Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by Kenji on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:15PM
(#11273816)
It's not just that. By accepting bitcoin, even if you change them to USD right away, you run a currency risk if BTC suddenly loses value. Also, when is a BTC transaction validated? Yeah, they have eventual consistency, but doublespending is actually possible. How long must the chain be after a transaction for it to be valid? These are nontrivial questions and tradeoffs that the store owner has to do about risks.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:28PM
(#11273853)
Transactions are valid only when you trust you have the longest chain. If a longer chain comes along, you may abandon the shorter chain and believe the longer chain.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by Kenji on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:31PM
(#11273866)
Exactly. But when do you trust you have the longest chain? It could be that by some stroke of misfortune or malicious manipulation, a shorter chain suddenly catches up. Is a chain that is 10 links longer safe? As I said - eventual consistency. But when is eventually? This is a real issue for BTC transaction validation.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by jcoffland on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:21PM
(#11274079)
If the senaro you describe were remotely possible BitCoin would not exist. A chain more than a couple of blocks behind has almost no chance of catching up unless over 50% of the hashing power consolidated on the shorter chain. Since miners automatically abandon short chains and it is in their best interest to do so this is extremely unlikely.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by the_mitsuhiko on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:47PM
(#11274217)
What if mining pools would deliberately hold back mint blocks until they find more? That way they could invalidate transactions if they like.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 12, 2016 @03:05PM
(#11274282)
You can only hold a mint block until right before another block arrives. Once another block is known your mint block is garbage.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by the_mitsuhiko on Saturday March 12, 2016 @04:59PM
(#11274804)
> You can only hold a mint block until right before another block arrives. Once another block is known your mint block is garbage.
What controls this?
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 12, 2016 @06:46PM
(#11275346)
Each block must incorporate the hash from the previous block.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by the_mitsuhiko on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:23PM
(#11275467)
So what stops you from mining ahead secretly?
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 12, 2016 @11:19PM
(#11276189)
As colejohnson said, the difficulty. The network, as a whole, expects to generate 1 block approximately every 10 minutes. Someone with less than 50% of the network power will never be able to sustainably mint a longer chain of 'fake' blocks before someone else mints a legit one.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by the_mitsuhiko on Sunday March 13, 2016 @04:48AM
(#11276817)
> As colejohnson said, the difficulty. The network, as a whole, expects to generate 1 block approximately every 10 minutes. Someone with less than 50% of the network power will never be able to sustainably mint a longer chain of 'fake' blocks before someone else mints a legit one.
If you look at the blocks mined you can see that there are plenty of mining groups that manage to mine consecutive blocks: https://blockchain.info/blocks
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by jsprogrammer on Sunday March 13, 2016 @01:49PM
(#11278569)
Mining a few consecutive blocks isn't enough. All it itakes is one known block to cancel all the witheld blocks. Additionally, the attacks you can perform by extending a known chain a few more 'fake' blocks are minimal.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by colejohnson66 on Saturday March 12, 2016 @10:29PM
(#11276058)
My guess is the difficulty of making a block means it would take too long
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore
by droffel on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:23PM
(#11274087)
Usually, 1 confirmation is enough. 6 confirmations is considered enough for any amount. Most exchanges are comfortable with letting you use your coins in 2-3 confirmations, and they tend to be very high risk businesses in the space.