News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by jcoffland on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @03:50PM (#11068646)
This sounds great but Google has been making it harder and harder to run your own mail server even for personal use. I think they would be happy of email servers were only run by a few large companies. They make it sound like they are doing the right thing but really they are bully the industry to do it their way. So many people have Gmail accounts that you can't run an email server that cannot send email to Google.

I've run my own email server for about 15 years. Every now and then I have to drop everything and implement some new technology that Gmail demands I have. Granted SPF, DMARC and TLS are all great technologies but I take issue with Google making the decision that everyone is going to switch, now and with out sufficient warning.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by inopinatus on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:29PM (#11069962)
I'm in the same boat as you - running a personal/friends/family mail toaster for 16 years now. But I disagree that Google have made the administration harder. Internet mail servers don't live in isolation, and context has always been changing. I have no issue with adapting configuration as expectations change, so Gmail's evolution has never inhibited my ability to exchange email with the world. This move is no different. Really, I feel that the elephant has been tremendously careful not to tread on the mice.

I don't believe this particular change materially improves security, since it isn't representing an end-to-end behaviour, but if it raises awareness and challenges mass surveillance then so much the better.

Personally I would like them to advocate for other necessary infrastructure advances and include, for non-IPv6-capable MTAs, an icon of a lurching monster that refuses to die.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by Lunatic666 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @08:07PM (#11070114)
That's not right, I host some email servers for small companies and private people who all have problems with Google accounts although supporting DKIM, SPF and a TLS connection. They block them as bulk mail and in their FAQ the option hosting your own server isn't even listed. Of course contacting them is impossible, so the only way left is creating a ton of fake accounts on gmail and add the addresses to their contacts or ask friends with gmail accounts to add them and mark them as no spam. Google definitely IS the email bully and there's not much you can do about it.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by inopinatus on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @09:18PM (#11070348)
Maybe they have a reputation system in which I've gained a good standing and you haven't. Have you considered that your attempts to game their system have actually been regarded as abuse?
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by jonknee on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @09:26PM (#11070380)
All major email providers do similar things because this is exactly the setup you'd have if you were a spam operation. Email is just something that you shouldn't try and do yourself on a small scale.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by jacquesm on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:00AM (#11071509)
How long before 'The world wide web is just something that you shouldn't try and do yourself on a small scale.'.

Really that's bothers me greatly. Email is the example of a successful open protocol and by all means you should try and do it yourself. The less we are reliant on these giant companies the better and to abdicate email to google just because they've achieved critical mass is to wipe 25 years of internet history under the carpet.

Decentralization is good, not bad.

If installing and operating a compliant email server is too hard then we should make that easier, not push to get everybody to switch over to some corporation.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by jonknee on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:06AM (#11073597)
There's not a good way to make running your own email server both easy for you and not easy for spammers. It's a shame, but that's how it is.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by Tepix on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @03:45AM (#11071454)
It very much is something that should stay decentralized. I'm was shocked when I learned that google mail has 1 billion accounts. It's starting to break email as a non-proprietary service.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by inopinatus on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:34AM (#11071611)
Email remains the poster child (given its age, perhaps that should be poster grandparent) for how a lightweight federated communications protocol can service needs from micro to mega.

For comparison: the sidelining of XMPP by corporate interests was awfully disappointing; the centralisation of social networking feeds is downright heartbreaking. But none of that should put us off trying and trying again. Everyone with an interest in how the Internet protocol stack works in context should try running their own mail service, it's a fantastic and low-cost way to gain insight.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by shkkmo on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @09:24PM (#11070371)
Huh, I've had more problems with other blocklists, but never with google. It certainly can be a pain. We need something simple, maybe sort of like EV SSL certs, to allow more painless establishment of email sending reputation on new IPs and domains.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by yhager on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @03:52AM (#11071478)
I too have my own email server for some years now (7 maybe?). Only had problems when I mis-configured it.

