News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rhino369 on Thursday February 18, 2016 @07:43PM (#11130642)
Taken narrowly, there is no personal liberty at stake in this situation. Searching this phone is clearly permissible under the 4th amendment.

I guess making Apple--a huge corporation--assist is somewhat against liberty, but I wouldn't call it personal liberty. They get compensated for it.

The slippery slope argument everyone seems to be pushing doesn't quite make sense to me. How is forcing Apple to help get past security after a valid court order going to hurt third parties privacy? Nobody is asking for Apple to introduce a backdoor into their products for sale. Only to exploit a backdoor into one specific phone.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by skywhopper on Thursday February 18, 2016 @07:53PM (#11130700)
The backdoor does not currently exist. Creating it leads to a slippery slope because the FBI will not only ask Apple to unlock phones from known dead terrorists who killed multiple people, but it will cascade to suspected terrorists, and then families of suspected terrorists, and then drug dealers and drug users and then speeders and loiterers and people of the wrong color, just like every other police abuse of power.

And then if Apple gives into the FBI, it'll have to give into the UK and France and Germany and China and Russia and anywhere else they want to sell their phones. And once the capability is created and exists, it can leak, and then no one's phone is safe anymore.

That's the slippery slope.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by noonespecial on Thursday February 18, 2016 @07:57PM (#11130725)
And unlike many of the "slippery slope" arguments that seem to involve hand-wavy-ness and no-reasonable-person-ness, this one is straight, slick, steep and you can see right to the bottom.

Don't get in the tube and push off if you don't want to ride this one all the way down.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by InclinedPlane on Thursday February 18, 2016 @09:25PM (#11131100)
Note that the purpose of this case is not to get the data, the FBI have other options for this specific example. The purpose is to set a precedent, and to get the backdoors they want created. This isn't some haphazard accidental "oops, we didn't mean to go so far" situation, this is the FBI getting out the hose and the slip-n-slide and pointing a gun at Apple to get on.
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rhino369 on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:16PM (#11130822)
>The backdoor does not currently exist.

This is pretty much semantics. Apple can load a modified firmware without the password. That is a backdoor.

>Creating it leads to a slippery slope because the FBI will not only ask Apple to unlock phones from known dead terrorists who killed multiple people, but it will cascade to suspected terrorists, and then families of suspected terrorists, and then drug dealers and drug users and then speeders and loiterers and people of the wrong color, just like every other police abuse of power.

The fact is that each time this tool would be used would require a federal district court to specifically order it. That eliminates the slippery slope risk. The courts would absolutely allow it for murder cases. In fact, any federal crime. But that's what is supposed to happen.

And if you really think that a district court would let the FBI search a phone because they are the wrong color (or any other blatantly illegal purpose), well that court would also force apple to help them. So it ordering this now doesn't increase the likelihood of it happening.

>And then if Apple gives into the FBI, it'll have to give into the UK and France and Germany and China and Russia and anywhere else they want to sell their phones.

I am not arguing that Apple should give the FBI the power to do it independently. The FBI isn't asking for it. And the court didn't order Apple to do that.

Apple already has the capability to do this.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by VikingCoder on Thursday February 18, 2016 @10:05PM (#11131270)
Would you agree that having a device to torture someone, and using a device to torture someone are different things?

Apple doesn't want to build a device to torture people. They're worried that if they build a device to torture people, that they will be told to torture people all the time, and will be barred from disclosing the fact that they're torturing people.

> The fact is that each time this tool would be used would require a federal district court to specifically order it. That eliminates the slippery slope risk.

I can't imagine why you think this. Getting a wire tap used to take a warrant. Then it took a warrant in a secret court. Then it took a warrant in a secret court, which could be granted after the fact. Then blanket permission to wire tap every overseas phone call was taken. Then blanket permission to wire tap every domestic email. I just don't see how you think you've ELIMINATED a slippery slope, by starting at requiring a federal district court order.

Congressmen are already gearing up to write laws. McAfee is already volunteering to do it for free.

> or any other blatantly illegal purpose

Torture is blatantly illegal. Waterboarding is torture. So is forced anal feeding. I haven't seen any prosecutions, under military code, or otherwise, of people who admit to authorizing torture. If the courts aren't punishing blatantly illegal government action, what's to stop the government from more blatantly illegal actions?

> Apple already has the capability to do this.

I have the capability to torture someone. I don't care if the courts order me to do it.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by millstone on Thursday February 18, 2016 @10:10PM (#11131282)
Sorry, but you greatly overestimate the ability of the courts to restrain the FBI. There are many examples of the FBI submitting false declarations to the courts, accessing password-protected files without a warrant, using improperly obtained evidence, and more. [1]

Intelligence tools are pitched as counter-terrorism, and then used in whatever cases they feel like it. For example, the Stingray phone surveillance device, which the FBI loans out to be used by local police departments, without warrants. [2]. Or pretty much the entire Patriot Act.

Of course the FBI wants the power to do this independently. And this is exactly how they go about obtaining this power.

[1] https://www.eff.org/wp/patterns-misconduct-fbi-intelligence-...

[2] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/02/secretive-stingray-sur...

