News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by hackerboos on Thursday February 04, 2016 @11:45PM (#11039516)
When I read about sales taxes and arbitrary taxes on commodities I think just like you have said.

If he wants a tax that doesn't hit consumers he should just raise federal corporate taxes.

In fact, removing subsidies would be a good start.

Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by wildmusings on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:11AM (#11039622)
Corporate tax is a political sham, a sleight of hand by politicians to make taxes more palatable to voters. There is no such thing as a tax on corporations that's not a tax on people. Corporate income is either paid out as salaries or dividends, or spent on purchasing goods from other firms (so eventually only dividends and salaries). Taxing corporations means reducing salaries and reducing dividends.

The corporate tax also benefits big firms with overseas offices and armies of tax accountants and lawyers, at the expense of small and medium sized businesses that can't afford to play the tax avoidance game.

We should eliminate the corporate tax. Make it revenue neutral with equivalent small bumps in the income tax. But it actually doesn't generate much revenue to begin with, more evidence that it's not worth the trouble.

Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by hackerboos on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:17AM (#11039648)
It's 11% of the federal budget [1]. We'd be talking about a steep rise on payroll and income taxes to replace it.

It would actually be a lot more than 11% if it wasn't for avoidance by multinationals like Apple.

[1] - http://www.cbpp.org/sites/default/files/thumbnails/image/pol...

Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by lowpro on Friday February 05, 2016 @01:00AM (#11039808)
Apple is a primary example of his point... If corporate tax isn't eliminated or reduced, will Apple ever put that cash to good use? No! It doesn't want to lose billions, so it'd rather the money sit there then lose it. Removing the tax in that case would stimulate the economy with billions of dollars in new private capital (without devaluing the money already out there [printing money]).
Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by mc808 on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:59AM (#11039806)
Cutting the federal budget 11% would throw us all the way back to 2014 levels. I don't know if the system could handle that kind of shock.
Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by wildmusings on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:19AM (#11039664)
When you compare it to the income tax, that's not a big percent. The corporate tax is equivalent to an income tax on people, but with the strange property that it distributes the burden between the classes (shareholders vs employees, though there is a lot overlap) through the market instead of by law. Depending on the situation in a particular firm, the burden might be wholly on employees or wholly on shareholders, but probably somewhere in-between. This is all ignoring that some of the burden could be shifted to consumers too, depending on how competitive the market is and what the margins are.

As I said, you would raise the income tax on the middle to high brackets to offset abolishing the corporate tax. You'd be taxing the same people, for the same money, with much less hassle for everyone.

What does the corporate tax accomplish that an equivalently higher income tax does not? It's the same money.

Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by adventured on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:22AM (#11039675)
It would of course be far better than that. The low corporate tax rate would attract vast numbers of relocations. Companies like Pfizer would stop fleeing the US; major corporations in other nations would relocate.
Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by wildmusings on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:55AM (#11039789)
It's really sad that our politics is so dysfunctional that we'd rather hold on to this harmful fiction of a tax, just so some politician can play people against each other, than make common sense reforms that wouldn't even change the total tax level.
Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by mozumder on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:04AM (#11039582)
A tax on consumers is fine if it's used to guide people away from consumption of that product. We do that for Tobacco, for example.

The less oil the world uses, the better.

Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by hackerboos on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:18AM (#11039660)
You don't need cigarettes. You do need energy.
Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by ant6n on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:46AM (#11039763)
oil !=== energy
Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by Jwilkinson on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:11AM (#11039625)
Removing subsidies would be a huge start.
Re:Obama wants to tax oil companies $10 a barrel to pay for ... by prostoalex on Friday February 05, 2016 @02:53AM (#11040178)
Would that include the subsidies for solar rooftop installations, wind energy projects and electric vehicles?

Problem with that approach is that you quickly get into "subsidies I like" and "subsidies I dislike" territory.