News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by seren on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:36AM (#11104229)
I don't know if it will prevail in the end, but I think that Reddit approach by splitting the community in small subgroups/communities has a better chance to last in the long run.

Of course, you'll create feuds between communities but at least it is somewhat confined and not always spilling in the common public space.

Unfortunately it also greatly increases the echo chamber / filter bubble but it seems you can not have a peaceful community without an heavy dose of groupthink.

A long time ago, at the dusk of the XXth century, I used to believe that Internet would usher a new age of Enlightenment since every one would have access to many different opinions and unbiased sources. Arguably that was a pretty naive view, and instead we got new tribes disagreeing on almost everything conceivable.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by MicroBerto on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:30PM (#11105023)
For those of you old enough to have seen the net hey started, but young enough to have been impressionable by its start:

Remember when we wanted EVERYONE to get online? Remember when we thought how great the world would be if everyone was connected and could read all this great information and research?

HA! One thing we did not understand: the tragedy of the commons.

It is now nothing but a tragedy. Best thing to do is stay deep within your select niches and away from general purpose networks like Facebook or Twitter.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by bananaboy on Monday February 15, 2016 @09:23PM (#11107517)
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by markatkinson on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:49PM (#11105123)
Yea man, I used to just screw around on Yahoo for hours on end exploring the internet in its weird pixelated glory.

I like that term "general purpose networks", although "purposelessness" might be better suited.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by Paul-ish on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:19PM (#11104515)
I have been waiting a long time for someone to use lessons learned from recommender systems to build a social media site like reddit, but rather than having users group themselves up, they would be shown posts algorithmically, based on how they have voted in the past. For example, if I vote for a lot of pro EFF posts, maybe I will see more posts about free software or something like that.

This also allows the site to treat votes as merely an expression of preference, not a judgment of quality (which is hard to define). Many sites try to enforce a rule that says "Don't downvote things disagree with." This is an impossible battle to win, there will always be people who downvote things they don't agree with. This behavior needs to be accounted for in the platform.

This is more "socially scalable" to me.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by spatulan on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:30PM (#11104612)
That sounds horrible. I don't want the internet to become a giant echo chamber. I want to hear differing views from time to time, because I might be wrong.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by HCIdivision17 on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:44PM (#11105103)
I would imagine you could also similarly find the things you either stay away from or actively dislike. Sort of a topical noise cancellation. Train it to know your preferences, but to occasionally give material outside the comfort zone. I think you'd really need a substantial map of topics to have a good understanding of where contrasts lie, but we're likely on track with the datasets currently being built in public sites like Reddit.

Really, I'm surprised this feature isn't implemented anywhere, since one of the joys of the Internet is being delighted by a new idea you haven't seen before. I certainly would appreciate filtering of the obvious rubbish like Fry is exasperated with, but having quality dissenting opinions available is precious.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by punee on Monday February 15, 2016 @03:56PM (#11105888)
So you will upvote differing views that you find interesting. And they will be included in your "bubble". Tada.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by organsnyder on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:28PM (#11104590)
Isn't that basically how Facebook's algorithms work? The only difference is that it restricts the pool of possible content to your list of "friends".
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by jcoffland on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:54PM (#11104776)
FB also decides who your real friends are. You normally only see posts from the friends you interact with most.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by slig on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:03PM (#11104842)
Reddit used to have that years ago.

> reddit is a source for what's new and popular on the web -- personalized for you. Your votes train a filter, so let reddit know what you liked and disliked, because you'll begin to be recommended links filtered to your tastes. All of the content on reddit is submitted and voted on by users like you

https://web.archive.org/web/20061117074302/http://reddit.com...

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by SmellyGeekBoy on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:54AM (#11108855)
Quora works this way to some extent, and I find that it works very well.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by reitoei on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:39AM (#11104253)
In-fighting within communities is one of reddit's biggest problems.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by fredley on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:02PM (#11104393)
I think there's probably an upper limit for how big any community can become before it becomes fractured. This size is probably variable, and dependent on the medium and structure of the community to an extent, but I'd posit it exists for any community. See: reddit, Stack Overflow, Facebook, any church, any religion, any politcal party, any country.

Often secession is what happens: new subreddits, new churches, new countries. But as they grow, the same problems return.

One thing I've often thought about is some kind of community-space with a fixed upper-bound on the size of communities, essentially forcing a community to split to add new members, like an old cell.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by vidarh on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:43AM (#11104273)
Yes, but then those who don't enjoy that infighting can, and often do, leave and form their own.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by reitoei on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @06:28AM (#11109161)
Which fail in 99% of cases, so they come back to the original one more bitter than when they left.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by DanielBMarkham on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:45AM (#11104285)
(Not directly applicable to Twitter, but to online communities in general)

It'd be interesting if you could have two votes: whether you liked what the person posted (which would only be visible to them) and whether you'd personally share it with your friends (which would affect it's ranking only among your friends)

Or put differently, I wonder if it's not possible to create a system that dynamically sorts content, instead of having static groups. Seems like static groups with a label on them inevitably end up arguing about exactly what the label means (grin).

