News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by bsbechtel on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:16AM (#11203628)
One theory here is that it is easy to predict basic needs for a population, and thus let the government control the production of those - food, shelter, medicine, etc. For an extremely simplified example, you have 1 billion people in China, so you need to build 1 billion housing units. That is going to keep a lot of people very busy for 20+ years.

Once the general population's needs move beyond basic necessities, it becomes much harder for a central authority to predict what will be needed by it's citizens. Services, entertainment, and consumer goods are all highly dependent on many more variables than shelter and food are.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by tdaltonc on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:39AM (#11203846)
That perspective was Hayek's primary contribution to economics. Markets are not just short-term allocation systems. In the medium and long term, their primary function is to collect, compute, and communicate granular information about what is wanted where.

Bureaucrats can compile reports on the broad strokes in static systems, and by doing it without wastes like marketing, or redundant infrastructure they could maybe even do those parts more efficiently than markets. But nothing beats a market for realtime servicing of rapidly moving demand (unless you ask the techno-utopian communists).

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by pash on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:48PM (#11205009)
"The Use of Knowledge in Society" [0], Hayek's famous essay on the subject, is an enjoyable 12-page read. I first read it as an undergraduate economics major, and it remains one of my favorite economics papers for its clear and simple insight into the role of markets as basic mechanisms of social organization.

If you want to get a feel for what the other side of things was like in Hayek's era, I recommend a curious book written a few years ago by Francis Spufford called Red Plenty [1], which illustrates (partly in fact, partly in fiction) the immense ambition of economists at Gosplan, and the even bigger task they faced, as they tried to modernize the Soviet economy of the 1950s and '60s.

0. https://www.aeaweb.org/aer/top20/35.4.519-530.pdf

1. http://www.redplenty.com/Front_page.html

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by bsbechtel on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:41PM (#11205471)
I'm a big fan of Hayek, however I don't think he ever discussed what I feel is the strongest argument against state-sponsored central planning - contingency planning. When the government decides it needs to be responsible for some basic human need because it is too important to be left up to the free market, such as food security or healthcare, it crowds out alternatives that actually behave as valuable insurance/backups to a primary provider of a given good or service. If/when the government fails at providing something as vital as food or water, there isn't much you can do when the government controls the means of production. If a natural monopoly exists, people are at least free to find alternatives on their own, and thus profit from them, should those managing that natural monopoly fail at their jobs.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by vlehto on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:44PM (#11204968)
I've been wondering if stuff like this was the reason for initial growth spur of soviet union. It was easy for Lenin to see in 1923 that the country needed steel, food, housing and railroads. If you just churn out that stuff, you can't go wrong too much. But once those markets we're saturated in the 70's, you had no data provided by the markets about what to do. So the soviet union was pretty much doomed to that level of GDP.

Now I imagine it would be still relatively easy to take a country like Peru, turn communist and simply churn out steel, food, housing, install internet cables and improve roads. But you would hit a wall in decade or two.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by tdaltonc on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:57PM (#11205581)
Today that's called "The State Development Capitalism Model" as opposed to the market-led capitalism model in "The Washington Consensus" and I think it has a lot to recommend it. But the hand-off to a first world economy and governance style is really really tricky (see the "middle income trap").
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by vlehto on Wednesday March 02, 2016 @06:48AM (#11209367)
Ah the good old "national socialism". It worked good for Nazis for a short while. But I don't think we have no long term data? Francoist Spain suffered from trade restrictions and Baathist countries used to benefit "unfairly" from oil.

I suspect the problem is the same. Your indicators get skewed if you accept them as goals. Bit like if you go to school, not for learning, but for getting good grades. It's going to kick you sooner or later, but at latest in academia.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by icebraining on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:28PM (#11204333)
For an extremely simplified example, you have 1 billion people in China, so you need to build 1 billion housing units.

Well, only if you want to have empty units, as there's (almost?) always more than one person per housing unit. How many? Well, that depends on the wealth of the household, on how many children they plan to have, on how many generation will be living with them.

And where should those houses be located? That depends on the (future!) employment opportunities, on the surrounding environment, on personal preferences, etc.

And what kind of zoning should there be applicable? US-style sprawling suburbs? High-density skyscrapers? Smaller towns? How dependent is that on other factors?