I'm frightened as well that google is taking over email. As long as people rely on web based email, there's no hope for actually encrypting email. TLS is nice, but really, it doesn't mean much. Your email is stored plain text on Google's servers anyways.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by tantalor on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:07PM (#11068777)
> some new technology that Gmail demands

> everyone is going to switch, now

The article is pretty clear that gmail users can keep emailing others who don't support TLS or authentication; they will just now see an additional icon informing them of that condition. Nobody is being demanded to switch anything.

disclaimer: works for Google

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by pera on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:31PM (#11069345)
Hi there, I have two questions: first, which CAs will you use? and second, what will you do when a CA gets compromised? Thanks!
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by tantalor on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:32PM (#11069694)
This might help: https://support.google.com/mail/answer/21291?hl=en

What are the SSL certificate authority requirements?

We do not accept self-signed certificates. For a certificate to be valid it needs to chain up to a valid CA, like one in the Mozilla CA list.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:11PM (#11069890)
That's obviously for mail retrieval, so doesn't apply here.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by gscott on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:24PM (#11068892)
For now they will just warn on it. In a few months they will send it to spam. Just wait.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by sangnoir on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:24PM (#11069639)
> For now they will just warn on it. In a few months they will send it to spam

As a recipient of all kinds of mail, I'm okay with that. I'd rather not see that unencrypted email than have it QUANTUM INSERT'd or whatever the Chinese equivalent is.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by vidarh on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:35AM (#11071773)
There's nothing stopping the spammers from getting certs.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by sangnoir on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:35AM (#11072292)
My comment has nothing to do with spammers, and everything to do with the possibility of unencrypted email I receive (spam or not) being nefariously tampered with while in transit (see QUANTUM INSERT)
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by wnevets on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:17PM (#11069253)
>For now they will just warn on it. In a few months they will send it to spam. Just wait.

How many months is a "few"?

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by michaelmior on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:20PM (#11069622)
Maybe. But that's far from "without warning."
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by Navarr on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:19PM (#11069268)
These aren't requirements. Gmail is a mail client. What it is doing is adding warnings.

Without SPF/DKIM you can't be authenticated. Google is showing the user that they cannot verify the sender.

Without TLS email is sent in the clear. Google is showing the user that sensitive information will be visible when sent over the network.

You can run your server fine without this, but users will be warned that you're not following best practices.

It is not Gmail's fault that you're late to best practices.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by lmm on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:57PM (#11069512)
No, best practices are to avoid using any of that and trusting anyone's servers. S/MIME if you trust the CA system, PGP if you don't. Supporting either of those would be a real step forward for privacy - but of course if Google can't snoop on your email then it's not helping them target their ads.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by packetslave on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:05PM (#11069550)
but of course if Google can't snoop on your email then it's not helping them offer you a high-quality email service for free by showing you (hopefully) relevant and unobtrusive ads

Fixed that for you.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by mynameisvlad on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:22PM (#11069291)
> These aren't requirements

Well, except they are. Before, yes, they were just best practices. It was great if you had them but by no means required and didn't really impact your experience much if at all. With this switch, though, they became requirements to getting a "normal" experience in Gmail. Even having a warning is a degraded experience at this point.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by chii on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:53PM (#11069483)
I don't think there's anything wrong with gmail upping the game. It's not like they are using tech that no one else can get.

If I ran a restaurant that provided extra services, that doesn't stop anyone else from opening a restaurant and provide similar levels of service.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by abalos on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:47PM (#11069448)
I'd actually consider that an improved experience. Sure, the sender using the improperly created personal mailbox will be inconvenienced if people ask about it. However, the actual user of gmail benefits from this.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by emergentcypher on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:15PM (#11068836)
Now I can just get a free cert and turn on TLS. What's the problem, exactly?

Most people are not capable of running their own mail server. The convenience of services like Google, plus the risk of turning your mail box into a spam machine, vastly outweighs the downsides for most people.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by elihu on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:21PM (#11069281)
> What's the problem, exactly?

> Most people are not capable of running their own mail server.

I think that is a big part of the problem. It should be relatively straightforward for someone who isn't a full-time email server administrator to setup a mail server correctly, but it's not. At least, it wasn't easy last time I tried it with Postfix and (iirc) Courier on Ubuntu. All the cryptography options are disabled by default and you have to spend a lot of time figuring out which ones should be turned on, where to stick the certificate files and how they should be formatted, how to get Courier and Postfix to talk to each other, etc...

