News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by grandalf on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @12:27PM (#1115394)
I'm not sure why everyone thinks Toyota has failed. If two of the US automakers hadn't been bailed out by the US Government, Toyota (with all of its current challenges) would have bought up thousands of dealerships and dozens of plants in the US and would be poised to totally dominate the worldwide automotive market.

Instead, it had a bit of bad luck (requiring a recall) and it now faces stiff competition from two companies kept in business by massive government subsidies.

I think most people would still rather buy a Toyota than a Chrysler, Ford, or GM vehicle, on the basis of both safety and reliability -- and increasingly performance and styling.

The fact is, Toyota already won in the marketplace. It deserves to have a near monopoly because it fought harder and smarter for decades, slowly earning customer confidence and loyalty. What were the fruits of its labor? Now it gets to fight against massively subsidized ghosts from its past who have already lost the battle but are reanimated by politicians waving American flags, etc.

And now the American press seems to be having a field day claiming that Toyota has failed after one major recall. Note that similar stories about Toyota's demise surfaced after the firm had its first unprofitable quarter ever at the same time that two US automakers became insolvent.

This anti-Toyota propaganda really boggles the mind.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by dmm on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @01:19PM (#1115564)
They hid a problem that was killing people. That is why they are now getting negative publicity.
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by grandalf on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @02:53PM (#1115807)
Are you serious? The only reason any car companies do recalls (ever) is if the cost-benefit analysis favors it.

cost of recall < possible bad publicity + lawsuit damages

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by andrewljohnson on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:10PM (#1115874)
Could we have a little more in-depth analysis than "I saw fight club?"
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by jjs on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:54PM (#1115987)
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by grandalf on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:16PM (#1115887)
I didn't see fight club, fyi. Not sure what you mean. Are you under the impression that the recall decision is more complex than that? Most bugs are fixed in the next model year or ignored.
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by dtegart on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @07:13PM (#1116490)
I have been involved in automotive recalls as a quality engineer and believe it or not things have advanced in the last 40 years and this is no longer how recalls are handled. In fact the cost of the recall is usually one of the last things discussed after the decision has already been made.
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by somecanuck on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @12:56PM (#1115494)
The failure is not the recall -- that happens. The failure is that they knew about the problem and lied about it.
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by grandalf on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @02:55PM (#1115814)
All cars have lots of "known bugs", many of which could cause loss of life but are not subject to recall.

Why? Because there is a cost benefit equation that car companies use. If the cost of doing a recall is less than the possible bad publicity + lawsuit damages.

Toyota is no different, if anything, that they decided not to mention it suggests it's a low risk (if the cars killed even a few dozen people the cost the recall would have been obvious from the beginning).

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by somecanuck on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @04:36PM (#1116092)
It was not a case of "not mentioning" the problem. They actually hid the truth and lied.
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by mdasen on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @12:57PM (#1115498)
First, Ford didn't take any government money and actually reported a profit for the past year.

Second, there's a difference between a subsidy and loans. GM and Chrysler got loans. Now, they were loans they couldn't have gotten on the open market because they looked too toxic. However, GM is now saying they'll be able to repay the loan pretty quickly. That indicates that investors misjudged the risk. Granted, it could have turned out otherwise (and I was one of the people that thought that it would have).

And I think that people feel betrayed if a company has a potentially fatal flaw in their devices. This isn't an issue of mere reliability. If my car is unreliable, it's annoying and I have higher repair bills. If my car speeds up to 100MPH and I can't stop it, I can die. Those two things sit differently with consumers. And it looks like Toyota tried to write it off as nothing when it was something and tried to protect their image rather than their customers lives.

It's one of those things: if a company has produced a wonderful, superior, reliable vehicle that kills 1 in 100,000, are they better? Most would say no, but it's easier to hide and it looks like Toyota was trying to hide their problems.

Toyota isn't failed, but this will be a huge setback for them (and it should be). If you hide problems that are fatal to people, you deserve to have your sales drop. There's an outrage over that.

Toyota screwed up big time for many years. The US auto makers also screwed up for many years. The US auto makers troubles came to light slowly in a way that was mostly about finances, wages, etc. Toyota's screw up is about human fatalities and came to light very quickly. That's a lot of the difference in the way it's being treated by the media.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by kqr2 on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @02:09PM (#1115694)
The "Cash For Clunkers" program which cost the tax payers billions was an indirect subsidy for dealerships and automakers.

The most popular new car under the program was the Ford Focus so Ford did benefit from government spending.

Edmunds estimates that the Cash For Clunkers program actually cost tax payers $24,000 for each additional new car sold.

http://money.cnn.com/2009/10/28/autos/clunkers_analysis/inde...

http://autos.yahoo.com/articles/autos_content_landing_pages/...

