News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by danielvf on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @05:19PM (#11213494)
So we have an app that tracks on an hourly basis the following: people who hire against the law, people who work against the law, people who don't withhold income tax on wages, and people who don't report income to the IRS. All in a beautifully supeanable electronic format.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by cheese1756 on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @11:07PM (#11214963)
Since the developers have been working on the app for three years, I'm sure that they've built in safeguards. One simple fix that comes to mind is to store all data locally, except for the database of abusive employers. If people want to contact lawyers to recover lost wages, all of the information in the app is kept private since attorney-client confidentiality kicks in. With something like that, there is no additional risk to using the app.

P.S. This is not a criticism of you or your comment, danielvf (I think that the point you brought up is valid). One thing that does bother me about Hacker News, though, is that the top comment is almost always a rejection of the innovation at hand. The hacker part of Hacker News should be about improving imperfect systems, not instinctively criticizing and rejecting them. I feel like HN would be a much more interesting site and much truer to its culture if every critical comment had to include a potential fix for the criticism. If someone can't come up with a potential fix to add, then they haven't done enough research to justify making the comment in the first place.

Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by moonshinefe on Thursday March 03, 2016 @03:27AM (#11215655)
"Since the developers have been working on the app for three years, I'm sure that they've built in safeguards."

In my experience assuming people are competent in their security is usually a really really optimistic view point and very often untrue.

Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by PhasmaFelis on Thursday March 03, 2016 @03:14PM (#11219664)
The "lead organizer who helped develop the app" is a Mexican immigrant and (former?) laborer, so hopefully they are at least more in touch with the needs of their market.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by GauntletWizard on Thursday March 03, 2016 @12:28AM (#11215200)
The flaws (or potential flaws) in a given system are almost always more interesting to discuss than the ways in which it has succeeded. Praises ring soft, criticism is fun to debate.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by cheese1756 on Thursday March 03, 2016 @02:15AM (#11215476)
I agree that it can be interesting and useful to discuss flaws, but potential solutions are what make the discussion worthwhile. Saying "This will never work for X, Y, and Z reasons" creates a much less interesting debate than "This has flaw X, but I think it could be solved by this change. What do you think?"

It frequently appears that people react negatively on HN purely based on instinct, without doing any research. The response to Dropbox's launch is particularly illuminating: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863 (I think that every Dropbox user can point out half a dozen ways it is better than FTP or a USB stick)

All of the criticism on the Dropbox post is addressable, but the discussion would have been a lot more interesting if the original commenters pointed out solutions themselves. That shifts the discussion from a feeling of "This will never work" to "Cool idea! Here's how you can make it better." The latter, and not the former, is important to the culture of HN.

Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by a3n on Thursday March 03, 2016 @08:49AM (#11216775)
You're right, it is important to remember to give credit.

But for many of the people here, getting something "right" is an explicit and fundamental part of what we do. It's a specific, on purpose focus. So it's natural (and good) that we'd think that way.

Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by mc32 on Thursday March 03, 2016 @12:48AM (#11215253)
That's exactly my thought. It's like a submarine way to rat people out. You hook them on one pretext and then you can turn around and sell the data to the IRS so they can get the tax cheats and on the other hand sell data to ICE to get people who jump in front of the immigration line in trouble. Win win win, for them, lose for the cheaters, and the cheated.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by xbmcuser on Saturday March 05, 2016 @09:11AM (#11229538)
Well they are getting away with not paying as the worker won't or can't complain. Now the worker will have his own leverage so will cancel out cheating.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by SilasX on Thursday March 03, 2016 @08:34AM (#11216696)
Yeah I think it misses the core problem with day labor, which is that the victims of any such shenanigans are themselves unwilling to report it because they are breaking immigration and taxation laws. Reporting it -- via this app or otherwise -- can make them much worse off.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by Eridrus on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @07:59PM (#11214328)
These day labor spots are well known enough for employers to find them, I don't think this will add significant exposure to these people.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by sigmar on Thursday March 03, 2016 @01:15AM (#11215321)
> people who hire against the law, people who work against the law

Day labor is not illegal.

Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by danielvf on Thursday March 03, 2016 @08:09AM (#11216589)
You are correct, it's not illegal, and it serves a very useful purpose, however it's highly correlated with not paying taxes on both sides, and with hiring people who cannot legally work.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by hga on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @05:56PM (#11213737)
Yeah, I can imagine a YUGE use case for this data starting in slightly less than one year.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by Zikes on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @11:37PM (#11215050)
Additionally, both the Apple App Store and Google Play Store have clauses against using apps that are intended to enable illegal activity. Their best hope to ensure it doesn't get taken down is to make it a web app.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by Matt3o12_ on Thursday March 03, 2016 @03:55AM (#11215740)
It should not be an issue if the data is stored Mexico and all traffic is going through HTTP.

I don't think law enforcement is able to extract data for illegal immigrants from Mexico. They aren't terrorist after all.

Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by EliRivers on Thursday March 03, 2016 @04:46AM (#11215888)
I expect that the argument they're terrorists could be made if that's what the authorities required.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by Matt3o12_ on Sunday March 06, 2016 @07:03PM (#11236277)
It could not be used in court, though, and putting all immigrants in some of CIA's secret prisons (if the exists) would be even more expensive for the tax payer.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by x5n1 on Thursday March 03, 2016 @01:35AM (#11215380)
Whatever, I have no sympathy for employers who exploit people like these or actually any people. More reason for them to play nice.
Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by pc86 on Thursday March 03, 2016 @08:33AM (#11216693)
Day labor is not illegal.

And I think the point was that this data is potentially one subpoena away from getting a list of illegal immigrants (who themselves would be very susceptible to exploitation).

Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by flashman on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @11:02PM (#11214946)
I'm not certain that any crackdowns that drive up the price of labor, and cost votes from the immigrant community, will get off the ground.

Then again, Donald Trump could get elected.

Re:New Weapon in Day Laborers’ Fight Against Wage Theft: A S... by bruceb on Thursday March 03, 2016 @01:25AM (#11215351)
It depends if your labor is going up in demand/price.