News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @09:51PM (#11024456)
> Hollywood thinks they have money and power...until an Apple, or Google, or Amazon comes along and shows them what real economic clout looks like.

Something I read once stuck with me. I don't remember the exact wording, but basically the movie industry's entire market, soup to nuts, is an order of magnitude less than just one of Disney's physical goods departments.

An entire industry's market doesn't even hold a candle to one company's department. Hollywood is stranger than you could ever know. It makes a pitiful amount of money in relation to global capitalism, always has, always will. But it wields outsized influence on American policymaking regardless.

Another quote comes to mind. When Apple released the Watch, someone asked one of the top watch companies if they were worried about Apple butting into their market. He just smiled and said something to the effect of, "Call me when they can figure out how to get men to wear diamonds on anything other than a watch."

Established industries have spent long, long periods of time getting to know their customer. More often than not, they can take any upstart's best efforts and treat it as outsourced R&D. Netflix and Apple can succeed to their hearts content and still not have a prayer of unseating Hollywood.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by bluejekyll on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @10:59PM (#11024658)
It's interesting to think about this, as what it really means is that Hollywood is basically advertising for physical sales.

Transformers the show was produced to sell Transformers the toys. The toys came first.

So will Amazon only pick up shows that encourage people to buy more stuff? They'll have big data to back up what types of content actually encourage that. Similarly, when will Netflix get into physical sales? Options like buy 'that thing' you just saw in 'that show', etc.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by SyneRyder on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @04:11AM (#11025531)
You might be fascinated by the 1957 Disney Business Model diagram sent to investors:

https://hbr.org/2013/05/what-makes-a-good-corporate-st

It shows exactly this, but also states that physical sales in turn become ads for their movies. Literal quote: "Music: keeps films in mind when they're out of circulation." Let It Go must be a gold mine: content for the movie, a top 10 hit song, and an ad for Frozen DVDs & toys every time a little kid annoyingly runs around singing it.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by toyg on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @02:46AM (#11025286)
Dude, most most shows and movies are already in the product-placement business. Bond movies are feature-long multi-ads. Sitcoms live on beer shots. Any sf/fantasy feature post-StarWars gets made by selling merchandise contracts before production even starts.

I don't think Amazon or Netflix will change anything there, it has been a reality for more than 20 years now.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by bluejekyll on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:36AM (#11026612)
Sure. It's the original TV soap model. I guess what's more interesting in this context is the potential that Amazon and/or Netflix have in directly mapping shows to sales.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by oldmanjay on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @10:04PM (#11024495)
Total domestic Hollywood box office for 2015 was ~10 billion[0]. Total 2015 revenue for Disney was ~52 billion[1]. Whatever you read, it is no longer correct.

[0] http://www.boxofficemojo.com/yearly/chart/?yr=2015

[1] http://www.statista.com/statistics/224397/quarterly-revenue-...

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by kbenson on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @10:22PM (#11024536)
I'm not sure why you think a department in a company with 52 billion in revenue can't individually have more revenue than an industry with 10 billion in revenue. Specifically, numbers posted seem to indicate there are some divisions with more than 10 billion in revenue[1].

1: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-08-04/disney-pro...

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by oldmanjay on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @10:28PM (#11024549)
52 billion can't contain an order of magnitude more than 10 billion no matter how you do your accounting.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by jaibot on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:07PM (#11024679)
Pedantic: It can if some of the departments are turning in massive losses.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by oh_sigh on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @02:21AM (#11025215)
Revenue can't be negative (without janky accounting which is irrespective of losses).
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by oldmanjay on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:24PM (#11024711)
That's not the case at Disney. I'm not making an abstract point here.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by paulsutter on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @01:49AM (#11025102)
You're not making an abstract point, you're making a minor and pedantic point. The comment said he didn't remember the exact details.

His core idea is true even if he got the details wrong: that whole-industry revenue from movies is much smaller than Disney's overall business. That's an interesting insight.

Your comment might be more useful if you acknowledged his core idea even as you corrected the facts. Instead you appear to be in such a rush to prove you're smart that you totally missed the central point. Just sayin.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by kbenson on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:51PM (#11024769)
Ah, I thought you were responding to this: "An entire industry's market doesn't even hold a candle to one company's department." I missed the order of magnitude statement.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:04PM (#11024671)
As I said, it's been awhile since I read that, I was sure I was misstating it somehow.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by prostoalex on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @12:12AM (#11024831)
It's crazy indeed, there are some numbers in this story http://www.bloomberg.com/features/2015-disney-princess-hasbr... - the toy princess business is $5.5 bln, and it's not even Disney's top line.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by icegreentea on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:07PM (#11024682)
Hollywood has an outsized effect on American policy making because American soft power is partly reliant on the export of American, or America-friendly culture, which is what Hollywood does.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by pjc50 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @07:48AM (#11026156)
Established industries have spent long, long periods of time getting to know their customer

.. and then forgetting about it while wringing the customer for all they are worth. Or failing to notice that their customers are aging and not being replaced by new customers with different tastes.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by Riod on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @10:27PM (#11024545)
On watches, I'd say when you have low cost smartwatches (like what happened with phones), then things might change. Watches might become relegated to being statements for the fashion conscious.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:17PM (#11024702)
> Watches might become relegated to being statements for the fashion conscious.