I don't want an echo chamber, and I want to be challenged -- but I don't want a daily rage fest against whomever the internet currently hates either.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by seren on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:59AM (#11104372)
> I don't want an echo chamber, and I want to be challenged -- but I don't want a daily rage fest against whomever the internet currently hates either

There is some scaling effect at play.

Let's say in community of 1,000 - 10,000 it is easy to keep a civil discourse by small moderation and self-policing. In the 100,000 - 1,000,000 range it is much much harder.

I have no idea of the size of HN but I believe it is closer to 50,000 and thus still "nice".

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by dustingetz on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:58AM (#11104365)
The follower system on twitter already sorts content like that, it's just the retweet system amplifies certain types of content so strongly that it drowns out other types. Amongst other glaring problems, like driving an evil feedback loop that makes twitter money by making everyone angry.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by DanielBMarkham on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:13PM (#11104474)
Many times online I see a friend who is justifiably upset. Let's say they like to put their dog in a sweater and somebody said it was animal abuse.

Now I could care less about dogs in sweaters, but I like my friend. I hear them and I want them to know that they have been heard. So I "like" the content.

When you've only got 1,000 or so followers, no big deal. But if you're around 50 or 100K? statistically you're going to end up with dozens, maybe hundreds of likes. Some likes are "I agree!" Some likes are "I like you". How could any system distinguish the two? I have difficulties doing this in small groups where people are physically nodding their head.

I know designers don't want to move away from the one-button like/vote/heart/plus/whatever, but hell if I can figure out how you'd make a system work like that without massive feedback noise (which is what's happening).

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by chris_wot on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:52PM (#11104760)
The other day my friend's pet died, and they put a status update on Facebook. Blow me down if they didn't get 5 sympathetic likes!
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by monksy on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:09PM (#11104440)
There is bleeding over from one extremist community to others. (Namely SRS)
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by nols on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:04PM (#11104849)
SRS is the boogeyman of Reddit. It doesn't have nearly the power so many people seem to think. There are plenty of reactionary subreddits on multiple sides of various spectrums.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by gedy on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:14PM (#11104491)
> Internet would usher a new age of Enlightenment since every one would have access to many different opinions and unbiased sources

Agreed. Seems like what happened is people could find their own opinion bubble to live it and feel empowered without having to deal with other opinions.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by EvanPlaice on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @05:41AM (#11109002)
The US does this by allowing states to have their own local governments and laws.

Forcing everybody into a single, homogeneous culture dictated by a central authority is a recipe for disaster.

People often point to the chaos that takes place in the US government as a 'failure of Democracy'. I'd argue the opposite, it's a side effect of a successful Democracy that supports a wide variety of subcultures with different beliefs/norms.

It should be extremely difficult to establish a universal consensus.

The danger comes when the central authority makes declarative judgements that affect everybody without working out foing due diligence. Some topics can't be addressed globally and therefore should be defined locally or not at all.

Universal laws work best when they're used to guarantee basic human rights and freedoms. Unfortunately, some groups try to manipulate public opinion and garner support by attaching 'human right' to whatever particular pet cause they're trying to force.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by fche on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:14PM (#11104482)
Re. your last paragraph, the "different opinions" is exactly what we get, so it's not "instead" but "consequently". As for unbiased sources, that is a pipe dream as it ever was.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by honksillet on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:47AM (#11104305)
Reddit might be the perfect analogy given the propensity for censorship demonstrated both by mods and the corporate folks.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by sdenton4 on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:00PM (#11104382)
There's two reasons for strong moderation (sometimes called 'censorship' by people who don't like it) on the internet: Jackasses creating an unsafe space for other parts of the community, and making a space safe for advertisers.

The first reason comes down to having a choice between taking action against jackasses to allow groups like "women" and to have a place on your site. This is pretty damn important, and something that places like twitter and reddit have been horrible at. To the extent that there's less harassment on sites like Instagram, I wonder if it's just that the jackasses have confined themselves to Reddit.

Advertising is a different issue altogether, and pretty much comes down to the Q-Tip corporation not wanting their ads to run on r/penetration. Which, meh, as far as I'm concerned, but companies based on ad revenue need to be able to sell ads.

Both of these become bigger issues, however, as the sites get bigger and have a larger need for advertising dime to keep the lights on, and just have a bigger pool of jackasses to deal with. Reddit seems to have scaled... poorly... in both of these regards, and needs to think hard about both issues.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by 0xcde4c3db on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:51PM (#11104757)
Another reason for "censorship", particularly on Reddit (where the aim goes against the broader cultural default of the site) is to prevent discussions from being overrun by memes and other "low-effort" posts. Most /r/science posts that make the front page end up with a lot of deleted comments, for example.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by Karunamon on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:43PM (#11104711)
We disagree (and I get the impression this is the root of much strife) on the definition of the word "safe" in "safe space".