What building materials should be used? Is it better to build something cheap for now, betting on improving economic conditions for later rebuilding? Or is a medium-term solution better?

If a layman like me can think of a few dozen variables in 10 minutes, how many are actually there? How can one make a plan that accounts for the particulars of each of the billion?

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by bsbechtel on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:33PM (#11204375)
My example was extremely simplified, and my point was not that China's central planning is correct, working well, or a good idea. It was that it is easier to get away/justify central planning on basic necessities (especially when 500 million people don't even have access to these things) than more complicated luxuries that are more subject to individual tastes.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by jdihwjbbr on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:36PM (#11204916)
Your thought experiment was lazy and clearly illusionary. At most your comment has some explanatory power as to how the central governments and central banks of the world trick themselves into believing they can make intelligible decisions for billions.

Sheer hubris which costs millions of lives and needless poverty.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by nickff on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:33AM (#11203792)
You vastly overestimate the abilities of any central planner. Coordination through market prices is the only way to provide the goods you describe. If houses were a simple cube of bricks built in the same location every time, what you descibe might be feasible (though it would still be a challenge to design the bricks, select materials, and an assembly technique). Market pricing allows for relative valuation of different options, such as making waterfront homes in Manhattan more expensive than homes in Boise tend to be, or deciding how many strawberries should be grown off season in greenhouses, and how many factories should be dedicated to producing insulin (as well as which techniques should be used, as modern insulin techniques were created by a startup you may have heard of).

You make the production of basic necessities sound simple, while ignoring the great amount of evidence to the contrary, i.e. Kruschev's famous tour of the grocery store.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by rdl on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:25PM (#11204309)
As a counterexample: Military logistics tends to be centrally planned/standardized, not market based, and while it's rarely efficient, part of that has to do with the environment (where P(success) > unit price; it's perfectly ok to have ammunition which is marked up 100x at the front line vs. manufacturer's door if you're certain to have enough at the right time/place).
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by bsbechtel on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:31PM (#11204358)
The risk of not having ammunition is factored in to the price in this example. For the same reason, I may pay 2x for marketing collateral I need for a trade show from a local supplier instead of purchasing online because the risk of not having it for the show is reduced. The price of goods in a free market is never necessarily the same in all contexts where transactions take place.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:07PM (#11204655)
I spoke with military logistics folks about ten years ago. They told me that at one point, DoD had over 40,000 containers missing in Iraq.

40,000.

But yes, if you keep throwing money at a problem, it tends to go away. Or at least disappear.

For as long as there have been armies, good logistics continues to be a critical need. There's a reason large army deployments are always accompanied by large black markets.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by vinceguidry on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:16PM (#11204739)
Also, US military procurement could not possibly work without a free market in which they could buy supplies in. There's entirely too many different kinds of things they need, from uniforms to food to parts for materiel. It would be utterly impossible to manage the production and distribution of these things of these things without a robust market that rewards everyone involved.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by icebraining on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:42PM (#11204447)
The F-35 alone is $163 billion over budget, with each plane costing hundreds of millions. Meanwhile, the $77 billion F-22 planes have been barely used, and probably won't be in the near future.

But hey, as the Lockheed Martin VP says, "the best weapon is the one that's never used".

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by leereeves on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:03PM (#11204625)
Because the best case scenario for a weapon is that merely having it prevents an attack.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by leereeves on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:24PM (#11204304)
Coordination through the market is far from perfect.

The market has myopia and rarely makes huge long-term investments, and sometimes it leads people off a cliff like a band of lemmings.

For example, it's given the United States a plethora of entertainment but decaying infrastructure, and the housing and dot-com bubbles.

The best system seems to be a mix of both central planning and private markets.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by icebraining on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:52PM (#11204530)
There was (and is) a tremendous involvement of central planning in the housing market, so much that calculating its influence the bubble is impossible. Using it as evidence that we need more central planning is essentially using No True Scotsman - "no, I mean the good kind of central planning".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causes_of_the_United_States_ho...