Maybe there's an easy solution (besides "pay someone a monthly fee to manage this all for me") that I'm oblivious to, but it seemed like I was on a well-travelled path and it was a lot harder than it should have been.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by techsupporter on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:46PM (#11069444)
If it helps, I recently rebuilt my mail server and changed from FreeBSD+qmail+Courier to Ubuntu+Postfix+Dovecot. In doing so, I used this series from Ars Technica:

http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/02/how-to...

It shows how to set up SPF, DKIM, TLS, anti-spam filtering, Sieve, certificate-based authentication (I still haven't figured out how to do this with an iPhone), and so on. The only bolt-on it references but doesn't explore and I actually used is the Z-Push package to implement ActiveSync.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by ejolto on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:33AM (#11071767)
Thanks for the interesting link, I've been curious for a while about running my own email server.

Do you encrypt the email on disk, or are they stored in plain text?

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by qewrffewqwfqew on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:47PM (#11069760)
are you able to mail folks at google/live without going to spam? Genuinely curious.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by techsupporter on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:08PM (#11069869)
Yes. I periodically test with various recipients and mail goes through without a hitch. The only difference I might have versus people starting out fresh is that the domains I host are relatively aged. The newest is two years old and the oldest is nineteen. I also made sure that DNS is set up properly, both forward and reverse, and especially for IPv6.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by qewrffewqwfqew on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:40PM (#11070010)
maybe my sin is hosting at linode - for a new recipient at either of the behemoths, I seem to have 50% chance of going to spam. Thanks for your comment.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by jbclements on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:17AM (#11070890)
I host with linode, and have had generally good results sending mail to gmail. They're definitely not the worst. Granted, I have had SPF enabled for about 10 years.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by Kadin on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:47PM (#11070038)
Most ISPs don't allow inbound (or, often, outbound) connections on port 25, so the number of people who can run mail servers at home is pretty limited. I think even Cox stopped allowing it a while ago, and they were among the most lenient of the big ISPs. (Comcast hasn't allowed it for a while.)

That, I think, is why the distribution managers don't make the default configurations a little more friendly/sane; most users aren't interested in installing a MTA to do anything but local delivery or smarthosting, and the people who are, are probably going to tweak the configs to death anyway, so it's not worth spending the time making it run well and securely straight out of the box.

It wouldn't be too hard to build a "mailserver in a box" with (say) Debian + Postfix + LetsEncrypt + BIND that you could stand up in an hour and be reasonably secure (and I'd be kinda surprised if that doesn't exist in some form already), but I don't know how many people would want it who aren't running mailservers already, and have the capability of doing so.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by dheera on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @08:06PM (#11070111)
So run it on AWS. In general, I think running mail servers off a residential, or even business ISP is very sketchy. E-mail is my primary line of communication for important matters, and I can't afford to have a snowstorm, busted hard drive, orange juice spill, or basement flood take out my mail sever.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by icebraining on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:39AM (#11071786)
I don't think it's "sketchy" to have different requirements. For my personal needs, email is definitively important, but it doesn't need HA, and its store-and-forward architecture means it copes fine with an hour or six of downtime (serves usually retry for several days until giving up).
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by amichal on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @08:29PM (#11070195)
Ec2 blocks/throttles outgoing smtp
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by _cudgel on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @09:32PM (#11070399)
EC2 blocks/throttles outgoing SMTP by default.

As with so many things in AWS, it's left up to the customer to inform AWS that a) you're running a mail server, b) what the purpose/use case is and c) request they configure the reverse lookup associated with the elastic IP you've allocated.

Source: I've been running public facing SMTP servers in EC2 for years with no issues.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by brongondwana on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:22PM (#11070559)
AWS also has an outbound SMTP service you can use:

https://aws.amazon.com/ses/faqs/

Still, unless you're running a server for a lot of people and you have tons of free time, you'll discover that it's more expensive than paying any of a bunch of people to take care of email for you.