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by oldmanjay on Thursday February 18, 2016 @09:21PM (#11131085)
That you consider it a fact that law enforcement obeys its judicial constraints undercuts any argument you might make
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rhino369 on Friday February 19, 2016 @12:26AM (#11131763)
I'm not considering it a fact. I consider it a fact that the FBI would not physically be able to use this tactic without an explicit court order.

You don't have to trust the FBI at all.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by oldmanjay on Friday February 19, 2016 @12:41AM (#11131828)
I'm not sure what physical restraints you believe would be in place. Please explain that.
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rhino369 on Friday February 19, 2016 @01:20PM (#11135331)
They ask apple to code the firmware so it only works on that specific iphone. And it would be signed so they cannot edit the firmware.

Finally, the FBI even said they'd agree to do this on Apple campus and then actually give the iphone to apple after they copied data off it.

There is zero chance they could reuse it.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by danjoc on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:01PM (#11130746)
I like to think it's about the 3rd amendment. The backdoor is a digital soldier.

Frankly though, I hope Apple loses this one. I'd like to see it spur them into developing a device that they do not have the ability to compromise, because it gives the end user the freedom to modify all the way down to the firmware. Like how you can theoretically flash your own signed coreboot into a chromebook.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by remarkEon on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:05PM (#11130772)
Interesting thought, though I'd imagine that if Apple loses the kind of device you're talking about might be by extension criminalized depending on the breadth of the ruling - or explicitly criminalized by congress.

I'd actually like to think of encryption as a 2nd amendment issue - protection against an unruly and intrusive government. Encryption being necessary to the security of a free state...or something.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rosser on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:40PM (#11130930)
To your point, remember that the US government has long classed encryption as a munition, and subjects it to arms control and export regulations. It is a Federal felony (though, aside, what isn't anymore?) to travel with crypto of a certain strength to dozens of countries — many of which don't even require a visa or do visa-on-arrival.

You weren't thinking of bringing your US-purchased laptop or smartphone along with you when you went abroad, were you?

EDIT: phrasing.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by dougabug on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:22PM (#11130854)
This is an astute point. Encryption is a modern, defensive technology against an overreaching State intent on total control over its populace. In the 21st Century, guns are a relatively weak counterbalance to State power. Even in Saddam's Iraq, people had guns.
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by Outdoorsman on Thursday February 18, 2016 @09:21PM (#11131088)
I think you make an excellent point...

>>if Apple loses the kind of device you're talking about might be by extension criminalized depending on the breadth of the ruling - or explicitly criminalized by congress.<<

I can easily see this going in that direction...

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by jkestner on Thursday February 18, 2016 @09:49PM (#11131213)
I love this point tying it to the Second Amendment. Originalists won't. Someday we'll remember our history and not just recite the words.

Which reminds me, this brings another lens with which to examine the next Supreme Court appointee, as they'll likely see this case.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rhino369 on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:19PM (#11130839)
>I like to think it's about the 3rd amendment. The backdoor is a digital soldier.

I do like the creativity. However, we are arguably at war with ISIS. Congress could probably pass a law quartering soldiers in our houses.

Plus this court order isn't putting the backdoor in any phone other than the one the FBI already possess.

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by sundaeofshock on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:40PM (#11130929)
No, we are not at war with ISIS. Only congress can declare war, and I don't recall such a vote.
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by InclinedPlane on Thursday February 18, 2016 @09:37PM (#11131160)
Lol, happened ages ago man.

We actually are at war with ISIS. Surprise!

You see, way back in 2001 just after 9/11 Congress passed a "Authorization for Use of Military Force" (or AUMF) which is constitutionally a declaration of war. That AUMF authorized the use of the armed forces in going after "terrorists" and terrorist organizations who played a role in the attacks or who harbored or aided the groups or individuals who did. In practice it is a sweeping authorization of power which effectively makes most of the world an active battleground and is the legal basis for the US military's use of drones and bombing campaigns in areas from Pakistan and Afghanistan to Iraq, Yemen, and Somalia. It has been modified, updated, and re-authorized by congresses over time but it is still in effect. We are still at war with "al qaeda" and its cousins and compatriots, which includes ISIS (the organization previously known as "al-qaeda in Iraq").

So there you go. We have actually been at war with ISIS since its inception (which was after 2001).

Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rhino369 on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:49PM (#11130967)
Declaring war and being at war aren't necessarily the same thing.
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by VikingCoder on Thursday February 18, 2016 @09:41PM (#11131180)
Do you remember the last war that the US declared?
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rosser on Thursday February 18, 2016 @10:23PM (#11131319)
Free hint: my parents weren't even born yet, and I'm at the early end of Generation X.
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by philovivero on Thursday February 18, 2016 @09:39PM (#11131168)
And just making up your own definitions for everything isn't necessarily the most useful way to engage in a conversation.
Re:Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to a... by rhino369 on Friday February 19, 2016 @12:32AM (#11131793)
I'm being totally serious. I'm not at all convinced that the only way the United States is at war is when Congress declares it.

Declarations of war are diplomatic in nature. There is even a theory that declarations of war are unnecessary after an act of war has already been undertaken.

Like the USA running a bombing campaign on ISIS.