News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by onetwotree on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:28PM (#11030372)
The Green Bay packers have an interesting approach to this problem, although it requires a fanatical fan base and special ownership provisions, and the fact that the team can't leave Green Bay (without a vote by the shareholders, who are all fans, which will never, ever, happen).

When they want to improve their stadium, they issue stock and sell more season tickets. This works because Packers stock cannot be sold or traded after purchase, and a season ticket is, for many working class Wisconsin families, an heirloom. A friend who's a Wisconsin native was put on the waiting list for season tickets at birth, and is in his parents' will to inherit his mother's ticket. His mom is probably going to die before he breaks 10,000th on the list, so that position will go to his kids. It's insane like that.

But it means that the taxpayers of Wisconsin, including those of us who, like myself, could really care less about football, don't have to foot the bill for maintenance and improvements to the Packers' stadium. But again, the Packers have a uniquely fanatical fan base, were created with provisions to keep them in Green Bay forever, and are owned by the fans.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by nhebb on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:41PM (#11030464)
The NFL changed the ownership rules, and the Green Bay model cannot be repeated elsewhere.

"The NFL does not allow corporate membership. Instead, it requires clubs to be wholly owned either by a single owner, or small group of owners, and requires that at least one owner owns a 1/3 stake in the team. The Packers are granted an exemption to this rule, as they have been a publicly owned corporation since before the rule was in place."

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Bay_Packers_Board_of_Dir...

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by nostrademons on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:09PM (#11030662)
Apparently the limit is now 5% per individual, 30% per family, and stakes can be owned by irrevocable family trusts:

http://www.sportsbusinessdaily.com/Journal/Issues/2015/05/25...

The loophole-finder in me wonders if it would be possible to create "The Mitochondrial Eve Family Trust", for all descendants of mitochondrial Eve, by invitation only. Assets could then be contributed into this trust in exchange for season tickets to a football team, and the trust would own the team. Additional restrictions (eg. X generations of residency in a certain metropolitan area) might apply.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by curun1r on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:23PM (#11031781)
If you're trying to game the system, why try to create a definition for family when one already exists that serves your purpose?

Just have your team be owned by the Hominidae family.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jaggederest on Thursday February 04, 2016 @02:59AM (#11032615)
Then you'll have bonobos showing up and claiming their percentage.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by MagnumOpus on Thursday February 04, 2016 @07:39AM (#11033566)
Well if they do claim it, who are we to deny them?
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by twic on Saturday February 06, 2016 @07:41PM (#11050882)
Hmm. Those guys can be pretty unruly when they're in crowds.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jonathankoren on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:56PM (#11030932)
As a Green Bay Packer Shareholder, there's a lot wrong with your idea. As per the 2011 Offering Document[1]:

1) The limit isn't 5% per individual, 30% per family. It's 200 shares. Total.

2) Shares can only be transferred to immediate family, defined as "the spouse, children, mother, father, brothers, sisters, or any lineal descendant of a shareholder". An improper transfer will give the Corporation the right to purchase the shares at 2 .5 cents per share.

3) "As is the case with holders of Outstanding Shares, a purchaser of Common Stock in the Offering will not receive any Packers merchandise, through the purchase of Common Stock. However, purchasers will play a key role in facilitating the continued viability of a professional football team in Green Bay and will have the opportunity to have a voice in the Corporation’s governance. In addition, shareholders will receive an invitation to the Corporation’s annual meeting and have the opportunity to purchase exclusive shareholder merchandise."[1]

Or in the words of Tom from "Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels", "You get a gold plated Rolls-Royce, as long as you pay for it."

So what do you get? A piece of paper. The right to vote. The ability to purchase specially branded merchandise. It's not even really a fan club.

[1] http://media.broadridge.com/documents/GBP+2011+Offering+Docu...

[2] http://blogs.wsj.com/totalreturn/2012/01/13/are-the-green-ba...

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jacalata on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @11:39PM (#11032029)
He was talking about the rules for other teams (pointing out that the minimum stake has gone down from 30% to 5%, apparently). The Green Bay model is explicitly banned for every other team.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by ableal on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:28PM (#11030782)
Clever, but probably some spoilsport judge would frown at families with 7 billion members.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:02PM (#11031700)
It wouldn't make sense to consider family lineage from before the team existed. That alone limits how much you can expand the pool of eligible shareholders.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by sandworm101 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:45PM (#11031845)
It depends on the state. Some still have rules against eternal trusts (google "rule against perpetuities") but the trend is now towards the supernatural. So it might fly as an Alaska trust.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by scoofy on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:54PM (#11030547)
That seems extremely anti-competitive. I wonder if that rule could be challenged.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by tamana on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:03PM (#11030614)
It's a League. The entire reason for its existence is to be anticompetitive (in business).
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by baddox on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:06PM (#11030634)
Yes. Note the idiom "in league with."
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by rst on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:04PM (#11030618)
The NFL got Congress to write them a specific exemption in the anti-trust laws, so it's very, very doubtful.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by thaumasiotes on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:24PM (#11030758)
I've heard about an exemption for baseball, although that came from judicial corruption rather than being a legislative effort. Confirm that there's a specific legislative exemption for football too?
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jsprogrammer on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:38PM (#11030829)
[1] 15 U.S. Code § 1291 - Exemption from antitrust laws of agreements covering the telecasting of sports contests and the combining of professional football leagues

