSA employees might be looking through all our stuff. I think the average man on the street does not see it as a massive invasion of privacy, because NSA employees probably aren't looking through all of their stuff, as they have more important stuff to do.

And then there's just the question of tradeoffs. We usually see government surveillance as a huge invasion of privacy with little if any benefit. Lots of people see it as a minor invasion of privacy with a huge law-and-order benefit.

I think just about everybody cares about privacy, but that doesn't necessarily translate into opposing government surveillance.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by nitrogen on Saturday March 12, 2016 @09:55PM (#11275945)
People don't mind it, because they're not criminals.

This should be called the "other people" fallacy, the idea that bad things only happen to someone else. Similar to the just world fallacy. How could we get people to understand these fallacies?

probably aren't looking through all of their stuff

We understand that the risks are not just from humans creeping on us, but also inscrutable secret algorithms monitoring and/or influencing people in ways we may not agree with. Also, potential abuse just about as important as actual abuse, since we don't know who will have access in the future.

minor invasion of privacy with a huge law-and-order benefit.

Maybe this can be countered by demanding numbers, with documentation backing up the numbers. How many crimes were solved, or terrorist plots foiled, by invading our privacy, that could not have been solved otherwise? And even if that number is significantly greater than zero, what is the societal cost, and is that societal cost justified by the numbers?

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by mikeash on Saturday March 12, 2016 @10:19PM (#11276029)
Is your "other people" fallacy actually a fallacy?

I mean, if the authorities really are just looking for criminals, and you really are not a criminal, then it doesn't seem to me that this reasoning is fallacious at all.

Where it falls down is when the authorities overreach and go after non-criminals, or when "criminal" gets so broadly defined that everybody qualifies when the authorities want them to.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by mike_hearn on Sunday March 13, 2016 @12:16PM (#11278170)
> Where it falls down is when the authorities overreach

Which in practice, in the west doesn't happen that often (to people who live there - I am not considering drone strikes etc for now).

The concerns about what the NSA are doing are serious, real and I fully share them. But I will happily admit that it is hard to convince someone who doesn't care at the moment, because

a) Everything done with the data is secret, so giving people examples of abuses is hard.

b) The worst problems are mostly what could happen rather than what is happening.

Even Edward Snowden called it "turn-key totalitarianism", that is, there's huge potential but the US is not yet a totalitarian state.

Of course the problem is, if one day the problems caused by massive automated surveillance are so clear that everyone dislikes it, almost by definition it'll be too late.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by mikeash on Sunday March 13, 2016 @12:36PM (#11278246)
I must confess that I don't find the (b) arguments very convincing. I generally oppose these mass surveillance programs, but just on principle and because they seem like a massive waste of resources.

The notion of "turn-key totalitarianism" just doesn't make much sense to me. Let's say the US elected Hitler II. (Hitler Jr.?) With the current situation, he could turn the NSA surveillance apparatus into a method of control. In a world where the government didn't have these mass surveillance capabilities, then he couldn't. Except I imagine the first thing he'd do would be to build them. So we'd get, what, a year or two under a totalitarian regime without mass surveillance, then we're back where we'd be anyway. Yay?

It feels a lot like the gun nuts' argument that the Second Amendment exists so we can overthrow the government if it turns tyrannical. It's planning for failure, and it won't work anyway. Much better to concentrate on getting good people into political office, and keeping the system itself in good shape so that bad people can't fuck it up too much.

Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by mike_hearn on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @01:37PM (#11299141)
"He'd just build them" is a huge stretch. Remember who we're dealing with here - guys like Trump are not technology experts and do not really have any conception of what's possible, until the tech guys actually build it and say, hey, check this out. We can hack every phone in the USA and turn its microphone on remotely.
Re:Anti-money laundering laws and copyright laws are similar... by nitrogen on Sunday March 13, 2016 @12:51AM (#11276414)
or when "criminal" gets so broadly defined that everybody qualifies when the authorities want them to.

Right, this is the scenario I was trying to suggest. And as someone who has had some above median but still indirect involvement with politics in the past, I have to worry about the probability of this going up with proximity to people planning on running for office, or journalists, etc.