I'd actually like to think of encryption as a 2nd amendment issue - protection against an unruly and intrusive government. Encryption being necessary to the security of a free state...or something.
You weren't thinking of bringing your US-purchased laptop or smartphone along with you when you went abroad, were you?
EDIT: phrasing.
>>if Apple loses the kind of device you're talking about might be by extension criminalized depending on the breadth of the ruling - or explicitly criminalized by congress.<<
I can easily see this going in that direction...
Which reminds me, this brings another lens with which to examine the next Supreme Court appointee, as they'll likely see this case.
I do like the creativity. However, we are arguably at war with ISIS. Congress could probably pass a law quartering soldiers in our houses.
Plus this court order isn't putting the backdoor in any phone other than the one the FBI already possess.
We actually are at war with ISIS. Surprise!
You see, way back in 2001 just after 9/11 Congress passed a "Authorization for Use of Military Force" (or AUMF) which is constitutionally a declaration of war. That AUMF authorized the use of the armed forces in going after "terrorists" and terrorist organizations who played a role in the attacks or who harbored or aided the groups or individuals who did. In practice it is a sweeping authorization of power which effectively makes most of the world an active battleground and is the legal basis for the US military's use of drones and bombing campaigns in areas from Pakistan and Afghanistan to Iraq, Yemen, and Somalia. It has been modified, updated, and re-authorized by congresses over time but it is still in effect. We are still at war with "al qaeda" and its cousins and compatriots, which includes ISIS (the organization previously known as "al-qaeda in Iraq").
So there you go. We have actually been at war with ISIS since its inception (which was after 2001).
Declarations of war are diplomatic in nature. There is even a theory that declarations of war are unnecessary after an act of war has already been undertaken.
Like the USA running a bombing campaign on ISIS.
Frankly though, I hope Apple loses this one. I'd like to see it spur them into developing a device that they do not have the ability to compromise, because it gives the end user the freedom to modify all the way down to the firmware. Like how you can theoretically flash your own signed coreboot into a chromebook.