Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by gitmagic on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:51PM
(#11089461)
Thanks for the feedback. The JSON structure is something we will refine, and right now we wanted to have very explicit rules and not too complex configuration settings. But we will evaluate this along the way, and I like your example :)
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by atom-morgan on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:05PM
(#11089584)
Please! Maybe I'm weird but sometimes I simply want to reposition text on my screen. Just a slight adjustment, think eye level, so it's a bit easier to read and sites like this don't allow me to do so.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by andyfleming on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:30PM
(#11089809)
I agree and disagree. As a general rule, you shouldn't be screwing with the scrolling behavior, but in case like this (with a slider-type of interaction), it is a bit more understandable. What I can't stand is when people do it just to affect the acceleration/whatever of scrolling as a gimmick. This has some usefulness at least and doesn't affect my experience negatively at all.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by jc4p on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:21PM
(#11089727)
Or at least use `replaceState` not `pushState`. I scrolled from the top of the page down one section and when I hit back it just went right back to the top of the page.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by dkubb on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:25PM
(#11089766)
I saw this comment and then started looking for a link to a second page. It turns out I was able to "swipe up" on my magic mouse to scroll down to the second page.
I'd strongly recommend that the developer stop hiding the scrollbar.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by gitmagic on Friday February 12, 2016 @12:47PM
(#11088950)
Tired of all the GitHub drama? We're close to launching GitMagic to fix some of that. If you have any questions, please ask, we’re happy to answer them :) And all feedback are appreciated.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by gitmagic on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:28PM
(#11089792)
Our plans is to begin with GitHub support only, since it is (at the moment at least...) the most popular service. But later we plan to support both GitLab and Bitbucket too.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by kannonboy on Friday February 12, 2016 @04:02PM
(#11090560)
Sweet action! Depending on how far you want to go with the Bitbucket integration, you could potentially inject warnings on the commit, branch, and pull request pages using the Bitbucket Connect framework.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by dkubb on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:31PM
(#11089820)
My main feature request would be a way to enforce a PR must be a fast-forward merge.
I tend to have a small set of words I prefix each git commit summary with (Add, Remove, Fix, etc). If I could verify summaries match that pattern that would be awesome.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by gitmagic on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:57PM
(#11089509)
I'm glad to hear that you get our message! The 'magic' branding is there because everything is done automatically (i.e. it's a cloud service) without the need to install anything on the client side.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by StavrosK on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:16PM
(#11089691)
It's a cloud service? I'm probably missing something, but it looks like a smallish git linter script? I guess I'm not seeing where all the work went to make this something more than an OSS script one could write in two hours.
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by gitmagic on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:25PM
(#11089765)
Yes, I will look into how to make that a bit more clear :) This is integrating with GitHubs build checks and web hooks and we want it to be very easy to get started. A script could do local validation but that would require the contributor to actually run the script :P
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by gitmagic on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:02PM
(#11089553)
Thanks! We decided to not pick a too specific name (like something with "contributing"), since in the future we want to provide services that automates other types of tasks related to working with git. Hence the "GitMagic" name :)
Re:Show HN: GitMagic – Enforce your GitHub contribution guid...
by gitmagic on Friday February 12, 2016 @03:08PM
(#11090129)
Travis is mainly for running tests and would require you to write your own validations. And I'm not sure if they have support for validating the descriptions of PRs and issues? Hound looks awesome! But it's only for code style validation. GitMagic will enforce contributing guidelines such as how to write commits, branches, what to include in PR descriptions, issues, and even file structure/naming conventions.
Instead of
Something like: [1] http://json-schema.org/latest/json-schema-validation.htmlBut I hear you and when the site goes from landing page to real website we will make sure to have a nice scroll experience for everyone :)
Good design is unobtrusive. [5]
Good design is as little design as possible. [10]
[5, 10]: https://www.vitsoe.com/us/about/good-design
AFAICT, there's nothing to try yet.
indeed.
https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html
I'd strongly recommend that the developer stop hiding the scrollbar.
One of our engineers wrote an add-on recently for enforcing some less automated aspects of CONTRIBUTING.md that you might be interested in too: https://blog.bitbucket.org/2016/01/26/pull-request-guideline...
I tend to have a small set of words I prefix each git commit summary with (Add, Remove, Fix, etc). If I could verify summaries match that pattern that would be awesome.
Also, if it is possible to enforce the guidelines specified in http://tbaggery.com/2008/04/19/a-note-about-git-commit-messa... I'd be so happy.
> Magically enforce your GitHub contribution guidelines.
Looks pretty non-magical and quite straightforward to me. I even get to set explicit rules. Why the 'magic' branding?
And we love magic ;)