[2] 26 U.S. Code § 501 - Exemption from tax on corporations, certain trusts, etc.

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1291

[2] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/501

There are also a few more places the Code references football: https://www.law.cornell.edu/search/site/football?f[0]=bundle...

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by HelloMcFly on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:57PM (#11030936)
Football and baseball are not equivalently exempt. Baseball enjoys far broader exemption. The NFL does have some conditional exemptions, but not in the same scope [1]. Recently, the US Supreme Court said exactly as much [2] in a very specific scenario.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law#Sc...

[2] https://www.oyez.org/cases/2009/08-661

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:02PM (#11030607)
Private company, go start yer own football league if you don't like it, etc.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by douche on Thursday February 04, 2016 @04:35AM (#11032874)
It's been tried a few times... Probably the best challenge was the USFL, but they couldn't make a go of it over the long term, and that was when the NFL media machine was much less entrenched. The ESPN 30 for 30 film "Small Potatoes: Who Killed The USFL?" is pretty interesting (especially given that Trump was a key player in that drama)[1]

[1] http://espn.go.com/30for30/film?page=small-potatoes-who-kill...

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by rickycook on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:36PM (#11030824)
that's a pretty horrendous way to change what's morally wrong with the world
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by TheGRS on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @07:24PM (#11031066)
The alternative is to change a majority of people's minds that this is something morally wrong with the world, make cases to supreme court and/or lobby congress and eventually turn the tide in your favor. Not really sure which way is easier.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @07:44PM (#11031147)
I was mocking it not endorsing it.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by bluejekyll on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @11:06PM (#11031915)
XFL
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by michaelbuddy on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:11PM (#11030671)
non profit with tax breaks you mean
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by tamana on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:17PM (#11030710)
Any industry can form a similar nonprofit trade association. The members pay tax.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:12PM (#11030680)
When it's convenient, yup, doing a public service, keeping kids off drugs, stuff like that.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jonathankoren on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:57PM (#11030937)
The Green Bay Packers are a non-profit corporation in a private sports league. Business competition within a league is prima facie absurd.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by frandroid on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:01PM (#11030596)
A team's fans could form a corporation which would be a single owner, but I'm sure the NFL would find a way around that pronto.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by function_seven on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:04PM (#11030623)
That's what the NFL rule specifically prevents. They require a single human owner, or a small group where one of the humans has at least a 1/3 stake.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by maxxxxx on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:15PM (#11030696)
The first thing I'd do is to take away the tax exempt status of the NFL.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by nols on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:23PM (#11030750)
The NFL gave up nonprofit status last year, and its status as one was a bit of a misunderstanding. All the teams (except the Packers) were taxed for-profits, as was the merchandising, TV deals, etc. Basically all the revenue streams were already taxed, and now that they're not non-profit the NFL can be a lot more opaque about its finances.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by tosseraccount on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:20PM (#11030735)
Didn't this already happen?

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/04/28/nfl-tax-exempt-stat... NFL Voluntarily Ends Tax-Exempt Status

"Beginning with the 2015 fiscal year, the NFL's league office and management council will file tax returns as taxable entities."

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by gozur88 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:43PM (#11030863)
I don't think it will matter. The NFL doesn't make money - the teams make money.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by ripberge on Thursday February 04, 2016 @02:16AM (#11032507)
Not true. Roger Goodell made $44 million in 2013. Kind of shocking you can do that and still be considered a non profit.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by chiph on Thursday February 04, 2016 @09:40AM (#11034139)
Non-profits can still pay their employees & managers well (very well, in this case).
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by teej on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:18PM (#11030719)
The NFL is already planning to do this. Besides, the teams pay tax.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by Bricejm on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:41PM (#11030458)
Most was actually covered by a sales tax: http://www.greenbaypressgazette.com/story/money/2015/09/29/l...
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by voidlogic on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:33PM (#11030410)
>without a vote by the shareholders, who are all fans

Doesn't the German football team system work like this too? I think it at least does for Bayern.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by sehr on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:43PM (#11030481)
Yep! The club/members have to own >50% of the club to compete in the German pro leagues

In the past, private ownership wasn't even allowed but that changed in the 90s.