Safe from what? From having your views challenged? From someone calling you an asshat? From people making non-credible threats (Think navy seal copypasta)? From people making legitimate threats?

Talk to 10 different people and all will have different definitions as to what the meaning is there.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by jerf on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:24PM (#11104980)
IMHO, the objectionable part of "safe space" is the idea that everywhere needs to be a "safe space", and especially so when only certain favored groups of people gets to be "safe" in that universal "safe space" in accordance with the demands of a very vocal minority.

The right to carve out a space (on the Internet or otherwise) for certain like minded individuals to be "safe" from any of the things you mentioned, as well as any other things they may deem fit, is one that we should generally honor, though.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by Karunamon on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:32PM (#11105036)
Agreed, but only if said "carving out" isn't done platform-wide at everyone's expense.

Changing the rules after people have invested their time and effort into being part of a community with certain norms is generally a crappy thing to do. This is the internet, where anyone can start their own community with their own rules in any number of ways. The rights of the people that were there first should be recognized.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by sdenton4 on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:57PM (#11105169)
Sure. It's incumbent on a platform for a wide variety of communities to provide the tools for those communities to define and enforce their own norms. A big part of the problem at Reddit last year was failing to provide good tools for mods of subreddits.

Why not give mods a knob that auto kills ninety percent of the stuff they end up deleting, to keep them from just getting worn down dealing with this shit?

For my own part, the 'non credible' threats are a huge part of the problem. They stop being non credible if there's enough of them, or if you're getting private messages from people with your home address and a rapid or murder threat. That's the level of unsafe that I'm talking about here. And communities need the tools to stop bullshit before it gets out of hand. I actually think that the sort of over reactionary pc-ness that Steven Fry is concerned about could be a reaction to a lack of such tools.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by jonstokes on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:47AM (#11104309)
"A long time ago, I used to believe that Internet would usher a new age of Enlightenment since every one would have access to many different opinions and unbiased sources."

Heh, same here. I think that so many of us simply underestimated the immense power of capitalism to co-opt and commodify everything it touches.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by cousin_it on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:03PM (#11104399)
Your dig on capitalism is ironic, given that the original post was about the power of activism to politicize everything it touches.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by danharaj on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:15PM (#11104495)
The status quo is always political. There is no apolitical center.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by cousin_it on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:25PM (#11104567)
Sure, we can't have an apolitical space. But we can have an activism-free space, and that's exactly what I want.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by danharaj on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:28PM (#11104589)
so, a safe space from activism? :p

i think your desire is reasonable. however, i think it would be unreasonable to demand it of something as public and global as Twitter.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by cousin_it on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:16PM (#11104927)
Agreed that Twitter shouldn't be activism-free, but they could try to make it less threatening, e.g. by hiding or slowing down replies that are likely to be part of mobbing.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by blakeyrat on Monday February 15, 2016 @02:20PM (#11105280)
Twitter could do a million things to improve the platform (when it comes to reducing abuse), sadly they've chosen to introduce only orthogonal features nobody really wants, like "Moments".
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by jes on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:47PM (#11105117)
I would welcome some additional clarity on your use of the term capitalism, as there are many different things called capitalism today.

My definition is a system of free, un-coerced trade among individuals, to mutual advantage.

It's very simple, and I see it as beneficial.

Interested in your thoughts, if you wish to share them.

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by maker1138 on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:10PM (#11104456)
voluntary exchange is not the problem with society. involuntary exchange on the other hand...
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by danharaj on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:16PM (#11104498)
Property rights are involuntary for the have-nots. The basis of capitalism isn't 'voluntary exchange', but property rights and the accumulation of capital.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by minimuffins on Monday February 15, 2016 @04:51PM (#11106318)
Is there a name for the thing where every discussion online eventually becomes about stridently defending or bashing capitalism?

SOME PUBLIC FIGURE: I'm leaving twitter, too many trolls.

[ 50 pages of discussion ]

AGGRIEVED COMMIE: ACTUALLY, capitalism sucks!

(As it happens, totally agree with the commie stuff though. All the cheery talk about liberty and voluntarism is idiotic since it acts like primitive accumulation and enclosure don't exist, as if everybody starts out with equal capital to manage, like in a board game.)

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by danharaj on Monday February 15, 2016 @05:49PM (#11106656)
> Is there a name for the thing where every discussion online eventually becomes about stridently defending or bashing capitalism?

as a filthy commie, i hope it's the reawakening of the global proletariat :3

Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by minimuffins on Monday February 15, 2016 @06:46PM (#11106940)
Like Bob Fitch said, vulgar Marxism explains about 90% of what goes on in the world.
Re:Too many people have peed in the pool by Shivetya on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:49PM (#11104740)
It wasn't capitalism that co-opted communities, it was the end product of modern politics which strives to play people against each other to maintain the power of those who govern. By subtle and some not so subtle phrasing they can turn people into irrational actors which makes them all the more easy to manipulate. There have been some really good areas for the technically inclined to congregate that were destroyed with politically driven conversations took over.