Source: I work at FastMail

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by _cudgel on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @03:53PM (#11075888)
You're absolutely correct. The cost of my AWS deployment in service of my personal email, and less than 5 other people comes in at ~$5.06/mo. The time, however, is the real cost. If/when I gain significant users, Fastmail would be at the top of my list of companies to consider.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by Johnny555 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:02AM (#11071015)
If you make hard things easy to do, then people that don't know what they are doing will do it (poorly). They'll set up a server once, and never maintain or update it and it'll eventually be hacked and taken over by spammers. I set up and maintain our mail servers and work, and for my personal email, I chose to point my domain to Gmail to let Google take care of it, I don't want to expend the effort it takes to run my own mail server.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by ams6110 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:26PM (#11069653)
Have a look at opensmtpd. Easiest-to-configure mail server I've ever used.

https://www.opensmtpd.org/

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by xrstf on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:18PM (#11069922)
I tried it on Ubuntu 14.04, but unfortunately you get only pretty old versions, even via PPA. And no matter what I did, opensmtpd crashed each time it received a mail from localhost to a local receiver.

I'm having high hopes for Ubuntu 16.04 having a more recent version on board. Then I will try to switch from postfix again. Because as you've said, it's really straightforward to set up :)

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by hueving on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:46PM (#11069030)
>Now I can just get a free cert and turn on TLS. What's the problem, exactly?

Certs weren't free for business use until let's encrypt.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by linkregister on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:27PM (#11069321)
Long before Let's Encrypt, SMTP transactions with STARTTLS have permitted self-signed and non-root-CA chained certificates.

The pervasiveness of self-signed certificates for SMTP servers means that rejecting them would drop large amounts of email. STARTTLS is basically useful for thwarting passive collection of network traffic.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by makomk on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:54PM (#11069786)
Gmail's new rules on unencrypted e-mail don't support self-signed certificates though - you have to use an offcial CA-issued certificate from one of Google's approved CAs.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by jbclements on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:19AM (#11070894)
I'm not so sure about that; I use a self-signed cert for port 25 TLS, and I just sent from google to my domain, and didn't see a warning.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:13PM (#11069903)
What's your source for that?
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by technion on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:47PM (#11070817)
That doesn't bring a lot of extra security though, because there's no name verification. I can get a valid letsencrypt cert on anyrandomdomain.com, and if I can hijack your MX and point at it, it's "valid".
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by hueving on Saturday February 13, 2016 @09:01PM (#11096773)
What? How can you get a cert for a domain you don't control?
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by technion on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @08:41PM (#11114548)
I don't need to control your domain. If I control my own domain, which could be any throwaway domain I just purchased, I can get an SSL certificate on it.

And if I can point your MX records there, via hijack or any other means, then I have a valid SSL certificate for receiving your email.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by joshschreuder on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:52PM (#11069071)
That's kind of the point. They weren't but now are, and now there's even less of an excuse not to have a cert.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by dsp1234 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:00PM (#11069129)
Is it possible to get a Let's Encrypt certificate without a public facing website (which is unrelated to wanted to run a mail server)?
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by tokenizerrr on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:06PM (#11069175)
Yes, they recently enabled the DNS validation. Otherwise, it wants to use a webserver to validate ownership. It can spin up an embedded webserver if you don't have one already.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:19PM (#11069931)
I would say the opposite: There is no excuse for cementing the role of CAs for SMTP. DANE doesn't need any CA, and there is no problem with legacy clients that require CA-signed certs.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by bigiain on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:26PM (#11069952)
It's been a long time since the cost of a cert was an inhibiting factor - at least for 1st world businesses. (I don't suppose I'd want to be paying for a US dollar priced TLS cert in Zambian kwacha or trying to get a petty cash reimbursement for one on a typical IT salary in South Sudan...)
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by nly on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:11PM (#11069208)
WoSign never seemed to care.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by pera on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:23PM (#11069301)
My first concern is, if nowadays is so easy to get your certs signed by a CA how can "Authenticated/Encrypted" emails successfully prevent phishing attacks? In my modest opinion there are many week points in X.509 and how CAs are verifying identities, and even if this things were fixed you still have the problem of state-sponsored attacks that have no solution within the current www pki. I personally have no problem if Google wants to add some icon in the UI, but I share OP's concerns.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by caf on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @08:33PM (#11070208)
The use of TLS (which is what uses a CA-issued certificate) isn't to prevent phishing attacks, it's to prevent emails being read or modified in transit.

