Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted
by lmm on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:57PM
(#11069512)
No, best practices are to avoid using any of that and trusting anyone's servers. S/MIME if you trust the CA system, PGP if you don't. Supporting either of those would be a real step forward for privacy - but of course if Google can't snoop on your email then it's not helping them target their ads.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted
by packetslave on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @06:05PM
(#11069550)
but of course if Google can't snoop on your email then it's not helping them offer you a high-quality email service for free by showing you (hopefully) relevant and unobtrusive ads
Fixed that for you.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted
by mynameisvlad on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:22PM
(#11069291)
> These aren't requirements
Well, except they are. Before, yes, they were just best practices. It was great if you had them but by no means required and didn't really impact your experience much if at all. With this switch, though, they became requirements to getting a "normal" experience in Gmail. Even having a warning is a degraded experience at this point.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted
by chii on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:53PM
(#11069483)
I don't think there's anything wrong with gmail upping the game. It's not like they are using tech that no one else can get.
If I ran a restaurant that provided extra services, that doesn't stop anyone else from opening a restaurant and provide similar levels of service.
Re:Gmail Will Warn If Message Is Not Authenticated/Encrypted
by abalos on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:47PM
(#11069448)
I'd actually consider that an improved experience. Sure, the sender using the improperly created personal mailbox will be inconvenienced if people ask about it. However, the actual user of gmail benefits from this.
Without SPF/DKIM you can't be authenticated. Google is showing the user that they cannot verify the sender.
Without TLS email is sent in the clear. Google is showing the user that sensitive information will be visible when sent over the network.
You can run your server fine without this, but users will be warned that you're not following best practices.
It is not Gmail's fault that you're late to best practices.