News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by carlisle_ on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @02:30PM (#11021815)
The NFL consistently demonstrates such a high level of greed it's astounding. I get it that you don't get rich writing checks, but what happened to doing right by people and the community at large.

Maybe I'm just wishy washy.

Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by randyrand on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @05:55PM (#11023382)
I agree. Nonprofit status is such a scam. The same way with other non-profits like the college I attended.|

Charge different tuition rates based on income. Pretend to 'subzidize' those who make less, in reality just charging you based on your income so they can maximize their endowment (corporate profit).

$6.5B endowment and still pestered the shit out of me for $20.15 upon graduating with debt. I paid it too, cuz otherwise I wasn't allowed to attend one of bigger graduation ceremonies.

Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by oldmanjay on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @04:08PM (#11022612)
In cases like this it's not clear to me which side has the most compelling greed, so I'm always interested in hearing some reasoning about what makes your preferred side in the conflict the right one.
Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by carlisle_ on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @05:24PM (#11023179)
They've offered a sum and refused to negotiate. I think I'd be indifferent otherwise if the NFL had shown they were willing to negotiate and not dictate the value of something that would have immense value if there were an open market.
Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by jedberg on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @02:37PM (#11021864)
> but what happened to doing right by people and the community at large.

That's not really up to the NFL, it's up to the guy who has the tapes being willing to give them away for free. The NFL is basically being extorted here. Sure they have the money, but why should they pay? The value of the tapes is zero, because the only possible buyer isn't interested.

Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by mmanfrin on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @02:45PM (#11021933)

  it's up to the guy who has the tapes being willing to give 
  them away for free
No... that would still be illegal and the NFL could still sue.

'The value of the tapes is zero'; what a weird statement to make. Are the value of illegal drugs zero because 'the only possible buyers' (i.e., no one) can't show interest? There is inherent value in a recording of the first event of a series of events that attracts hundreds of millions of viewers.

Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by dsp1234 on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @03:21PM (#11022198)
would still be illegal and the NFL could still sue.

If he uploaded a copy to youtube as part of a historical article or other non-commercial use, then the fair use analysis would likely go his way. Particularly for something of such cultural and historical relevance.

That said, trying to get money for it is certainly going to count against that analysis.

Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by TillE on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @03:56PM (#11022498)
That's really not how copyright works at all. If the NFL owns the copyright, then distributing it in any way is a blatant violation. There are no relevant fair use exemptions.
Re:Out of a Rare Super Bowl I Recording, a Clash with the N.... by wyldfire on Tuesday February 02, 2016 @04:43PM (#11022915)
No, you're mistaken. Fair Use is for precisely this kind of purpose and protects those who share copyrighted content for educational purposes.

Refer to USC, Title 17, chap 1, § 107

[1] http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#107

Note that "educational purposes" are described, but not "cultural/historical relevance". Up for debate as to whether those intersect here.