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by leereeves on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:08PM (#11204665)
Would you agree that the worst abuses (like NINJA loans and selling assets known to be toxic) weren't centrally planned?
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by icebraining on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:23PM (#11204801)
Sure. My disagreement, or actually, my skepticism is on whether having "more" centrally planning would have made things better. That idea seems to rely on some utopic visions of the political process, in which the responsible people are not only extremely honest, but also have uncanny foresight.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by leereeves on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:32PM (#11204884)
I'll grant that - obviously the government failed to prevent the housing bubble - but I think the bubble and the crash were fundamentally driven by market forces.

And central planning was essential to the clean up afterwards.

I think that supports the idea that a mix of the two is best.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by jazzyk on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @03:49PM (#11205932)
The housing bubble was not driven by market forces.

It was driven by central planners by incentivising mortgage companies to lend recklessly, as these companies knew the mortgages were guaranteed by quasi-governmental companies like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac which currently hold ~87% of all mortgages [1]. No wonder the Fed is so keen on pumping up housing prices (through too-low interest rates)

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/06/business/helpi...

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by woodandsteel on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @08:47PM (#11207609)
I have a couple of questions for you.

But first, when the bubble was happening, conservatives said that prices were sound, would never crash, and this was because they were the product of market forces. But then the bubble burst, and overnight conservatives switched to saying it had all been unsound because of government intervention.

So let me ask you, what was your position when the bubble was happening, and how did you respond when conservatives suddenly changed their story?

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by jazzyk on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:25PM (#11208080)
Why do you bring politics into this? This was neither conservative nor liberal bubble. Both sides are guilty, this is central planners vs the market. I saw the bubble for what it was, most of my friends looked at me strangely, thinking I was probably jealous, because I was not interested in buying a $2M shack masquerading as a house.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by leereeves on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @05:53PM (#11206788)
That link shows that the "share of mortgages backed by the government" dropped during the bubble and fell as low as (about) 38%, and it didn't increase until after housing prices peaked.

I think you've misinterpreted the statistic you quoted.

During the bubble, lenders found easy money for mortgages from private markets, and it was after the bubble ended that the government stepped in to prop up prices.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by coryrc on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @02:12PM (#11205234)
That's not the worst abuse; the worst abuse is studio apartments renting for over $2000/mo.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by sandworm101 on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:22AM (#11203682)
>> Services, entertainment, and consumer goods are all highly dependent on many more variables than shelter and food are.

I'd agree with that for the most developed economies. The US government is in no place to predict consumer wants 5/10/15 years out. But china is far behind. They can look to the more liberal/advanced economies for guidance. They seem to be doing this in their allowance of some international culture (hollywood) and communication (internet). And I think the population is following the pattern. They haven't demanded anything radically different than more advanced economies have.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:33AM (#11203791)
> The US government is in no place to predict consumer wants 5/10/15 years out.

It doesn't have to. It just need to provide the framework for US businesses to be successful and allow the entrepreur class to handle future demand. China, Russia, etc have so much state owned industry that the government itself needs to predict this stuff, which is the problem.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by ajross on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @11:47AM (#11203918)
> you need to build 1 billion housing units. That is going to keep a lot of people very busy for 20+ years.

By all accounts, though, housing is already vastly overbuilt in China. They spent all those labor-hours already fueling the boom, and those "very busy" hands are now idle.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by leereeves on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:04PM (#11204099)
Reportedly, China wants to move tens or hundreds of millions of people to the "ghost cities" by 2020.

http://europe.chinadaily.com.cn/epaper/2015-07/03/content_21...

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/18/world/asia/china-releases-...

http://www.techinsider.io/heres-chinas-big-plan-to-move-a-po...

It's seems like a strange plan: build empty cities then move people to them en masse. I guess it makes more sense for a centrally planned economy.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by beachstartup on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:26PM (#11204316)
china is operating on a longer timescale than commercial real estate developers.

on the flip side, there's a housing shortage (symptom: insanely high prices) in many US cities. i don't think that's any more or less strange, it's just an artifact of the system that's in place.

in vancouver there's a housing shortage (insanely high prices), combined with a housing glut (in the form of empty units). that's weird too.

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by leereeves on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:41PM (#11204436)
Yes, strange was not the right word.

What China is doing is like building a whole housing development before selling any, but on a much larger scale.

It's the scale that I find striking.