Even cooler, the 2 largest football clubs on earth, Real Madrid & Barcelona are completely fan owned. They even vote for the presidency of the club! So refreshing compared to American sports, though without a salary cap their competitions are 1000x more predictable & boring. (ex. RM won their league match on Sunday 6-0, and Barca just won today 7-0)

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by tragic on Thursday February 04, 2016 @03:43AM (#11032722)
I guess the biggest difference is that, in European soccer (especially in lovely England), the clubs are vastly more powerful than the leagues and governing bodies of the sport. In the NFL, NBA etc, the opposite seems to be the case - the teams are more like suppliers to the league.

Both systems, to put it mildly, have their warts.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by tosseraccount on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:26PM (#11030773)
Clarification: The corporate structure of the Green Bay Packers is shrouded in a mystery that would make a venture funded Silicon Valley company blush.

There are are multiple classes of stock. The later issued ones are indeed basically paper trinkets bought by rabid "cheese heads" so they could claim "ownership".

There is apparently no reason the owners of the few voting shares couldn't change the bylaws.

Rumor is that the NFL had to step in the 1980s (90s ?) and force the Packer owners to run a better shop (and stop paying themselves dividends). Same rumor mill reports they had to step in and force the New York Giants (who were paralyzed by two incompetent owners that owned 50% each) to run a better ship.

Note that this intervention turned around the fortunes these two teams which had earned reputations for gridiron incompetence. Miracle in the Meadowlands? Bart Starr coach?

Both the Packers and Giants have been very competitive, well run franchises since.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by cafard on Thursday February 04, 2016 @10:22AM (#11034456)
Don't know about the Packers, but the league definitely intervened with the Giants. One of the Maras sold out to the Tisches, the other one is is still there.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by stevefeinstein on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:39PM (#11030445)
Well, it's a good thing they've locked in a team, because no one in their right mind would build one in Green Bay Wisconsin today when there are fools in warmer climates literally throwing money at anyone who will move a team.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jkaunisv1 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @08:05PM (#11031245)
NFL disruption tactic: calculate sites of new major cities based on projected global temperatures, ice cap melt and rising water changing coastlines; start minor league in those cities. Wait.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by rsync on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:43PM (#11030864)
They are just finishing the new stadium in Minneapolis, which is colder, on average, than green bay[1] ...

[1] average low temp in MPLS, in January, is 8F, as compared to 9F in Green Bay.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jessaustin on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @07:37PM (#11031115)
That stadium is a heated dome.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by rsync on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:47PM (#11031638)
... unfortunately.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by ec109685 on Thursday February 04, 2016 @12:59AM (#11032301)
How do you sell more season tickets to raise money? There are only so many seats and like you said, ticket rights are passed down from generation to generation. And like other folks said, there is a sales tax.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by fluxquanta on Thursday February 04, 2016 @11:24AM (#11034998)
Green Bay may be off the hook for NFL stadium costs, but Wisconsin's still paying at least a quarter of a billion dollars for the new Bucks arena.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by FussyZeus on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:53PM (#11030537)
I'm glad there are other Wisconsinites who don't give a shit about football. HELLO FRIEND

That said, those of us in Brown County still got stuck with a 0.5% tax hike to pay for the stadium on sales tax, which I wouldn't mind so much except it stuck around about 4 years longer than it was supposed to.

Being a resident close by I can attest to what the evidence says: The argument that stadiums augment the local economy is hoo-hah. The area around the stadium is more built up, sure, and plenty of businesses do well there but the vast majority of the money goes right into the Stadium and of course the NFL, the only exceptions being the local motels (which can't be doing that well, they all look like slum housing).

Honestly I'd pay the 0.5% tax hike forever if we got rid of the stupid thing and stopped locking up the Green Bay metro area every Sunday.

Edit: For the record, it's not the amount of the tax hike, I realize I'm bitching over pennies. It's the principle that I'm subsidizing an industry that makes so much fucking money they have no business getting tax breaks on toilet paper, let alone facilities like Lambeau Field.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by tamana on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:19PM (#11030725)
How much tax does Packer County pay?
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by anon4 on Thursday February 04, 2016 @12:51PM (#11035710)
> could really care less

Annnd that's a downvote. This community prides itself on good, honest discourse and high-level language. Please don't bring us down to the level of a 7-year-old redneck.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by dang on Thursday February 04, 2016 @02:15PM (#11036392)
As far as I'm concerned this community could care less about people using idiomatic English, but we care a lot about personal rudeness in comments. Please don't do this again.

If you think a comment is bad for Hacker News, you're welcome to flag it, but not to post abusive noise.