DKIM (which does not use a CA-issued certificate, it uses a public key published in DNS) is the technology that's intended to authenticate the email sender. It still wouldn't stop phishing attacks where the purported email sender is something like "[email protected]" though, and I don't know that there really is a good technical solution to that sort of thing.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by lucaspiller on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:16AM (#11071048)
> to prevent emails being read or modified in transit

Except everything you send and receive with your Gmail account is read by them and whatever government agencies anyway... So what's the point?

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by wdewind on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:07PM (#11068783)
Just to play devil's advocate: the vast majority of (even technical) people have no interest in running a mail server. Who should Google optimize for?
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by vonklaus on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:21PM (#11068874)
The question is Who does google optimize for?

As a publicly traded company, it optimizes for GOOG. I have nothing against google, but I do think there is not enough skepticism our fear about them eating the whole stack.

* Receive gmail link from friend. * Use Chrome Browser as gateway to internet. * Use DNS to resolve that URL. * Site built on Angular and has new SPDY tags. * Libraries and Fonts served from CDN.

see something unclear at the url.

* use google search to find that link * google analytics beacons on both websites report your traffic.

I am concerned about the temptation for google to get up to something naughty. Luckily, as we now, it is an undisputed fact that our data is 100% safe with google and there are no organizations trying to actively attack their network or intercede. We also know, that compromising an individual (either an employee or a customer of google) is 100% impossible, never has happened, and never conceivably could happen. So it isn't a big deal.

So, is the issue you can't run a mailserver? Maybe. Maybe not.

You can't crawl many valuable sites now, unless you are google bot or a big vendor.

2 (3 if we count microsoft) companies can ban you from competing on mobile.

etc.

The slight losses in some areas to optimize for what google wants are small. In aggregate, they are wildly irresponsible for us to accept and we shoudlnt.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by bluecmd on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:14PM (#11069225)
> As a publicly traded company, it optimizes for GOOG.

False. The voting stock are not traded, so the founders still have irrevocable rights to do whatever they please.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by vonklaus on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:00PM (#11069833)
I meant that the company does what is in its own best interest. It does publicly trade stock with voting rights as GOOGL which has a 1:1 share to vote. It does not allow the class B stock to trade publicly which is 1:10.

I meant, and you correctly pointed out was not clear or a particularly good way to verbalize, that google like most companies does what is best for itself. In googles case this is a combination of maximizing shareholder value and the vision various thoughtleaders in the company have.

I do not believe google is evil or bad.

I used to believe this.

I now believe that google is doing a lot of great things. However by achieving horizontal success in almost every area of such a powerful concept, it effects how the landscape develops and does cause many issues.

Even if we accept google is mostly good, and I mostly do, it is concerning. I hope that their voluntary meta structure will allow them to distribute fault tolerance and limit power consolidation.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by joshstrange on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:13PM (#11068810)
Couldn't agree more. I run a number of my own services on my own servers but email is not one of them. I don't have the time or energy to keep up with it and it's imperative that I receive all emails sent to me and all my sent emails are received. Google apps does that perfectly for me and I don't have to worry about it.

As far as "I take issue with Google making the decision that everyone is going to switch, now and with out sufficient warning." it would be nice to get some notice on these changes no doubt but email is shit. It just is but we are stuck with it and at least google is attempting to drag it forward even if in doing so they leave some outdated servers/services behind. I'll take more secure of infinitely backwards compatible any day.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by vonklaus on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:26PM (#11068903)
To play devil's advocate, why is email shit? It is pretty much a way to send someone a document in the original way Berners Lee defined html which was essentially sgml. I get not letting people mail active scripts, but every large mail provider also makes a browser.

