News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by icebraining on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:28PM (#11204333)
For an extremely simplified example, you have 1 billion people in China, so you need to build 1 billion housing units.

Well, only if you want to have empty units, as there's (almost?) always more than one person per housing unit. How many? Well, that depends on the wealth of the household, on how many children they plan to have, on how many generation will be living with them.

And where should those houses be located? That depends on the (future!) employment opportunities, on the surrounding environment, on personal preferences, etc.

And what kind of zoning should there be applicable? US-style sprawling suburbs? High-density skyscrapers? Smaller towns? How dependent is that on other factors?

What building materials should be used? Is it better to build something cheap for now, betting on improving economic conditions for later rebuilding? Or is a medium-term solution better?

If a layman like me can think of a few dozen variables in 10 minutes, how many are actually there? How can one make a plan that accounts for the particulars of each of the billion?

Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by bsbechtel on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @12:33PM (#11204375)
My example was extremely simplified, and my point was not that China's central planning is correct, working well, or a good idea. It was that it is easier to get away/justify central planning on basic necessities (especially when 500 million people don't even have access to these things) than more complicated luxuries that are more subject to individual tastes.
Re:Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix by jdihwjbbr on Tuesday March 01, 2016 @01:36PM (#11204916)
Your thought experiment was lazy and clearly illusionary. At most your comment has some explanatory power as to how the central governments and central banks of the world trick themselves into believing they can make intelligible decisions for billions.

Sheer hubris which costs millions of lives and needless poverty.