News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by echelon on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:07PM (#11273786)
Does anyone have any idea why this is? Have companies moved on from considering Bitcoin something serious?

I imagine their Bitcoin code was too expensive to maintain relative to the transaction volume it brought. Could this be a sign of things to come from other companies that support Bitcoin, and if others follow in Microsoft's footsteps, does this impact Bitcoin at all?

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by LukeHoersten on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:34PM (#11273880)
My guess is that they gave it a try and the purchase volumes never materially compared to credit card payments. Integration was done very poorly. You had to go to a special link "commerce.microsoft.com" and click on a small, un-styled link at the bottom of the page called "Redeem bitcoins". It was never integrated in to their main purchase flow in an easy way. It couldn't be found just by chance. You had to google to figure out how to fund with bitcoin.

Edit: There are a handful of comments about price fluctuation. Microsoft liquidated to USD right away using a company called BitPay. BitPay would take on the short term price risk and Microsoft would get exactly what they quoted in USD. Microsoft was not subject to BTCUSD price fluctuation in this scheme.

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by aaachilless on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:53PM (#11273950)
It probably has something to do with their support of Ethereum.

https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/blog/ethereum-blockchain-a...

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by valhalla on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:21PM (#11273838)
If the Microsoft was liquidating bit coin the way planetjones describes, it was probably too inconvenient since the exchange rate (Bitcoin to $) would fluctuate so unpredictably and wildy (at times) there was no way to reliably exchange bitcoins for the exact amount customers were charged.

If the exchange rate was too low, MSFT would lose money. If it was too high, they'd be breaking a number of very basic but important laws that are designed to protect consumers.

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by LukeHoersten on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:36PM (#11273892)
Microsoft did liquidate to USD right away using a company called BitPay. BitPay would take on the short term price risk and Microsoft would get exactly what they quoted in USD. Microsoft was not subject to BTCUSD price fluctuation in this scheme.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by bunderbunder on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:42PM (#11273914)
That said, just by eyeballing some graphs at Coinbase it looks to me like the exchange rate was a more volatile back when Microsoft started accepting Bitcoin than it is now. Which isn't to say that they couldn't reasonably decide that it's too volatile, but it does seem odd that they'd do so while the volatility's dropping rather than increasing.

I'm inclined to guess that all the BTC in the news just led them to a more fundamental reconsideration of their bet that it is (or will become) a viable unit of exchange. There are a lot of take-aways you could get from recent events that might lead to that decision, but the most fundamental one is simply that it's become clear that a huge portion of the people controlling Bitcoin's future don't want it to become one.

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by valhalla on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:29PM (#11273856)
November 29th 2013 (A week after the Xbox One release) 1 Bitcoin == $1216.73.

By December the same year the price "[had] crashed to $600, rebounded to $1,000, crashed again to the $500 range. Stabilized to the ~$650–$800 range."

Here's a graph showing the rate from July '13 to June '15:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Bitcoin#/media/File....

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by the_mitsuhiko on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:35PM (#11273888)
> Does anyone have any idea why this is?

I wouldn't be surprised if they had a contract with a payment provider that was just too expensive for the little to no revenue that came in via bitcoin. Other than people that got bitcoin early there are not really any bitcoin users out there.

Also pretty sure that handling refunds and customer support for failed payments must have been pretty involved.

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by elorant on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:19PM (#11273829)
Could be related to recent development in Bitcoin as it reaches the 1MB limit and transactions take up to ten hours to be cleared.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by dinkumthinkum on Saturday March 12, 2016 @03:28PM (#11274387)
But, and I mean this in a nice way, why would people consider Bitcoin to be something "serious" in terms of an actual currency? It is always on HN but it is like an interesting hobby for them, I guess. I also understand there are startups that have built "businesses" off of it, but it is sort of reminiscent of those businesses that sell the currencies from MMORPGs.