When have they ever not been? The watch, even back in it's heyday as something you carried around in your pocket, has always been a status-first, function-second fashion accessory. It has always been much, much cheaper to use the established methods of telling time, most villages first infrastructure investment was a town clock, once those became cost-effective to build.

It has only been very recently where it became fashionable for everyone to wear one, and that's only because of cheap electronic watches. Cheap electronic watches had the inevitable effect of whetting appetite for luxury options. Casio was the best thing that ever happened to luxury watch makers.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by Riod on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @12:33AM (#11024891)
Right. And the choice could now be upgrading to a smartwatch from Casio as opposed to a higher end Swatch. Check out Swatch's share price since 2013.

No clue why Europe is the only relevant market you're referencing here. Either way no clue what the market size for town clocks was.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @12:55AM (#11024957)
People upgrading from Casio to Apple are of no concern to higher-end makers like Patek Philippe. Swatch is not a premium watch maker. What Patek and the like might be worried about is people moving from Patek to Apple.

But when you start to think more carefully about that scenario, it's rather ridiculous. People into watches don't just buy one. You don't "switch" brands, you just select a different one for your next purchase. It could be another Patek, perhaps an Audemars Piguet, or even an Apple Watch.

The idea that someone buying these watches would sell them all and buy an Apple Watch, never to own another high-end watch again, is simply absurd.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by SwellJoe on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @02:10AM (#11025174)
"People into watches don't just buy one. You don't "switch" brands, you just select a different one for your next purchase. It could be another Patek, perhaps an Audemars Piguet, or even an Apple Watch."

You're talking about collectors. They already do not represent a significant portion of the current market for high end watches. Sure, wealthy people who like watches probably have one or two "nice" watches. But, people who collect things will never be the majority of a mass market consumer good. There are car collectors with classic cars, that won't save internal combustion engines. There are people who collect old computers, too, but no one is seriously suggesting the Commodore 64 will ever be a mass market product again. People collect dolls, but Barbie doesn't make their millions from sales to collectors; they make their millions from the mass market.

So, you're arguing there will always be classic watch collectors. No problem. I'm sure there will be. Hell, there are still people that knit their own sweaters. Watch collectors will not be common, and they will not represent a multi-billion dollar market.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:50AM (#11027063)
> You're talking about collectors.

No, I'm not. I'm talking about people that buy high-end watches. They're like ties, it doesn't really make sense to own just one. You need one for every occasion, to match all the types of outfits you wear.

It makes sense for you to own just one high-end watch. But the kind of person that can pay $30K for a watch is not you. They are the people that keep Patek Phillipe in business. They made €765.6 million in 2013. The Swiss watch industry as a whole is around $10 billion.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by SwellJoe on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @01:57PM (#11028712)
I wonder how we ended up talking so much about luxury watches in this conversation about Hollywood and the tech industry. I still don't think there's a useful comparison to be made, even if we assume that luxury watches are immune to the same sorts of factors that made fancy hats and canes disappear. It's an impossibly large leap for me to treat Hollywood movies and entertainment as a "luxury good"; there's simply none of the same motivations behind it. It really isn't a status symbol to own a copy of the Criterion Collection on Blu Ray.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by Riod on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @01:57PM (#11028699)
$800MM is a small business and $10BN is a small industry fyi.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @04:39PM (#11029974)
I never said it wasn't. The theme is small, entrenched industries that seem way bigger than they are. Hollywood seems so much bigger than it is because geopolitically, US culture exports are a big contributor to global goodwill.

The watch industry is sheltered by old, old money, patronized by the kind of people who could comfortably buy up the entire industry if they saw the need.

Market logic is a useful thing to grasp, but there are bigger things in the world than markets, and it's really useful to be able to understand how they work. What looks small often isn't. Bigger, better, faster, stronger are not the only rules the world lives by. There exist points at which normal logic upends and irrationality rules.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by Riod on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @03:01AM (#11025315)
Well aware that swatch is not premium. They are however higher end when compared to Casio. Market have different segments. Timex and Casio make up 30% of the market. ~50% of buyers care about value and another 30% care about watches as a symbol. Swatch falls in that 50%. That's a big market segment. That's where smartwatches compete.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by somberi on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:17AM (#11025868)
"... Last year, when consultants from Deloitte surveyed Swiss watch executives, eighty per cent of them indicated that demand was down “due to anti-corruption legislation” in China."

source - http://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/the-kleptocrat-i...

