News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by vzip on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:40AM (#11072996)
It's kind of frightening that people are leaving university with a developed hostility toward the notion of sexual dimorphism in humans.
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by araneae on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:00AM (#11073148)
You're implying that people learn this at university. My experience was the opposite; I took an animal behaviour course at university that presented much of this information. Sexual dimorphism is a fairly major topic in animal behaviour.

For instance, I learned that in every society where it was tested, men are more violent than women. But interestingly, the society itself was important as well; for instance, American society is overall more violent than Icelandic culture, and accordingly American women commit more violent crimes than Icelandic men. So there are differences in between the sexes, but the culture is a very important input if we look at how extreme the trait is.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by kalzium on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:50PM (#11074474)
Didn't the British exile lots of prisoners to North America in the early settlements?

Maybe there's also a genetic connection? ;)

Just joking.

I think overall happiness of people is also really important. The more unhappy people are the more violent they get.

People in Skandinavia are generally quite happy folks: Easy access to education, internet, food, health care, low poverty etc...

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by golemotron on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:47AM (#11073050)
Steven Pinker's'The Blank Slate' explains it well. Western culture has a bias toward nurture explanations rather than nature explanations because admitting nature affects people's perceptions of their abilities and our sense of agency as a culture. If all differences are culture we can fix them. That's why it becomes political.
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by swayvil on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:28PM (#11074323)
Another reason to favor nurture explanations is that nurture explanations carry less weight in an argument than nature explanations.

There's no arguing with nature, it's the ultimate citation.

But nurture means that you, or somebody involved, had a choice. So the buck stops at, rather than the faceless divinity of nature, a mere human. And those are much easier to dismiss.

So we paint the opposing argument as arising from nurture rather than nature. And those arguments stick around and get cited. And a "it's all nurture" model develops.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by bonoboTP on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:02PM (#11074126)
This is especially so in US culture. The "eveyone's responsible for their own fate" meme is still very strong there.
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by zo1 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @03:13PM (#11075612)
I disagree. The opposite is ridiculously pushed from what I can tell of the online-manifestation of western culture. Rather, what I'd argue is the elephant in the room, is that it doesn't matter which of the two is the right answer. We should take responsibility for doing the right thing, regardless if our nature or our surroundings made us a certain way.

Barring certain extreme cases, of course, such as mental illness and such.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by bonoboTP on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:04PM (#11077233)
I wasn't talking about which one is right. It's just an interesting feature of American culture. The positive side is that people are proud of their successes, they are encouraged, every kid is told they can one day become President etc (obviously exaggerated, but the Tall Poppy Syndrome is not characteristic of the US).

The stereotypical US things, like no universal health care, no tuition-free education, lax gun laws, mass incarceration, death penalty etc. are also a manifestation of this attitude.

You must take care of yourself, you must protect yourself, if you make it then great! If you become a criminal, you become subhuman and can be executed and treated brutally by the police. If you become dirt poor, that's your fault, you can become homeless, there's no welfare.

Now again, I'm exaggerating somewhat to emphasize what I mean. And yes I also know the historical origins of this mentality, and as I said, there are also positive consequences, like most major innovations and scientific discoveries coming from the US, the huge dynamic market where anyone can start a new company with manageable levels of bureaucracy (compared to most European countries) etc.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by digi_owl on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:30PM (#11074329)
Its the unspoken shadow of "the american dream"...
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by swayvil on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:35PM (#11074373)
It's a sneaky kind of authoritarianism.

Regular people are dismissed.

Only the faceless, invisible authority is respected.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by astazangasta on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:12AM (#11073234)
Pinker is full of shit on this subject. I remember his intro to psych lecture including an example of a how gendered thinking is hard-wired involving small boys playing with guns. Obviously an example of socialization; evolution did not teach anything to anyone about guns. There is a huge amount of sloppy thinking in this subject.
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by Retric on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:59AM (#11073561)
People have been using bows for 500+ generations and ranged weapons for even longer. That's plenty of time for a preference for ranged combat to show up (ed: become frequent).

The Atoal is believed to be ~30,000 years old. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spear-thrower And spears are ~400,000 years old. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amentum is rather hard to date, but it's simpler than an Atoal.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by astazangasta on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:16AM (#11073688)
This is the kind of argument I am criticizing; "its possible based on our vague understanding of the evolutionary background and selection that this behavior is adaptive, therefore my speculation that this behavior is genetic and the product of evolution is correct."
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by Retric on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:23AM (#11073744)
That's not what I said. I said there was enough time, not that anything actually happened. Thus evolution did not teach anything to anyone about guns is not a supported statement.