I think Bitcoin is really meant for geeks to play with and argue and start massive flamewars over zero-knowledge proof engines and all this kind of stuff, rather than an actual real currency of the world. I guess there is an element of something like Goldbugs, but we were discussing being "serious," right?

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by pash on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:19PM (#11274074)
Microsoft seem to be more interested in Ethereum [0]. They introduced an Ethereum blockchain-as-a-service offering on Azure [1] last year, and they are working with R3 [2] and some other Ethereum-using players in the much-hyped blockchain space. They seem to have decided that Ethereum is a better solution than Bitcoin for a broad set of applications, and they're probably right.

I do think Microsoft's move is indicative of growing disaffectation with Bitcoin. Bitcoin's community has been a cauldron of discontent for the better part of two years now. It's a mess, but it's not just about the blocksize. What most scares investors and technologists is that Bitcoin's development team appears to be beholden to the interests of a single company, and still worse, has disavowed making basic changes to the protocol. But basic changes are needed to enable many of the sorts of things that people dream of doing with blockchains—at least if they're going to be done with Bitcoin's blockchain.

Meanwhile Ethereum and several other competitors are maturing into good alternatives. Ethereum is a much nicer platform for programmatic money. Dash [3], Monero [4], and new projects like Zcash [5] are in some ways technically superior to Bitcoin as currencies and payment networks. At the same time, many speculators have fled bitcoin, fearing a gridlocked community and technical stasis; they've put their money into other crypto-assets, driving up their valuations. The price of ether, Ethereum's underlying asset, has skyrocketed lately, to a valuation of over $1 billion. About half a dozen altcoins have risen enormously in value over the past several months, and higher valuations bring more interest. With more interest comes more use, and with more use comes more infrastructure; Bitcoin's first-mover advantage narrows.

There was a time when I thought Bitcoin would be able to incorporate proven technical improvements from other systems, and by maintaining its technical competitiveness in that way also be able to maintain its network effect. I no longer think that. If Bitcoin can't purge its demons, other systems will out-compete it.

0. https://www.ethereum.org

1. https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/blog/ethereum-blockchain-a...

2. https://r3cev.com

3. https://www.dash.org

4. https://getmonero.org/home

5. https://z.cash

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by deftnerd on Saturday March 12, 2016 @04:51PM (#11274766)
Microsoft seems intent on supporting Blockchains as a service, but that doesn't mean that they're going to accept them internally on a business level.

Microsoft's Blockchain platform on Azure currently supports Bitcoin, Bitshares, Ethereum, Emercoin, OpenLedger, Ripple, Factom, Eris, Coinprism, and more.

Just because they now support Ethereum as a service doesn't mean that they're validating Ethereum and plan to incorporate deep within their business units. It also doesn't mean that they think it's better than Bitcoin.

On a personal level, I'm quite excited by Ethereum and am more and more dejected by Bitcoin these days.

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by jkyle on Saturday March 12, 2016 @03:18PM (#11274341)
I don't think these companies ever considered Bitcoin as serious currency. More likely it's more about publicity and maintaining an image of being on the techno hipster edge.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by stevewilhelm on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:50PM (#11273940)
> Does anyone have any idea why this is?

I wonder about the accounting and tax ramifications of transactions done in Bitcoin.