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by saryant on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @10:33PM (#11024562)
Well, yeah. That was the point. Very expensive fashion statements with incredibly high profit margins.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by Riod on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @12:35AM (#11024899)
Not all watchmakers make expensive fashion statements. Market is segmented. Guys beyond Casio (Swatch et al) will/have been affected
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by JackFr on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:14PM (#11024699)
> and still not have a prayer of unseating Hollywood.

That's true, but by the same token television has failed to unseat Hollywood -- millions of people still go to the movies every year. And yet I wouldn't quite describe motion pictures as having 'won'.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by SwellJoe on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @10:01PM (#11024484)
I don't think luxury goods are at all a useful comparison to the various entertainment industries. I would argue entertainment is far closer to what Google/Amazon/Netflix/Apple are doing than it is to what jewelry makers are doing.

And, I think it's too early to tell what'll happen to luxury watch makers. I think that cockiness is not well-founded. I'd be willing to bet that in a few more years, those traditional watches will be as common as cuff links. They'll still exist, but they won't be considered a standard part of people's every day wear, even people who buy and wear luxury goods.

I do agree with you, however, that Hollywood and the entertainment industry wield way more political power than the size of their industry would indicate. They're good at lobbying, and they have a few friends in very high places (like Disney) to fight their battles for them, such as copyright terms, for example.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @11:11PM (#11024694)
> I'd be willing to bet that in a few more years, those traditional watches will be as common as cuff links.

I'm not sure where you're getting this from. Traditional watches have seen way more potential challengers than just the Apple Watch, and managed to survive nonetheless. You can think "yeah, but this time it's different," but try to think of it from the point of view of somebody whose been making and selling watches to people his whole life in an industry that's been making and selling watches for hundreds of years, as part of a company that's probably been around for at least a hundred years itself. These guys know a thing or two about why people buy watches.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by nostrademons on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @02:41AM (#11025271)
The biggest risk to traditional watchmakers isn't the Apple Watch per se, it's the wealth created by the whole tech ecosystem.

Luxury good makers have spent decades getting to know their customers, who are largely wealthy, cultured individuals. It is unlikely those individuals will suddenly switch their preferences to the Apple Watch. It is more likely that those individuals will no longer be wealthy. Over the last 15 years, we've seen a level of wealth instability that's been unprecedented since the Gilded Age, with whole industries disappearing and new fortunes being made.

I don't see the nouveau rich being a big fan of traditional Swiss watches. Most of the millionaires/billionaires I know tend to own Pebbles, actually.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:55AM (#11027103)
The old rich has way more to fear from political upheaval in their home countries than from American tech wealth. There's way way way more old money than there is new. When you look at the grand scheme of things. American tech is tiny. I would not be surprised at all to hear of rich people who've never even heard of Apple.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by SwellJoe on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @12:06AM (#11024821)
But, try to think of it from the point of view of somebody who's been making and selling wagon wheels to people his whole life in an industry that's been making and selling wagon wheels for hundreds of years, as part of a company that's probably been around for at least a hundred years itself. These guys know a thing or two about why people buy wagon wheels.

Sometimes, things change.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @12:45AM (#11024932)
You're completely not getting why technology is different from luxury. Wagon wheels are not and never were a luxury product. People bought them for completely different reasons.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by SwellJoe on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @01:35AM (#11025063)
Beaver skin hats, wool or fur topcoats, previously mentioned cuff links, boned corsets, pocket watches, cravats, wigs...

Traditional watches have had their run. They will disappear, except for hipsters and old people, within a generation.

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by nemothekid on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @02:20AM (#11025212)
>cuff links, boned corsets, pocket watches, cravats, wigs >They will disappear, except for hipsters and old people, within a generation.

The items you mentioned fell out of fashion, so I believe his point still stands. It seems to me, watch makers aren't concerned about smart watches from a utilitarian point of view, but from a fashion point of view (After all most people stopped wearing watches once you could get the time on your phone).

Likewise, if it was just the case that watches simply had to have more functions to upend the market, smartphones would have eradicated traditional watches by now.

Whether or not they are underestimating Apple's ability to create a fashionable digital time piece is one thing, but it looks like watch makers understand that their customers aren't buying their products in order to measure their heart rate (or even check the time).

Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by terryf on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @03:38AM (#11025427)
You don't wear a breitling to tell time. You wear it to tell everyone else that you have money, power and self-confidence. It's essentially jewellery for men. That hasn't gone out of fashion for thousands of years. Pretty sure it never will, either.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by naveen99 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @07:57AM (#11026196)
I can see money. But how does it give you power or confidence independent of money ?
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by Golf_Hotel_Mike on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:14AM (#11026506)
Any aspirational luxury good does that to an extent. I suppose it's all about how people see you and treat you when you wear expensive clothes and Breitlings.
Re:Netflix deals at Sundance don’t make economic sense, they... by colmvp on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @10:37PM (#11024581)
Honestly, it's why I as a POC dislike Hollywood and a lot of Westernized popular media in general. We tend to be under-represented and stereotyped, which can have a subconscious effect on the masses.