Also, a preference for guns may or may not be there. But, males having more accurate spatial reasoning due to ranged weapons, or hunting, and or fighting seems likely. The obvious alternatives are men developed better spatial reasoning due to very widespread cultural factors seems suspicious. Or women scarified spacial reasoning for some competing features.

Anyway, the important thing is not to debate this stuff it's to actually test it. Until then it's all just hot air.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by astazangasta on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:34AM (#11073845)
Based on my understanding of genetics this reasoning is very unattractive. 500 generations is the blink of an eye in genetic terms, certainly not enough to establish a pervasive biological truth that splits the whole species across gender lines; maybe you could drive a single variant to global fixation in that time, certainly not a whole host of them. We also know nothing about how strong the selection in question might be. We know nothing, in fact, to suggest that evolution is "likely" other than our own gut feeling that it must be.

As for testing, that would be great. But it turns out that proving anything about human evolution is very hard, because most of the evidence is lost.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by Retric on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:05PM (#11074141)
For clarity, 500 generations is easily enough for some things to shift frequency, but I agree it would be fast for a mutation to go global. However, thrown weapons are on the order of ~20,000+ generations which is plenty of time for mutation and adaptation.

As to testing, I suspect we are going to get good at decoding and editing human DNA fairly soon which is going to have a lot to say about these debates. This stuff is either there or not, when and how it showed up (or not) is a separate issue.

EX: Domestic cattle are also around 500 generations old and lactose tolerance has been spreading. http://www.foodbeast.com/news/map-of-milk-consumption-lactos... lactose tolerance: 96% in Sweden, 10% in China.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by astazangasta on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:53PM (#11077487)
>when and how it showed up (or not) is a separate issue.

I don't think new data will help. We know the changes in the human lineage; even if we knew their functional meaning, we cannot conclude whether they are adaptive or not; fixed alleles reveal little about their fixation time, etc.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by soperj on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:37PM (#11074386)
They believe the haast eagle evolved from the little eagle diverging just 700 000 years ago. That's going from one of the smallest eagles(0.8kgs) to the largest (11.5-14kgs) in under a million years.
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by Excavator on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:11PM (#11074628)
More accurate spatial reasoning could also be due to the need to navigate a complex environment, such as during hunting.

It could also be due to males having larger brains.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by Retric on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:39PM (#11074859)
Or to break out of the survival aspects, dance may have been important from an evolutionary standpoint.

IMO, the point is there are reasonable priors to actually start testing.

Some of these tests may be fairly simple. Do male baby's throw more things than female baby's?

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by RodericDay on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:46AM (#11073986)
Noam Chomsky was concise on this point:

> "You find that people cooperate, you say, ‘Yeah, that contributes to their genes' perpetuating.’ You find that they fight, you say, ‘Sure, that’s obvious, because it means that their genes perpetuate and not somebody else's. In fact, just about anything you find, you can make up some story for it."

Cordelia Fine also does a great breakdown of all of these "monkey does this, therefore women shopping men guns" arguments.

The nurture side of the debate has its "no nature" clowns, but the caricature by the top-level post is completely uncalled for in this context.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by Retric on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @03:59PM (#11075933)
That's not an actual counter argument.

You can say men are associated with blue for purely cultural reasons, because _

A: It's a 'just so' story which we can make about anything.

B: very recently they where associated with red and pink was considered a less intense version of red.

The B is an actual reasonable argument, where A has zero predictive power.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by shasta on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:40AM (#11073429)
Could you expound upon your definitely-not-sloppy thoughts on why boys obviously couldn't be predisposed to playing with weapons?
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by neffy on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:14AM (#11073675)
Distaff side here. I loved playing with guns when I was a kid. My parents though thought they weren't suitable for girls, so they were quickly banned. So I made my own bow and arrow set, needless to say, that didn't last long in the suburbs. Then I finally got smart, and they never found about the slingshot.

And I was enlightened.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by astazangasta on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:56AM (#11073524)
They could be; its just difficult to conclude that based on observing that they play with weapons, since obviously they must be taught what weapons are, and along with that who (men, women) should use them. Pinker makes little effort to account for such problems and often makes the "widely observed == genetic" fallacy.
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by TazeTSchnitzel on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:41AM (#11073933)
The hostility isn't to sexual dimorphism per se. If only because of hormones and reproduction, there is clearly sexual dimorphism. Anybody can see that.