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by pmorici on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:57PM (#11273974)
There really aren't any outside of the normal. A company like Microsoft isn't holding the bitcoin they are immediately exchanging it so it is no different than taking USD since they don't make any gain or loss on the BTC.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by dheera on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:41PM (#11274187)
In which case there's really no point to them using bitcoin. If they're converting it to USD immediately, they derive no benefit by using a decentralized currency.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by pmorici on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @08:28AM (#11289082)
Sure they do. There is no charge back or fraud risk for the merchant with Bitcoin. It lets you service customers that might otherwise be too risky because they happen to fit a profile that correlates to high fraud risk.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by ethagknight on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:11PM (#11273805)
Or could it be related to real/perceived risk in holding and trading bitcoins?
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by Kenji on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:15PM (#11273816)
It's not just that. By accepting bitcoin, even if you change them to USD right away, you run a currency risk if BTC suddenly loses value. Also, when is a BTC transaction validated? Yeah, they have eventual consistency, but doublespending is actually possible. How long must the chain be after a transaction for it to be valid? These are nontrivial questions and tradeoffs that the store owner has to do about risks.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:28PM (#11273853)
Transactions are valid only when you trust you have the longest chain. If a longer chain comes along, you may abandon the shorter chain and believe the longer chain.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by Kenji on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:31PM (#11273866)
Exactly. But when do you trust you have the longest chain? It could be that by some stroke of misfortune or malicious manipulation, a shorter chain suddenly catches up. Is a chain that is 10 links longer safe? As I said - eventual consistency. But when is eventually? This is a real issue for BTC transaction validation.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by jcoffland on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:21PM (#11274079)
If the senaro you describe were remotely possible BitCoin would not exist. A chain more than a couple of blocks behind has almost no chance of catching up unless over 50% of the hashing power consolidated on the shorter chain. Since miners automatically abandon short chains and it is in their best interest to do so this is extremely unlikely.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by the_mitsuhiko on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:47PM (#11274217)
What if mining pools would deliberately hold back mint blocks until they find more? That way they could invalidate transactions if they like.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 12, 2016 @03:05PM (#11274282)
You can only hold a mint block until right before another block arrives. Once another block is known your mint block is garbage.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by the_mitsuhiko on Saturday March 12, 2016 @04:59PM (#11274804)
> You can only hold a mint block until right before another block arrives. Once another block is known your mint block is garbage.

What controls this?

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 12, 2016 @06:46PM (#11275346)
Each block must incorporate the hash from the previous block.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by the_mitsuhiko on Saturday March 12, 2016 @07:23PM (#11275467)
So what stops you from mining ahead secretly?
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 12, 2016 @11:19PM (#11276189)
As colejohnson said, the difficulty. The network, as a whole, expects to generate 1 block approximately every 10 minutes. Someone with less than 50% of the network power will never be able to sustainably mint a longer chain of 'fake' blocks before someone else mints a legit one.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by the_mitsuhiko on Sunday March 13, 2016 @04:48AM (#11276817)
> As colejohnson said, the difficulty. The network, as a whole, expects to generate 1 block approximately every 10 minutes. Someone with less than 50% of the network power will never be able to sustainably mint a longer chain of 'fake' blocks before someone else mints a legit one.

If you look at the blocks mined you can see that there are plenty of mining groups that manage to mine consecutive blocks: https://blockchain.info/blocks

Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by jsprogrammer on Sunday March 13, 2016 @01:49PM (#11278569)
Mining a few consecutive blocks isn't enough. All it itakes is one known block to cancel all the witheld blocks. Additionally, the attacks you can perform by extending a known chain a few more 'fake' blocks are minimal.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by colejohnson66 on Saturday March 12, 2016 @10:29PM (#11276058)
My guess is the difficulty of making a block means it would take too long
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by droffel on Saturday March 12, 2016 @02:23PM (#11274087)
Usually, 1 confirmation is enough. 6 confirmations is considered enough for any amount. Most exchanges are comfortable with letting you use your coins in 2-3 confirmations, and they tend to be very high risk businesses in the space.
Re:Microsoft Store doesn't accept Bitcoin anymore by eterm on Saturday March 12, 2016 @01:45PM (#11273923)
Almost certainly just low volume. Most merchants offering sale by bitcoin had little to no use.

And it makes sense, most bitcoin owners bought to speculate. Spending bitcoin isn't that different to just selling the bitcoin and spending with actual money, so if they weren't going to sell their bitcoin, why spend their bitcoin?

It's not like middlemen payment processors were avoided, most companies accepting bitcoin actually just accepted through a third party who would liquidate it back to money directly.