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by grandalf on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:05PM (#1115855)
Excellent point. Note too that the program only subsidized certain sorts of vehicle upgrades (the kind that benefit US companies).

Most anyone could have improved overall MPG by simply buying a Prius, but the incentives were structured not to give any additional incentive to such purchases.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by MrFoof on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @02:17PM (#1115709)
>If my car speeds up to 100MPH and I can't stop it, I can die.

Is it just me, or is this a design problem just waiting to be solved.

Not the accelerator design, but to counter the fact that although there are numerous ways to either slow down the car or bring it to a halt that consumers simply weren't aware of.

Yes, you can shift into neutral. However, drivers didn't realize that. Yes, you can also turn off the engine. However, drivers didn't think of that.

I had a friend years ago (college days) in which the brakes in his Trans-Am decided to not do much of anything. Boiled off brake fluid? Bad master cylinder? Overheated rotors? Who knows. Rather than downshift, or put it in neutral, or turn off the engine -- and then wait and use the handbrake -- he figured putting it into a tree at 60mph was his best option.

The fact that drivers will not think to employ a variety of methods to slow down the car screams to me that there's something that doesn't exist, that should, that better caters to the average driver's instinctual reaction (which currently is depressing the brake pedal as hard as possible, and not giving up until the car stops).

I realize that the vehicle could've taken both brake and accelerator inputs and simply given total priority to the brake, which would've mitigated many accidents, but there are other situations (like my friend who didn't think things through) which probably merit a "panic button" solution.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by grandalf on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:03PM (#1115847)
On the other hand, it shows just how reliable cars are that we don't think about those things.

Generally people are quite foolish while driving. Have you noticed how people driving heavy SUVs with 4 wheel drive (which get better traction in the snow) think that they can safely travel 65 mph on icy roads? It seems not to occur to them that the vehicle has lots of momentum and will slide on ice.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by ams6110 on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @10:01PM (#1116745)
The fact that drivers will not think to employ a variety of methods to slow down the car screams to me that there's something that doesn't exist, that should

Real drivers education, and real demonstration of your competency to operate a vehicle before getting a license?

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by InclinedPlane on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @04:11PM (#1116030)
"Second, there's a difference between a subsidy and loans. GM and Chrysler got loans."

General Motors is currently a wholly owned subsidiary of the United States Treasury. This is a point of some significance and worth avoiding glossing over.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by gojomo on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @05:03PM (#1116167)
GM didn't just "get loans". It went bankrupt and is now majority-owned by the government.

The $7 billion "loan" GM received, and plans to pay back, is a tiny fraction of the $50 billion in assistance it's received. And GM is still losing money. So GM is really just paying back the loan with other subsidies it's received.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by grandalf on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @02:58PM (#1115825)
I didn't mention Ford getting bailouts, did I?

BTW loans at below market interest rates are a subsidy. Calling them loans is just doublespeak.

And turning off the key stops any car. The people who died when the car got to 100 miles per hour would probably also have died in the midst of nearly any minor malfunction that led to a bit of panic.

That's not to excuse the error, but as I mentioned, I think out of control speed "bugs" tap into the public psyche a bit more than all the other possible equally risky bugs.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by andrewljohnson on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:13PM (#1115879)
Another uninformed comment.

If you drove a Prius (I do) then you would know A) Prius's don't usually have a key in the ignition and B) you can't turn the car off while accelerating.

Do you understand this is a software issue, chief? You have no clue what is going on. For all you know, the entire car might be unresponsive. Ever had a computer hang on you?

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by smokey_the_bear on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @04:55PM (#1116143)
I also have a Prius, and though I haven't tried it, I've read that you can in fact turn it off while accelerating by holding down the power button for three seconds.

Though make sure you can go straight for awhile, as it will also disable power steering.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by dtegart on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @07:03PM (#1116473)
If you are going fast, which presumably in this situation you are, your power steering isn't giving you much boost anyway. Losing power steering doesn't mean you lose steering, you probably wouldn't even notice it until you slowed down
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by grandalf on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:25PM (#1115912)
Most of the problems were no pre-Prius models which you could turn off w/ the key. The Prius may be an exception.

What difference does it make if a problem is "hardware" of "software" (or even user error for that matter), if it's common enough and if it results in loss of life?

I was not arguing that Toyota shouldn't fix the problem, only that bugs are routine and we shouldn't pretend that there is negligence here.

Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by andrewljohnson on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @04:49PM (#1116130)
Jeez... I'm just saying it's not the drivers screwing up. You actually can't stop the car.
Re:Secretive Culture Led Toyota Astray by whatusername on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @05:46PM (#1116279)
Sometimes turning off the key doesn't work: http://theage.drive.com.au/motor-news/cruise-control-terror-...

Also - has has already been mentioned - the Prius doesn't have a key.