The hostility is to the tendency to attribute differences between men and women to sheer biology without a careful consideration of other factors.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by sarciszewski on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:46AM (#11073043)
To split hairs a bit: Gender identity is a social construct while biological sex is not.

I think the author meant sex, not gender, and GP meant gender, not sex.

It's easy to conflate the two in conversation, but keeping a semantic barrier between them will help maintain civil discourse without the risk of devolving the discussion into a flame war.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by goda90 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:11AM (#11073222)
The thing is, gender identity is very much affected by sex too. Many outward behaviors that are often classified as masculine or feminine have roots in different hormone levels in the sexes. That's why I dislike that many attack gender roles and other social gender norms indiscriminately. Some of them have a basis in nature and it's healthy for the vast majority of people to embrace them. At the same time there shouldn't be any room for attacking those who don't follow the norms either. And of course some norms are just harmful. It's not so easy to just throw them all out.
Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by sarciszewski on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:12AM (#11073655)
> The thing is, gender identity is very much affected by sex too.

Affected by? Yes.

The same thing? No.

> That's why I dislike that many attack gender roles and other social gender norms indiscriminately.

Huh. That sounds like something I'd expect to read about firsthand on Tumblr moreso than something that reasonable people would do.

> At the same time there shouldn't be any room for attacking those who don't follow the norms either. And of course some norms are just harmful. It's not so easy to just throw them all out.

I think that's fair.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by crimsonalucard on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:01AM (#11073571)
I hate to break it to you. But behavior and gender is determined by genetics. Therefore gender identity is not just a social construct but a biological one as well.

Take for example the correlation between feminine behavior and two X chromosomes (XX). There is high correlation between these two factors. Additionally examine the correlation between masculine behavior and XY. Again another high correlation implying the possibility of a causal connection between gender and genes.

Though correlation doesn't imply causation it lends more credibility to the hypothesis. What if we were to raise a child, born a boy, as a girl? If gender were truly a social construct there would be no issue.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Reimer

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by sarciszewski on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:16AM (#11073691)
> I hate to break it to you. But behavior and gender is determined by genetics. Therefore gender identity is not just a social construct but a biological one as well.

I must admit my knowledge of the scientific literature around the relationship between biological sex and gender identity is limited. Have they found a genetic/epigenetic/hormonal marker that correlates with 95%+ of transgendered people yet?

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by crimsonalucard on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:51AM (#11074042)
No they have not found such a marker.

They have not found a definitive biological causal mechanism that causes transgendered traits. They have found correlations between certain biological mechanisms and transgendered traits. However these findings lead to only about a 70% correlation at most.

Please note that the 70% correlation cannot be ignored. It indicates high likelihood of a causal connection. It is unwise to dismiss this correlation even if it is below a 95% criteria. My intuition tells me that 70% is only a statistic for a single causative biological agent out of several. Once all biological markers are discovered and correlated together, I believe that the number will be 99%.

Please also note that the correlation between the XX chromosomes and the female gender is above 95%, same with the XY chromosomes and the male gender. These correlations meet your criteria. There is no scientific study that proves this but you will note through common sense that males and females tend to act within their gender role over 95% of the time.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by sarciszewski on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:35PM (#11074372)
> There is no scientific study that proves this but you will note through common sense that males and females tend to act within their gender role over 95% of the time.

Then I propose such a scientific study be performed.

I don't like appeals to "common sense" in political matters (and unfortunately gender and sexuality is very political right now). Because, hey, if you're wrong, wouldn't that be an interesting result?

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by crimsonalucard on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:40PM (#11076272)
I take it back. There have been studies. Common sense and science are in line in this case. The amount of people who admit to operating outside of gender norms is <4% according to certain studies.

http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2015-05-22/americ...

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by crimsonalucard on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:46PM (#11076311)
>I don't like appeals to "common sense" in political matters

All things must often appeal to common sense regardless of the politics behind the issue. Males have penises and females don't, does a scientific study need to be conducted to prove this point? No. Because if we needed a scientific study for every possible issue without regard to common sense we would make zero progress on any topic.

Re:The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap by sarciszewski on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:14PM (#11078012)
> Males have penises and females don't, does a scientific study need to be conducted to prove this point?

What you've described is what I refer to as "sex" while totally ignoring the topic of gender. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_and_gender_distinction

I'm not sure what your politics are, but a lot of people who have traveled down this path in a conversation ended up expressing very intolerant opinions towards transgendered people. If you do feel contempt for someone whose gender identity and/or assumed gender role doesn't match their biological sex, please don't share that opinion with me.