So email is shitty because providers fuck with it at the mailserver level (i think this is the case, and have heard that about providers) as it doesn't seem to be a problem at the view level.

So this is sort of the issue. We couldn't get consensus on this early on, so no one was able to force standardization, now only a few players have the ability to define standards but they all own large scale messaging channels outside of email.

edit: meant to say that browsers obviously view html and css3 is pretty good as well. We could probably standardize this enough to allow people to write emails in this format and embed imagery. We would not allow JS for obvious reasons, but sending cool emails would be fun and we could also add new features. I mean, the web has developed somewhat shittily, but adding a few new features outside of like the 16 original tags would be cool. Not sure what percentage of tags and attributes actually work, but then again, no one is...

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by striking on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:54PM (#11069489)
Email is also far less instantaneous and is locked into a single kind of infrastructure. It's useful for only one thing.

I don't think it needs to be changed, really. It will stay this useful forever, probably.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by Johnny555 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:16AM (#11071050)
"locked into a single kind of infrastructure"

What does that mean? A mail server can be a small perl script running on an embedded computer, or it can be a hundred front-end SMTP servers using a database as a back end datastore, there's no real infrastructure limit other than being able to make and receive connections on TCP port 25.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by striking on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:44AM (#11073024)
You can't add in-message active content, though. (At least not without some serious hacks, like that thing LinkedIn did.)
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by VikingCoder on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @04:09PM (#11068795)
Their users are suffering because of phishing.

Measurably.

And as to "sufficient warning," sure, I can see that it would be nice to have given people like you more lead time. But then again, "GMail has always supported encryption in transit using TLS," and if you care about running your own email server, it feels to me like the writing has been on the wall for that one for a long time.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by jms703 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:30PM (#11069332)
> Google has been making it harder and harder to run your own

insecure mail server

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by wzdd on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:04PM (#11069850)
This is not entirely true. Gmail (and other big email providers) blacklist blocks of IP addresses belonging to hosting providers who are perhaps not as proactive as they should be at detecting and removing spammers. If you unwittingly sign up at one of these providers, it doesn't matter how perfect your mail configuration is: anything you send to a gmail address is gonna go to spam. Gmail of course doesn't publish these lists, so the only way to find out about them is to run into one.

I understand gmail's problem, and I don't have a better solution, but it's not just about insecure mail servers.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by fungi on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @07:01PM (#11069835)
You can tick every box securing your email server and still get rejected or flagged as spam.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by collinmanderson on Thursday February 11, 2016 @08:43AM (#11080024)
If you run your own postfix server, the first part is as easy as setting smtp_tls_security_level = may. You don't need to certificate or anything.

The DKIM authentication just requires a self-signed certificate. It doesn't need to be signed by a CA, I believe.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by jankins on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:24AM (#11070907)
I disagree - I run a personal mail server and dkim+spf just took a little bit of research to set up, so I'm very glad this brought them to my attention because I want to do what I can to make my emails trustworthy.

If there are any potential downsides to these things I'm interested to hear them, but it seems like they're generally agreed good practices, and hosting your own mail means you're signing up for some ongoing learning and maintenance anyway.

Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by 746F7475 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:12AM (#11071037)
Maybe I'm in an odd position, but is email really such a big communication tool? I mean sure in business world, but for that companies have their own email servers anyway. I only receive email from 2FA-things and order confirmations/paypal recipes. I hardly ever actually send anything from Gmail or receive anything from actual people. All my communication with actual people is either through apps like Signal or WhatsApp or through IM like IRC
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by treenyc on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:49AM (#11072101)
Main complain to Google or other big company. Stop putting email in spam that doesn't have reverse DNS set. Why should one IP be tight to one email domain?
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted by rphlx on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:59AM (#11074102)
Well, it would be much worse if they refused to implement those enhancements, or tried to force proprietary or gmail-specific alternatives.

They pretty much had to do something to improve e-mail's abysmal confidentiality and authenticity, and at least they used open technologies which can be configured on a Debian VPS in a couple of hours using a HOWTO.