It shows how much of his own lifestyle he is potentially sacrificing. To take it to the extreme: if he was giving up all his wealth to his employees, you would treat it differently to if he was giving 0.01%.
Edit: I think this is the most controversial comment I've ever made on HN. It keeps going up and down between -2 and +8..... I wonder why it's so polarising?
Some believe that "good" giving means giving a large portion of what you have, not a small fraction.
Others believe a gift is good gift, no matter how small.
Others believe a $14mm gift is good because of how large it is, regardless of whether or not it's 0.01% or 100% of his net worth.
Others take offense when people try to dictate theirs or others lives by claiming a kind or charitable act is insufficient because it doesn't put out the giver as much as they should like.
And there are probably other ways to look at it as well.
This sort of debate always crops up when rich people donate money.
Some people internalized that to mean that gifts without sacrifice were worthless, but that was, in my opinion, the wrong take away. Every gift and every kindness has value, regardless of how hard it is to give. Its impact however can be moderated somewhat by the amount of sacrifice behind it.
And as most people also recognize that failing to provide the kindness when the sacrifice is minimal, is its own kind of problem.
Even with the potential personal gain, imo there isn't much to criticize here. It's not like a majority shareholder getting a one time special dividend (I'm looking at you, PE funds) or something obviously sinister like that.
Also, I challenge you to find anyone who has been CEO of a publicly traded company for more than a year who isn't also independently wealthy.
A perhaps unintentional critique of charity itself.
It's two different ways of looking at charity. "Glass half empty" type of thing.
Sure, there's the possibility this act is purely for optics and employee retention. But if that's what drives people to be good human beings you won't catch me complaining.
And the "worth noting" section in this article is curious as well. Why does any amount of personal wealth degrade the value of this act? It's like the writer is saying "don't be impressed folks, this guy is still rich."
We should encourage and support acts like this, not couch our praise in snark and envy.