Re:ReactOS 0.4.0 Released
by exizt88 on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @09:50AM
(#11118166)
Please don't hijack scroll on web pages.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:ReactOS 0.4.0 Released
by marssaxman on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @12:57PM
(#11119750)
More importantly, please don't build web browsers that give nitwit web developers the option of hijacking scroll (or control keys!!) in the first place.
I use the web to build applications and very much need to set scroll points and capture key input thank you very much.
Re:ReactOS 0.4.0 Released
by marssaxman on Thursday February 18, 2016 @12:11PM
(#11127300)
I'd really rather you didn't do that, since it makes using the web as the web so annoying. I think we really need to fork the web and let "browsers" specialize in one direction while the "client/server application platforms" go another.
I’m using the page on Firefox, with a laptop (with touchpad) and it works perfectly normal – now I’m interested what I’m missing? What’s it like?
I'm using Firefox 44.0.2 on Linux with a mouse and it appears to be fine too...
The scrolling seems fine to me.
They're using kinetic/smooth scrolling, which is included in theme they're using from Okler. If you look in the JS, you'll see:
Plugin Name: smoothScroll for jQuery.
Written by: Okler Themes - (http://www.okler.net)
And here's a forum where a customer asks to disable it:http://www.okler.net/forums/topic/disable-scrolling-effect/
Another offender:
https://www.astralgameservers.com/
Inertial/kinetic scrolling is incredibly frustrating when implemented in JS. On my Mac, sure, if I swipe my fingers and let go, I expect the OS to emulate a free-spinning scroll wheel. But when it's emulated in JS, there's no way for the code to know whether I lifted my fingers, so it defaults to making the page skid around uncontrollably, when I intend to quickly swipe - while keeping my fingers down at the end - to go to a precise offset in the page.
It's visually a cute a effect, but I have no idea how anyone thinks that it makes for anything other than an utterly infuriating user experience.
There's something non-standard going on with it for me. It snaps to certain sections at the bottom and I can't swipe to navigate back and forth like I usually do.
exizt88 is correct. I can't swipe to go back a page. And if I swipe up, the page seems to want to continue scrolling at the same speed, it feels different and not fluent.